Slice Box, Sodo
25 people recommendvia r/Seattle, r/SeattleWA, r/AskSeattle28 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Most commenters recommend Slice Box, and many put it at or near the top of Seattle pizza. Some praise the square Sicilian-style pie, and several say it is the closest local match for New York or East Coast pizza. Some find its limited opening hours hard to work around. Slice Box has more than one outlet; several commenters name the SoDo branch.
Address
Slice Box Pizza, 1727 1st Ave S, Seattle, WA 98134
At a glance
- Signature dishes
- Square Sicilian style pie, Pepperoni pizza
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Slice Box, Sodo, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/spraj in r/Seattle · Nov 2023taste
Lists this among Seattle pizza strong enough to rank in most cities, except possibly New York or New Haven.
- Recommendsu/DYonkers in r/SeattleWA · Apr 2024portion
Loads pepperoni with good flavor and has great thin crust; prefers it over Pagliacci.
- Recommendsu/drgonzo44 in r/Seattle · Mar 2024taste
Judges the Magnolia or Sodo branch the top pizza in town, with a friend's shop a close second.
- Recommendsu/pizzaandicecream3312 in r/AskSeattle · Nov 2026taste
Calls the pizza very good and says the regular and square styles differ; finds the opening hours hard to work with.
- Recommendsu/delicious_things in r/AskSeattle · Nov 2025
Names it among standout local pizza spots in a reply defending the city's pizza scene.
- Recommendsu/Anand999 in r/AskSeattle · Jul 2026
Calls the SoDo branch great, answering the crispy pepperoni question directly.
- Recommendsu/fsck_ in r/Seattle · Mar 2024taste
Says its square pizza beats Queen Margherita and is among the best in Seattle.
- Recommendsu/GrippyCloaca in r/AskSeattle · Nov 2026
Lists it among their picks for slices.
Show all 28 cited comments
- Recommendsu/StoopieHippo in r/Seattle · Jun 2024taste
Says the SoDo location comes closest to their ideal, though a rival has a firmer crust but weaker flavors.
- Recommendsu/blaizedm in r/Seattle · Jun 2024
Agrees with a recommendation for Slicebox and says they fully agree.
- Recommendsu/splanks in r/Seattle · Jan 2026taste
Says Slice Box satisfies the NYC slice craving.
- Recommendsu/Shmokesshweed in r/SeattleWA · Apr 2024
Used to frequent the Sodo location and thinks it's great.
- Mixedu/Nickd86 in r/AskSeattle · Nov 2026
Says it is a favorite spot of theirs too, but finds its hours hard to live with.
- Mixedu/TheNonExample in r/AskSeattle · Jun 2026taste
Calls it their favorite, though its weekday hours are tough for lunch breaks.
- Mixedu/kgberton in r/AskSeattle · Apr 2026variety
Has approximately Neapolitan potato pizza and slices, but slice flavors are American.
- Recommendsu/BoogerTea89 in r/Seattle · Jan 2026taste
Recommends the SoDo location for East Coast-style pizza, calling it the top choice.
- Recommendsu/insom187 in r/AskSeattle · Jun 2026
Strongly endorses it, joking that its open days are limited.
- Recommendsu/good-good-dog in r/AskSeattle · Apr 2026taste
Says it is straight-up New York-style pizza, though they go there often and love the place.
- Recommendsu/Boredbarista in r/SeattleWA · Nov 2025taste
Loves adding the dressed arugula-and-parm topper to their pizza.
- Recommendsu/TaeKurmulti in r/Seattle · May 2025taste
Recommends Slice Box across two outlets and says it matches Dino's on pizza.
- Recommendsu/SlippahThief in r/SeattleWA · Jun 2024taste
Named among the closest local options to a NY slice and considered solid.
- Recommendsu/dlrust in r/SeattleWA · Apr 2024portion
Adds another vote for Slicebox, saying they load up on pepperoni.
- Recommendsu/christofir in r/AskSeattle · Oct 2026taste
Calls it their top East Coast-style pick in Seattle after broad searching; also notes Sicilian slices.
- Recommendsu/TheRealJamesWax in r/AskSeattle · Jun 2026
Hasn't tried it yet, but reports positive word of mouth.
- Recommendsu/BeanSecretCider in r/SeattleWA · Nov 2025
Includes Slice Box in its list of good local pizza spots.
- Recommendsu/JoshInJersey in r/SeattleWA · Jun 2024taste
Praises its Sicilian square pie as the best in Seattle, admitting limited knowledge of others.
- Recommendsu/w4tts in r/Seattle · Jun 2024
Lists Slicebox among its picks for the best pizza.
- Recommendsu/-Linkz- in r/SeattleWA · Oct 2026
Names this SoDo spot as a pizza option, noting limited weekday lunch availability.
More maps in Seattle, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 13 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.