2 Amys, Cathedral Heights
19 people recommendvia r/washingtondc22 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Most people who mention 2 Amys recommend it, and several single out its Neapolitan-style pizza. A few point to it for a meal near the National Cathedral, and one calls it the go-to spot in Cathedral Heights while another calls it the only good option nearby. Caveats: a couple find it costly for what it is, one says the oven can get overcrowded, and one calls it acceptable.
Address
2 Amys, 3715 Macomb St NW Ste 201, Washington, DC 20016
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to 2 Amys, Cathedral Heights, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/ISDM27 in r/washingtondc · Aug 2024taste
Suggests 2Amy's as foodie-grade pizza.
- Mixedu/MrMoustachio55 in r/washingtondc · Mar 2024value
Says Two Amys is better than 90 Second Pizza but not worth paying double.
- Recommendsu/As_I_Lay_Frying in r/washingtondc · Aug 2024
Names Two Amys as a direct answer to the request.
- Recommendsu/N00bivore in r/washingtondc · Oct 2026
Lists 2 Amy's among their favorite spots.
- Recommendsu/Vino_Peregrino in r/washingtondc · Oct 2026value
Suggests splitting a few pizzas there for a group, calling it a genuinely DC-feeling spot.
- Recommendsu/Inside-Beyond-4672 in r/washingtondc · Apr 2025price
Points to 2 Amys as the go-to in Cathedral Heights, though a bit costly.
- Recommendsu/toorigged2fail in r/washingtondc · May 2024taste
Ranks it among the top Neapolitan options.
- Recommendsu/Butinyiko in r/washingtondc · Oct 2026
Describes 2 Amy's as a solid pizza option near the National Cathedral.
Show all 22 cited comments
- Recommendsu/islesandterps in r/washingtondc · Sep 2025taste
Says 2Amys is the better choice, with several other spots comparable.
- Recommendsu/terpfan417 in r/washingtondc · Apr 2025
Agrees it's Neapolitan rather than NY style and calls it the sole good option nearby.
- Recommendsu/Thatdewd57 in r/washingtondc · May 2024
Bare reply naming 2 Amy's as a pick for the pizza question.
- Recommendsu/butterscotches in r/washingtondc · May 2024
Names 2 Amy's in the same bare reply.
- Recommendsu/Emergency_End8437 in r/washingtondc · Sep 2025
Endorses 2Amys with emoji and gives it top billing.
- Recommendsu/lalalalaasdf in r/washingtondc · Aug 2024taste
Suggests 2Amys as a Neapolitan-style place for pizza over jumbo slices.
- Recommendsu/sib9397 in r/washingtondc · Oct 2026taste
Lists 2 Amy's as one of their top picks.
- Mixedu/Kanly_Atreides in r/washingtondc · Apr 2025consistency
Praises it as great Neapolitan, though notes the oven is sometimes overcrowded.
- Mixedu/Timely-Ad-4331 in r/washingtondc · May 2024taste
Calls it acceptable, while saying other places aren't worth the trip.
- Recommendsu/mmeeplechase in r/washingtondc · Oct 2026
Says they've eaten at the first three list places and enjoy all of them.
- Recommendsu/Diligent-Practice-25 in r/washingtondc · Apr 2025
Recommends 2 Amy's as a pizza choice, noting it sits by the National Cathedral, itself worth visiting.
- Recommendsu/Vegetable-Tennis4515 in r/washingtondc · Apr 2025
Recommends it.
- Recommendsu/rockinpetstore in r/washingtondc · Oct 2026
Lists this as a favorite spot to take visiting family.
- Recommendsu/bessann28 in r/washingtondc · Apr 2025
Suggests 2Amys for pizza, and says the nearby National Cathedral is worth visiting.
More maps in Washington DC, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 13 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.