Best cafés in Edinburgh
61 cafés that Edinburgh locals recommend — the real reasons, and the caveats.
Edinburgh coffee shops and bakeries discussed for espresso, beans, cakes and pastries, with queue and seating caveats alongside the recommendations.
Drawn from real discussions in r/Edinburgh, r/espresso, r/Coffee and r/Scotland — 61 cafés in Edinburgh that people actually recommend. Each one shows why people rate it, the caveats they raised, and a link straight to the original comment — so you read the source yourself instead of trusting a laundered rating. Places cluster around Leith Walk, George Street, Stockbridge and Constitution Street.
How this map is made: Built from 654 Reddit comments across 556 people in r/Edinburgh, r/espresso, r/Coffee and r/Scotland. Last refreshed November 10, 2026. We paraphrase — never copy — and never take payment for a place. How we make our maps
Showing 61 places
Filters
Map
The map and place list use the same cited directory records. Every public entry has a stable Maps We Made ID and geopoint.
Places
1.Lannan Bakery, Stockbridge
38 people recommend, 16 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend Lannan Bakery, and many praise its pastries as excellent, with some saying the wait is worth it. Queues are the main drawback, and many people say they would not stand in one that long, though some say early or weekday visits bring shorter queues. It is counter service only with no seating. Several say other Edinburgh bakeries are just as good or better, and the bakery divides opinion.
Stockbridge
- RecommendsBacks the bakery and its customers, criticising the sub's hostility toward them. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2026
- CaveatLives nearby; says queues remain huge and takeaway box litter is common around the area. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2026
2.The Source
33 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Scotland, r/Edinburgh, r/espresso
Overall, people recommend The Source, a small cafe that roasts its own beans. Many people rate its coffee highly, and many call it among the best in town. Diners single out the flat white and the espresso, and several praise its beans and roasting. One diner is unconvinced by the hype.
- RecommendsVisitor said this Edinburgh spot was mind-blowing for coffee during their trip. r/Scotland, Jul 2025
- CaveatDoesn't get the hype and finds staff rather unfriendly. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2024
3.Artisan Roast, Broughton Street
32 people recommend, 5 warn against itcounted across its outletsvia r/Edinburgh, r/espresso
Artisan Roast is recommended across its Edinburgh branches, and Broughton Street is the shop commenters name most. Many people recommend it, several praise its range of beans, and one says it roasts in house.
Broughton Street
- RecommendsLists as a mid-tier option. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2024
- CaveatFeels like ordering a simple coffee there is an imposition on staff. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2026
4.Krema, Leith
30 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Most commenters recommend Krema, and many praise its cakes and pastries, with one diner saying a lemon cake there may be the best they have had. Two diners call its brownies the best they have eaten, and two praise the wide range of pastries. Cookie pie and cinnamon buns also get recommendations.
Leith
- RecommendsNames Krema Bakehouse as the answer, with no further detail given. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2025
- CaveatObjects to cakes left uncovered in the open shop area and dogs being allowed inside. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2025
5.Sicilian Pastry Shop, Off Leith Walk
27 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Most people who discuss the Sicilian Pastry Shop off Leith Walk recommend it, and many back its cakes and pastries. A few single out the cannoli. The caveats are that one diner found some fried pastries disappointing on one visit, while another finds the everyday bakes hit or miss and advises ordering ahead, since the best items go early.
Off Leith Walk
- RecommendsSays it tends to be reasonably priced and fairly popular, and they like its products. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2024
- CaveatTried it and found the fried pastries off-tasting; suspects an off day. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2026
6.Fortitude Coffee, Abbey Mount
26 people recommend, 1 warns against itcounted across its outletsvia r/Edinburgh, r/espresso
Fortitude Coffee is recommended across its Edinburgh outlets, and those who name one mention Abbey Mount (Abbeyhill) and Stockbridge. Most people recommend it, and a few count it among their favourites. Diners single out the iced latte and the hot chocolate, and one praises the pistachio and lemon cake. One diner finds it mediocre, and another finds the cafe espresso drinks a bit weak even though they rate the beans.
Abbey Mount
- RecommendsNames it as one of their favourite coffee shops in town. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2025
- CaveatCalls Fortitude overpriced and mediocre. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2023
7.Lowdown, George Street
23 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/Coffee, r/Edinburgh, r/espresso
Many people recommend Lowdown and praise the coffee as excellent, with a few naming the pour overs as a standout. A couple of commenters say seats can be hard to get. Opinion is divided on the feel of the place: one diner found it disappointing given the hype, and one commenter sees its strict drink-making as snobby but justified.
George Street
- RecommendsCalls the straight espresso excellent; warns seating is very limited, so visiting outside busy hours helps. r/Coffee, Jan 2024
- CaveatHas historically found Lowdown off-putting and wonders whether new ownership made it more welcoming. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2026
8.Little Fitzroy, Easter Road
22 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh, r/espresso
Little Fitzroy is on Easter Road, and most people recommend it. Commenters rate its coffee highly, with a couple calling it among the city's finest, and a couple praise its pastries and baked goods. One commenter likes its sit-down area and coffee flights. One diner who has been a few times finds it good but not as strong as Fortitude.
Easter Road
- RecommendsNamed among good independents where a flat white is reasonably priced. r/Edinburgh, Apr 2024
- MixedHas visited a few times and finds it good, but not close to Fortitude. r/Edinburgh, Jul 2026
9.The Pastry Section, Stockbridge
21 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
People recommend The Pastry Section, which bakes at its Stockbridge and Leith shops. Many commenters praise its cakes and sweet bakes, and one regular says it has stayed fantastic since opening. One commenter recommends the cakes and cinnamon rolls, and another says its Black Forest gateau is great when it is made.
Stockbridge
- RecommendsCounts a pecan-and-banana chocolate cookie among their favourite treats. r/Edinburgh, Feb 2025
10.Throat Punch Coffee, Dalry Road
20 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh
Throat Punch Coffee on Dalry Road, near Haymarket, is a coffee shop that most commenters recommend, and several people describe its coffee as strong. Several mention the resident shop dogs with fondness. One commenter rates the hot chocolate highly but wishes it stayed open later. A few commenters were unimpressed, with one finding the batch brew over-extracted and bitter.
Dalry Road
- RecommendsSays its coffee may be the best in Edinburgh and visits often with their daughter. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2026
- CaveatDisappointed; batch brew over extracted and bitter, milk drinks not liked. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2024
11.Machina, Marchmont
19 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh, r/espresso
Machina is an Edinburgh-based roaster that many people name among the city's good local coffee options, and several point to its Marchmont cafe. One diner has long enjoyed its brews, another was really impressed by it, and one calls it a knowledgeable independent local roaster and importer. One person is not a fan, and one places it in the mid-tier for specialty coffee.
Marchmont
- RecommendsLists as a mid-tier option. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2024
- CaveatSays they are not a fan of Machina, while listing it among established roasters with cafes. r/Edinburgh, Apr 2025
12.Black Medicine, Nicolson Street
17 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh, r/espresso
Many people recommend Black Medicine, and one commenter calls its Nicolson Street branch great. A few people praise the atmosphere and seating, and two recommend its millionaire's shortbread, one calling it the best they have tried. A couple of people call the coffee good or decent, but one says it tastes bad. A couple like it for working on a laptop.
Nicolson Street
- RecommendsRates Black Medicine Coffee as good; says independent cafes generally beat chains for a date. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2025
- CaveatSays definitely not Black Medicine, coffee tastes bad every time. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2024
13.Cult, Buccleuch Street
16 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh, r/Scotland, r/espresso
Many people recommend Cult, a coffee roaster with a cafe on Buccleuch Street, and a few praise its coffee and beans. One person recommends it for good food and a relaxed atmosphere, one visitor regularly has a hot chocolate there after a coffee, and another notes a good range of pour overs kept for an occasional treat.
Buccleuch Street
- RecommendsListed among local independent coffee shops that roast in-house; suggested as worth trying. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2024
14.L'Angelou, Northfield Broadway
16 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend L'Angelou, a French bakery on Northfield Broadway, and a few praise it in the strongest terms, calling it incredible, the best in town or authentically Parisian. One diner recommends the croissant pudding and another the classic white baguette. One visitor warns it can sell out before closing, so check the hours first.
Northfield Broadway
- RecommendsGives the Northfield Broadway branch a short, enthusiastic endorsement. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2024
15.The Cobbled Roastery, Thistle Street
16 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh, r/Scotland
The Cobbled Roastery is recommended across its Edinburgh shops, and those who name one mention Thistle Street and Castle Street. Many people recommend it, and a couple say the beans are roasted on site. A couple call it excellent, one rates it as a handy stop for a quick takeaway coffee in town, and one says it made the best cappuccino they have had.
Thistle Street
- RecommendsLikes its medium roasts and the shop's feel; handy for quick buys in town. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2026
16.Books N' Cup, Tollcross
16 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Books N' Cup is recommended across its Tollcross and Stockbridge cafes. Most people who weigh in recommend it, and many mention it as a late-night spot; at Tollcross, a few note it stays open into the evening, and one regular praises the pastries and drinks. A few commenters find it small and busy, one says some tables ban laptops, and another says Stockbridge evenings let laptop users sit at any table outside peak times.
Tollcross
- RecommendsSuggests this Tollcross coffee spot if wanting coffee, noting its late opening hours. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2024
- CaveatSays it is small and crowded, some tables ban laptops, and others are poor for typing. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2026
17.Söderberg
16 people recommend, 2 warn against itcounted across its outletsvia r/Edinburgh
Söderberg is recommended across its Edinburgh branches, including Broughton Street, Stockbridge, Queensferry Street and the Meadows pavilion. Many people recommend it, a few praise the cinnamon buns, and the banana loaf, semla buns and cakes also get mentions. One commenter lists it among mediocre bakeries.
- RecommendsRecommends the raspberry cinnamon bun. r/Edinburgh, Feb 2025
- CaveatLists it among the mediocre bakeries. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2024
18.Twelve Triangles, Dalry
16 people recommend, 5 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh
Twelve Triangles is recommended across its Edinburgh bakeries. One diner calls the Dalry Road shop superb and another recommends its pain au chocolat. Most diners recommend it, a couple praise its croissants and a few its cookies, and one names the pistachio croissant as a favourite. The cautions are about consistency: several diners feel quality has slipped, and a couple would skip the sandwiches.
Dalry
- RecommendsLists its pistachio croissant as one of their favourite treats. r/Edinburgh, Feb 2025
- CaveatLoved it years ago; now blames mass production for slipping quality. r/Edinburgh, Jan 2024
19.Beatnik
15 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh, r/espresso
Many people put Beatnik among Edinburgh's top coffee spots, with one commenter saying its coffee is on another level and another calling it a close runner-up for the top spot. One person points to its espresso tonic and another to a homemade brown sugar syrup. One diner finds the atmosphere a bit pretentious but keeps going back for the quality.
- RecommendsSays vibes are probably best at Beatnik. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2024
- MixedLoves the quality but finds it pretentious, with baristas who sometimes seem off-putting. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2025
20.Cairngorm Coffee, Melville Place
15 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh, r/espresso
Cairngorm Coffee is recommended across its Edinburgh cafes, and one commenter notes the Melville Place cafe stays open into the evening. Most people recommend it, one commenter rates its batch brew as a personal favourite, and one praises its subscription. One diner finds the espresso too acidic for their taste, and a couple describe the iced drinks as small.
Melville Place
- RecommendsNamed among good independents where a flat white is reasonably priced. r/Edinburgh, Apr 2024
- CaveatOrdered an iced coffee there, left disappointed, and called the serving tiny. r/Edinburgh, Jul 2026
21.101 Bakery, Newington
15 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Overall, diners recommend 101 Bakery in Newington, and many praise its cakes and baked goods, including a vegan chocolate cake that one diner found delicious. A couple of diners single out the cinnamon buns, a couple praise the cookies, and a few highlight its vegan options. Not everyone is won over: one diner rates other city bakeries higher and found the Guinness cake less good than a homemade version.
Newington
- RecommendsSays the cakes and buns they've had from the Newington shop have never been bad. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2024
- CaveatRates other bakeries higher; their Guinness cake fell short and a long queue ended with sold-out tiramisu. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2026
22.Williams & Johnson, Leith
15 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh
Most people recommend Williams & Johnson, a roaster with a cafe at the Shore in Leith. Several praise the coffee and a few single out the pastries, and one recommends the tahini cookie. A couple find the indoor seating uncomfortable, one says it can be busy at weekends, and a couple enjoy sitting outside on sunny mornings.
Leith
- RecommendsNames Williams & Johnson as their top pick for a cafe. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2025
- CaveatFound the staff pretentious on a recent visit, which put them off returning. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2026
23.Room and Rumours
13 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh, r/espresso
Many diners recommend Room and Rumours, a cafe in the railway arches on Market Street. Several praise its coffee, with one ranking its batch brew among the finest they have tasted, and one recommends the Biscoff cinnamon bun. One visitor makes a point of stopping in on every trip to the city.
- RecommendsEdit says Room Rumours adds no fee for oat milk. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2025
24.Babyfaced Baker, Leith Walk
13 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Most visitors recommend Babyfaced Baker, which people place on Leith Walk and around Leith and Portobello. Several praise its vegan options and pastries, one singles out the cookies, brownies and blondies, and another finds the coffee good. One visitor personally finds the pasties poor.
Leith Walk
- RecommendsFavourite lunch spot, takeaway only but lovely. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2024
- CaveatPersonally finds its pasties poor. r/Edinburgh, Jan 2026
25.Storries, Leith Walk
13 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh
Storries is a Leith Walk bakery, and several commenters point to the Leith Walk shop as the one to try. Most people who comment recommend it, several mention it as a late-night stop, one praises the pies and another the shortbread. Views are mixed: one commenter says it has declined badly, one finds it over-hyped, and one says it is good for late-night snacks but not in the same league as higher-quality bakeries.
Leith Walk
- RecommendsRecalls late-night visits after hospitality shifts as a lifesaver and calls it more than a bakery. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2024
- CaveatSays Storries has declined badly and questions how recently the other person visited. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2026
26.Mr Eion, Trinity
12 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Many commenters recommend Mr Eion, a coffee roaster that people mostly place in Trinity, and several praise its coffee and beans. A couple say it roasts its own beans for sale, and one commenter says the black coffee is fine. One diner says its salted milk chocolate cookie is a pleasant surprise, though it is not always on offer. The main caveat is the limited opening days, which one commenter wishes were more generous.
Trinity
- RecommendsListed among local independent coffee shops that roast in-house; suggested as worth trying. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2024
- CaveatWishes the cafe were open more often and finds its opening schedule absurd. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2024
27.Wellington Coffee, George Street
11 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Wellington Coffee is a George Street coffee shop that many people recommend. A couple call the coffee lovely or good, one finds the beans mild and easy to drink, and one singles out the carrot cake.
George Street
- RecommendsSimply describes Wellington Coffee as nice. r/Edinburgh, May 2026
28.Ante, Leith Walk
11 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Ante on Leith Walk is generally recommended, and several diners single out its pastries as excellent, with seasonal flavours such as greengage danishes and chanterelle and rye. One diner rates its coffee, including the batch brew and cold brew, and another says there are usually several savoury options.
Leith Walk
- RecommendsNames Ante as another great bakery worth a visit. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2025
- CaveatDislikes the payment screen that forces a no-tip choice before paying, even for takeaway. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2026
29.Patina
11 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh
Patina at Edinburgh Park is recommended as a bakery and coffee stop, though it takes a tram or a drive to reach. Many commenters recommend it, one calling it the city's best baker and worth the trip, and one describing it as quiet with plenty of seats. Another rates the coffee positively.
- RecommendsCalls it a lovely bakery-coffee spot that's quiet, with easy parking, plenty of seats and flat ground. r/Edinburgh, Jan 2026
- CaveatUnbothered by the pretentious label; annoyed at extra charges for ketchup and butter with bread. r/Edinburgh, Jul 2026
30.Tanifiki, Portobello
10 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend Tanifiki on Portobello High Street, and a few say it roasts its own beans. Several praise the coffee itself, one says its tonka bean syrup is very nice, and another says the food is good too.
Portobello
- RecommendsCoffee-loving friends like Tanfiki in Portobello. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2024
31.Black Rabbit, Brougham Place
10 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend Black Rabbit, a vegan cafe on Brougham Place, and several single out its cakes and pastries. One commenter loves the tofu benedict, and another recommends it for its sandwiches.
Brougham Place
- RecommendsHedged claim that this vegan cafe skips the alternative milk surcharge. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2025
32.Loudon's, Fountainbridge
10 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Loudon's is recommended across its Edinburgh cafes; the Fountainbridge branch is named by a couple of commenters, and others mention Waverley and a branch near the Royal Mile. Several people recommend it, and two note plenty of space for buggies and prams.
Fountainbridge
- RecommendsRecommends Loudons as a good pick close to the Royal Mile. r/Edinburgh, May 2026
33.The Bastard Barista
9 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend The Bastard Barista, a Queen Street coffee shop, and a few call its coffee lovely or excellent. One newer arrival to the city says it is the best they have found, another likes the vibe, and one calls it the original type of coffee shop.
- RecommendsOffered as one of three coffee suggestions. r/Edinburgh, May 2026
- MixedSays the coffee is lovely. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2025
34.Little Havana, Leith Walk
9 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
People recommend Little Havana, a coffee shop on Leith Walk, and several praise its wide range of beans. A couple praise the coffee itself, and one says it roasts its beans on site.
Leith Walk
- RecommendsSays this Leith Walk shop has a broad bean range and friendly staff, though beans aren't self-serve. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2026
35.Chapter One, Dalry
9 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend Chapter One, a coffee shop on Dalry Road close to Haymarket. One diner calls it a pleasant brunch spot, and another praises the reuben sandwich. A couple praise its vegan cakes and pastries, and one commenter says it has recently begun roasting its own beans and finds them tasty.
Dalry
- RecommendsCalls it a pleasant brunch spot in Dalry, close to Haymarket. r/Edinburgh, May 2024
36.Sugar Daddy's, Marchmont
8 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend Sugar Daddy's, a free-from bakery in Marchmont, and a few point to it as a good option for gluten-free eating, with one also mentioning dairy-free. One visitor especially likes the cookie sandwiches, and another suggests it for birthday orders.
Marchmont
- RecommendsCalls it good, especially handy if someone needs gluten-free options. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2026
37.Cafe Tepuy, Albert Street
8 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many commenters recommend Cafe Tepuy, a specialty Colombian coffee shop, and a few name its Albert Street shop. One visitor recommends the single-estate Colombian coffee and says the cafe is tiny, with beans for sale. Another finds the coffee fresh, one ranks it as the best in town, and another says the quality is high and the range broad.
Albert Street
- RecommendsCalls Cafe Tepuy excellent. r/Edinburgh, Jul 2024
38.Mayvn Cafe, George Street
8 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh, r/espresso
Mayvn Cafe on George Street is a laptop-friendly cafe: several diners say there is room to work, and a couple note a table or seating set aside for remote workers. A few describe the setting as lovely or tranquil. One commenter recalls it turning pub-like in the early evening on a past visit, and opening hours are remembered differently, so check before you go.
George Street
- RecommendsSuggests Mayvn on George Street, believing it stays open until 10pm. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2024
- CaveatRemembers it turning pub-like around 6pm on a past visit, an odd shift. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2024
39.Snax Cafe, West Register Street
8 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Snax Cafe is an Edinburgh greasy spoon, and one commenter names the West Register Street branch. Most people who weigh in recommend it, with two backing it for rolls and two for breakfast, and one calling it their usual greasy spoon. One diner who ordered breakfast there once found it only passable.
West Register Street
- RecommendsNames Snax as a recommendation for a working man's cafe. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2024
- CaveatWarns against both Snax branches. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2024
40.Lounge 33, Leith Walk
7 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Lounge 33 is a cafe and record shop on Leith Walk, and many commenters recommend it. One diner finds the coffee pretty good, another says the matcha juice is surprisingly tasty, and one mentions its homemade syrups and iced teas. A couple of commenters say it is open late on Thursdays and Fridays.
Leith Walk
- RecommendsSays Lounge 33 stays open late on Thursdays and Fridays, still takes coffee orders then, and has good decaf. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2026
41.Considerit
7 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh, r/espresso
Considerit is a fully vegan cafe in Sciennes that several people recommend, and several single out its doughnuts. A few commenters note it also does ice cream and milkshakes, and another highlights its many dessert options.
- RecommendsRecommends it as a top pick for donuts among fully vegan places. r/Edinburgh, Jan 2026
42.Thomas J Walls
7 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Most commenters recommend Thomas J Walls, a coffee shop on Forrest Road, and a few diners praise the coffee. A few describe the atmosphere as pleasant, and one notes a sofa at the back and usually being able to get a table. A couple of diners say it can feel cold.
- RecommendsLists it among cafes they have been enjoying lately. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2025
43.CJ's Cafe, Dalry Road
7 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend CJ's Cafe on Dalry Road, and one visitor found the place brilliant.
Dalry Road
- RecommendsNames CJ's on Dalry Road when asked for an affordable fry-up. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2024
44.John Lewis Cafe
6 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several visitors recommend the cafe at John Lewis, on the top floor, mainly for its views. A few say the views are good, one praises seats beside the glass walls, and one visitor says it works for visiting with a pram, with changing facilities and feeding chairs. One person finds it easy to reach for older relatives but does not praise the coffee, and one advises arriving early for a window seat.
- RecommendsSuggests the John Lewis café, noting changing facilities, feeding chairs, and a nice view for a baby. r/Edinburgh, May 2026
- MixedVery easy to reach and has good views, but coffee quality isn't praised. r/Edinburgh, Jan 2026
45.Rocksalt Cafe, Constitution Street
6 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend Rocksalt Cafe on Constitution Street in Leith, near the tram stop. One commenter calls it great and another says the food is fantastic. It is also named for rolls and cooked breakfasts, one visitor suggests breakfast outside when it is sunny, and a visitor with a toddler enjoys the window seat with a tram view.
Constitution Street
- RecommendsLevel access, close to the accessible tram stop. r/Edinburgh, Jan 2026
46.Polentoni, Easter Road
6 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Polentoni is an Italian spot on Easter Road, and several people praise its sandwiches. A couple rank them among the best in town, and one describes the fillings as simple rather than overstuffed. One adds that cakes only show up occasionally.
Easter Road
- RecommendsLists it as a favourite Italian spot, great for sandwiches with occasional cakes. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2026
47.Tasty Buns, Bread Street
6 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend Tasty Buns, and two name its Bread Street shop. One says the bakes change every day, another finds the baked goods excellent, one recommends the brownies, and one says it is good for tray bakes.
Bread Street
- RecommendsSuggests trying it; says the bakes change every day. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2026
48.Relish Cafe
6 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several diners recommend Relish, a cafe on Commercial Street in Leith. A couple call it a go-to or favourite stop for walks or work trips, one regular rates the sandwiches, and one praises the cappuccinos and calls it a nice place to relax. Another finds it decent.
- RecommendsRegular customer who favours the sandwiches; thinks it reopens on the 7th and says the notice is hard to spot. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2026
49.Sloe Lane, Leith Walk
6 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Sloe Lane is a bakery on Leith Walk that several diners recommend, two of whom praise its savoury pastries. One diner likes the lavender iced latte, and two note it is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays.
Leith Walk
- RecommendsLists this bakery among the local ones it recommends. r/Edinburgh, Jan 2026
- CaveatSurprised by praise for Sloe Lane; says staff make customers feel unwelcome even if the pastries are good. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2026
50.Bearded Baker
6 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Diners lean toward recommending The Bearded Baker, and a few praise its cinnamon buns, including vegan ones whose flavours rotate weekly. A couple recommend the donuts, one rates the tin loaf highly, and one says it is always great. One commenter lists it among the mediocre bakeries.
- RecommendsDisagrees, finding the donuts and tin loaf pretty fantastic. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2024
- CaveatLists it among the mediocre bakeries. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2024
51.Artisan Coffee, Leith Walk
6 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Several diners recommend Artisan Coffee, and the Leith Walk cafe on the corner of Balfour Street is the one most name. One says the coffee and food are great and another rates its iced latte as the best in town, while another calls it a nice little cafe.
Leith Walk
- RecommendsSays this corner spot has great coffee and food. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2026
- CaveatPaid a high price there for average quality, which they found ridiculous. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2024
52.The Howdah Tea and Coffee Company, Stockbridge
6 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh
Most people recommend The Howdah Tea and Coffee Company, a tea and coffee shop on Deanhaugh Street in Stockbridge. A couple point to its wide choice of teas and coffees, including a wall of bean varieties, and one calls it excellent. One person finds the coffee acidic.
Stockbridge
- RecommendsSays Howdah in Stockbridge seems to match what was asked for. r/Edinburgh, Jan 2024
- CaveatWarns that the person running this shop is unpleasant and that the coffee tastes acidic. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2026
53.Uplands Roast, The Meadows
5 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend Uplands Roast, a roaster on the edge of the Meadows. One diner who visited in person found the food tasty.
The Meadows
- RecommendsRecommends it on the Meadows' northern edge, followed by a walk through the park. r/Edinburgh, May 2026
54.Razz Cafe, Home Street
5 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Razz is a patisserie-style cafe on Home Street that people recommend for its baking, and several single out its cookies. A few say it stays open late into the evening.
Home Street
- RecommendsSays Razz's cookies are gluten-free and suggests trying them. r/Edinburgh, May 2025
55.Hata Cafe, Canonmills
5 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Hata Cafe in Canonmills is recommended by several people. One diner describes comfortable downstairs seating, including a sofa, and never felt hurried there; one suggests it for its granola, and one says it is worth travelling to Canonmills.
Canonmills
- RecommendsMentions a sofa and comfortable seating downstairs; has never been hurried there. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2023
56.Preachers Patisserie, Lady Lawson Street
5 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Preachers Patisserie on Lady Lawson Street, near the Grassmarket, is recommended by several people. One calls it excellent overall, another says it was really good, and one says it has been around for decades. Another visitor thought its breakfast rolls looked very inviting.
Lady Lawson Street
- RecommendsCalls it excellent overall. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2025
57.Sea Breeze Cafe, Leith Walk
5 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend Sea Breeze Cafe on Leith Walk, one calling it a classic, simple breakfast spot. One diner says the fry-up is tasty and works for eating in or taking away filled rolls.
Leith Walk
- RecommendsSays the fry-up is inexpensive and flavourful; works for eating in or taking away filled rolls. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2024
58.The Haven, Newhaven
5 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
The Haven in Newhaven, at the tram terminus, is recommended by several people for cafe food. One commenter praises its baked goods and a favourite toastie, one says it is the best coffee they have had, and another cannot vouch for the coffee. One visitor found it underwhelming on three visits.
Newhaven
- RecommendsSays Haven is good in their opinion. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2025
- CaveatVisited three times and found it underwhelming each time. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2025
59.The Old Spence Cafe, Constitution Street
5 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
The Old Spence Cafe in Leith is recommended by several people. One commenter praises the focaccia and another calls it great, one suggests it for rolls and cooked breakfasts, and one suggests it as a pro-laptop place that opens early. One commenter found it very humid on a recent visit.
Constitution Street
- RecommendsRecommends Old Spence for its focaccia, while disclosing that a friend owns it. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2025
- CaveatFound it very humid on a recent visit and wants the condensation sorted. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2025
60.Milkman
5 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh, r/espresso
Several commenters recommend Milkman. One visitor calls it incredibly good, noting the coffee is brewed with Origin beans, and one singles out its sugary blueberry twists as wildly good. One commenter, with limited experience, doubts it counts as specialty coffee, saying it focuses on milk drinks.
- RecommendsIncludes it in a list of cafes they suggest, with no detail. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2025
- CaveatSays it mainly sells milk drinks and not much black coffee; doubts it's specialty. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2025
61.Kilimanjaro
5 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh, r/espresso
Kilimanjaro is a Nicolson Street coffee shop that several people recommend, and a couple suggest it as an evening option. One diner says they love the fruit scones. Opinion is divided: one commenter likes it but finds it cramped, and a couple suspect its quality has slipped over the years.
- RecommendsSuggests Kilimanjaro as an evening option, noting it closes at 8pm. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2024
- CaveatConfirms it is still operating but does not rate it personally. r/espresso, Aug 2024
Questions people ask
- Which cafés do Edinburgh locals recommend most?
- Right now the most-recommended are Lannan Bakery, Stockbridge, The Source and Artisan Roast, Broughton Street, ranked by how many different people vouched for each one. Every place lists the reasons people gave and the caveats they raised, with a link to the original comment.
- How is this list made?
- It is built from public Reddit discussions — 654 comments from 556 people across r/Edinburgh, r/espresso, r/Coffee and r/Scotland. We paraphrase why each place is recommended, keep the negatives and caveats in, and link to the original comment so you can read the source yourself. We never invent details.
- Are these paid placements?
- No. Nothing here is sponsored, paid or ranked by a business. Places are included only because real people recommended them in public conversations, and every claim links back to its source.
- How recent are these recommendations?
- This map was last refreshed November 10, 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time, so confirm current details directly before you rely on them.
Did this page answer your question?
More maps to explore
Edinburgh
Indian restaurants
Indian dining in Edinburgh, from South Indian dosas to shared small plates, with the cited recommendations and disagreements about food and service.
Open the mapEdinburgh
Best restaurants
People steer friends in Edinburgh toward Soul Vegan for its laksa, Chez Jules for the lunch deal, Dishoom for okra fries and black daal, Gautam's for nihari gosht, Noto for butter crab, and Noodles & Dumplings for soup noodles, though you will need cash there.
Open the mapEdinburgh
Places to visit
Edinburgh recommendations run from museums to garden and riverside walks: the free National Museum of Scotland, which people return to again and again, a relaxed stroll at the Royal Botanic Garden, Dean Village on a Water of Leith walk to Stockbridge, the murals at the Scottish National Portrait Gallery and the closes off the Royal Mile, though its shops lean to souvenirs.
Open the map