Fourth Man in the Fire
32 people recommendvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO, r/toronto30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 7 threads.
What people say, in short
People recommend Fourth Man in the Fire, and many lists of recommended spots include it. A few diners praise the doughnuts, and one commenter is fond of its mushroom-and-garlic pie. One nearby diner mentions a lunch special that pairs a slice with a doughnut.
Address
The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria, 832 Dundas St W, Toronto, ON M6J 1V3, Canada
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/the-mongoose- in r/FoodToronto · May 2026
Lists it among recommended slice spots.
- Recommendsu/Wonderful-Eggplant47 in r/FoodToronto · Jul 2024
Includes this spot in a list of recommended slice places.
- Recommendsu/danielmaster_ in r/FoodToronto · May 2026
Lists it among recommended spots.
- Recommendsu/LongRoadNorth in r/askTO · Feb 2026
Suggests this spot alongside Lambretta as a good pick.
- Recommendsu/torontowest91 in r/askTO · Jan 2026taste
Says they like this place a lot.
- Recommendsu/gailanisgood in r/askTO · Jan 2026
Likes it too and says its donuts add a nice extra.
- Recommendsu/nvious88 in r/askTO · Feb 2026
Suggests this spot together with Grams.
- Recommendsu/Spirited_Comedian225 in r/toronto · Jul 2025taste
Advises visiting this spot and ordering a cheese slice there.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Recommendsu/singlikerahrah in r/askTO · Jan 2026
Ranks it among their top three picks.
- Recommendsu/TNG6 in r/FoodToronto · Oct 2026
Recommends it.
- Recommendsu/HeartOverall7045 in r/askTO · Feb 2026
Suggests Fourth Man in the Fire.
- Recommendsu/sibtiger in r/askTO · Feb 2026
Lives nearby and finds the place hard to resist.
- Recommendsu/almostcurly in r/askTO · Feb 2026taste
Recommends the restaurant and praises its doughnuts.
- Recommendsu/ink_13 in r/askTO · Feb 2026taste
Says its donuts are good.
- Recommendsu/articulate_pandajr in r/askTO · Feb 2026
Places this spot in a list of pizza places worth trying.
- Recommendsu/VowNyx in r/FoodToronto · Jul 2024
Calls this place a great stop, located near Renaissance and Superpoint.
- Recommendsu/averysleepygirl in r/FoodToronto · Oct 2026taste
Is fond of their mushroom-and-garlic pie and advises lunchtime for donuts, perhaps an apple fritter.
- Recommendsu/Beanstiller in r/askTO · Feb 2026
Adds this spot to a list of recommended pizza places.
- Recommendsu/justleavemebeaight in r/FoodToronto · Oct 2026taste
Really likes the sausage and onion pie and plans to return for the Hawaiian.
- Recommendsu/Due-Lobster-5915 in r/FoodToronto · Oct 2026
Calls it a solid pie.
- Recommendsu/sweatpantsjoe in r/FoodToronto · May 2026
Lists it among good spots.
- Recommendsu/_tax_noob in r/FoodToronto · May 2026
Lists it among recommended slice spots.
- Recommendsu/banned_salmon in r/askTO · Feb 2026
Suggests this spot along with Fresca.
- Recommendsu/radi81 in r/askTO · Feb 2026
Includes this spot in a list of recommended places.
- Recommendsu/Ok-Reference-1384 in r/askTO · Jan 2026
Names it among top picks.
- Recommendsu/goldreceiver in r/askTO · Jan 2026
Lists it among favourite pizza places.
- Recommendsu/kaipee in r/askTO · Jan 2026
Lists it among top picks.
- Recommendsu/richardjai in r/askTO · Jan 2026
Lists it among top picks.
- Recommendsu/curbrash1 in r/askTO · Nov 2025
Gives this spot as their single answer.
- Recommendsu/Decker_Mahogany in r/FoodToronto · Jul 2024taste
Says this spot's pies are much better than Badiali's.
Also on
Fourth Man in the Fire is on another map too, with what people said about it there.
More maps in Toronto, Canada
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 4 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.