Places to visit in Edinburgh
15 places that Edinburgh locals recommend — the real reasons, and the caveats.
Edinburgh recommendations run from museums to garden and riverside walks: the free National Museum of Scotland, which people return to again and again, a relaxed stroll at the Royal Botanic Garden, Dean Village on a Water of Leith walk to Stockbridge, the murals at the Scottish National Portrait Gallery and the closes off the Royal Mile, though its shops lean to souvenirs.
Drawn from real discussions in r/Edinburgh, r/uktravel and r/AskUK — 15 places in Edinburgh that people actually recommend. Each one shows why people rate it, the caveats they raised, and a link straight to the original comment — so you read the source yourself instead of trusting a laundered rating.
How this map is made: Built from 153 Reddit comments across 149 people in r/Edinburgh, r/uktravel and r/AskUK. Last refreshed November 3, 2026. We paraphrase — never copy — and never take payment for a place. How we make our maps
Showing 15 places
Map
The map and place list use the same cited directory records. Every public entry has a stable Maps We Made ID and geopoint.
Places
1.National Museum of Scotland
61 people recommend, 7 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh, r/uktravel
Most visitors recommend the National Museum of Scotland, many say they return again and again, and several mention that entry is free. One visitor says it keeps children entertained when it rains, another enjoyed the Cold War display, and one recalls seeing the Declaration of Arbroath. Some people miss displays removed in the redevelopment, such as the fish ponds and the whale skeleton, and several find it odd that visitors no longer enter through the main front doors.
- RecommendsSays it is worth spending hours in and is usually uncrowded; a regular go-to. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2024
- CaveatStill annoyed that the fish ponds were removed. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2024
2.Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh
27 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh, r/uktravel
Many visitors recommend the Royal Botanic Garden, several for a relaxed stroll, and several list it among the city's free things to do. A couple enjoy it year-round, with one praising autumn and another winter strolls, and a couple mention the cafe. One visitor suggests the upper part of the gardens for a view over the city, and another says they avoid the festive lights as too busy.
- RecommendsNames the botanical gardens as a favourite free thing to do. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2026
- CaveatAvoids the Botanics' festive lights too, finding them busy and not worth going to. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2025
3.Dean Village
15 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia r/uktravel, r/Edinburgh
Most visitors recommend Dean Village, and several describe it as stunning, gorgeous or idyllic. Several suggest it as part of a walk along the Water of Leith to or from Stockbridge. One visitor notes it is a residential area with no shops or cafes, and a few say residents dislike visitors photographing their homes, so stick to the riverside and bridges. One visitor says it now often feels packed and another remembers it as peaceful and quiet.
- RecommendsDescribes the village as picturesque, with appealing architecture and views, and worth a visit. r/Edinburgh, Jul 2026
- CaveatSays Dean Village is mainly homes with no shops or cafes, and residents resent tourists photographing their property. r/uktravel, Oct 2026
4.Scottish National Portrait Gallery
12 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many visitors recommend the Scottish National Portrait Gallery. A few praise a recent photography exhibition, one says its murals are worth returning to, and a couple enjoy the cafe. One visitor likes its central position and handsome building and says the exhibits change, and another calls it a favourite even though it is awkward to get to through the busy centre.
- RecommendsSuggests it as one of several galleries worth seeing. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2025
5.Royal Mile
12 people recommend, 5 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh, r/uktravel, r/AskUK
Many visitors recommend the Royal Mile, with several suggesting a wander along it and a few finding its closes and old buildings worth a closer look. A couple find it striking at dawn and one in misty weather. The caveats are that a few visitors say the shops are mostly tourist souvenirs, a few feel it does not need a whole day, and one calls it dismal. One says Leith Walk is nicer these days. One visitor suggests peeking into the closes once crowds ease.
- RecommendsHappened upon a sunrise glimpse on the Royal Mile and found it worth photographing. r/Edinburgh, Apr 2026
- CaveatSays the Royal Mile is mostly repetitive gift shops and does not need five hours. r/uktravel, Aug 2025
6.Holyrood Park
9 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh, r/uktravel
Many visitors recommend Holyrood Park, and a few mention walking there. One visitor thinks it is lovely in winter, with plenty of birds around, and another suggests going early for the deer. A couple suggest staying on the flatter ground at the bottom if you skip Arthur's Seat. One visitor who used to exercise there some years ago found it packed and hard to switch off.
- RecommendsFinds Holyrood Park lovely in winter; lived nearby and walked it year round. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2025
- MixedUsed to exercise there some years ago, but it got packed and hard to switch off, so they ran the Old Town steps instead. r/Edinburgh, Feb 2026
7.Dr Neil's Garden
9 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Nine visitors name Dr Neil's Garden as a place to visit in Duddingston. One calls it peaceful, and two suggest pairing it with a walk to or around Duddingston, either across the crags from Parliament or through the old village.
- RecommendsCalls it a peaceful little spot worth visiting in Duddingston. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2026
8.Mary King's Close
9 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh, r/uktravel
Many visitors rate Mary King's Close highly, with one calling it excellent and another amazing for the chance to walk beneath the modern streets. A couple say it is a must or well worth the time, one finds it fun for people who like history, and another says their children really enjoyed it.
- RecommendsConsiders it a must for anyone who hasn't been yet. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2026
9.St Giles' Cathedral
8 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh, r/uktravel
Many visitors list St Giles' Cathedral among the Old Town sights worth a stop, and a couple call the building attractive. One recommends it to architecture fans and singles out the Thistle Chapel. Three visitors mention its evening classical and choir concerts, though one adds that the music does not suit everyone. One visitor says it is only free for Edinburgh residents after September.
- RecommendsSuggests its six o'clock concert series as a way to hear classical music. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2025
- MixedLists the cathedral among free places, noting visitor access will change after September. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2026
10.People's Story Museum
6 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Six visitors mention the People's Story, a museum telling the city's story, and one finds it interesting and well put together. A couple feel it suits families and children, and another lists it among the smaller museums worth seeing. The caveats are that one visitor finds it barely advertised, one found it closed on the day they went, and another thinks it appeals more to residents and school groups than to tourists.
- RecommendsThinks closing or going seasonal is wrong; says tourist-tax money should keep this museum telling the city's story. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2024
11.Cramond
6 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Most visitors recommend Cramond. One praises its attractive streets and woodland walk, and another enjoys the walk in from Granton, which feels quieter than busier Forth spots. A couple say it is quieter than busier places nearby, and one recommends a New Year sunrise outing there, though it depends on suitable weather and tides. One visitor warns of few good pubs and cafes and crowds at Christmas, while another calls it great but says the sea sometimes floods the walkway.
- RecommendsRecommended for its attractive streets and woodland walk. r/Edinburgh, Jul 2026
- CaveatSays Cramond lacks decent pubs and cafes, and gets crowded at Christmas when little else is open. r/Edinburgh, Jul 2026
12.Colinton Tunnel
5 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Five visitors recommend Colinton Tunnel, two of them with only a brief mention. One calls the former railway tunnel a cool thing to see, one says the murals inside are amazing, and another suggests a downhill walk from Balerno toward Colinton that passes it.
- RecommendsPraises the murals inside the tunnel as striking. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2026
13.Craigmillar Castle
5 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Visitors recommend Craigmillar Castle, and one visitor says they prefer it to Edinburgh Castle. A few say it is off the usual tourist route, and another feels it holds its own against the central sights despite being further out.
- RecommendsSuggests it as a south Edinburgh spot people often miss. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2026
14.The Meadows
5 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several visitors recommend the Meadows, and one describes it as a central, scenic park where something is always going on. One says it is mostly flat with plenty of green space and popular with runners, another notes a signposted route to follow on foot, and another says it is better lit than Holyrood Park for running.
- RecommendsCalls the Meadows a central, scenic park with something always happening, such as events or people relaxing. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
15.Surgeons' Hall Museums
5 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh, r/uktravel
Several visitors recommend Surgeons' Hall Museums, and one describes it as a quirky, offbeat place to visit. One says it is mostly about anatomy and medicine but may be worth a look anyway, and one enjoyed it a lot. A couple of visitors were let down: one found it unsettling rather than quirky, and another says it affected them very differently than they had hoped.
- RecommendsRecommends it as a quirky, offbeat place to visit. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2026
- CaveatDid not find it quirky; found it unsettling rather than charming. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2026
Questions people ask
- Which places do Edinburgh locals recommend most?
- Right now the most-recommended are National Museum of Scotland, Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh and Dean Village, ranked by how many different people vouched for each one. Every place lists the reasons people gave and the caveats they raised, with a link to the original comment.
- How is this list made?
- It is built from public Reddit discussions — 153 comments from 149 people across r/Edinburgh, r/uktravel and r/AskUK. We paraphrase why each place is recommended, keep the negatives and caveats in, and link to the original comment so you can read the source yourself. We never invent details.
- Are these paid placements?
- No. Nothing here is sponsored, paid or ranked by a business. Places are included only because real people recommended them in public conversations, and every claim links back to its source.
- How recent are these recommendations?
- This map was last refreshed November 3, 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time, so confirm current details directly before you rely on them.
Did this page answer your question?
More maps to explore
Edinburgh
Best cafés
Edinburgh coffee shops and bakeries discussed for espresso, beans, cakes and pastries, with queue and seating caveats alongside the recommendations.
Open the mapEdinburgh
Indian restaurants
Indian dining in Edinburgh, from South Indian dosas to shared small plates, with the cited recommendations and disagreements about food and service.
Open the mapEdinburgh
Best restaurants
People steer friends in Edinburgh toward Soul Vegan for its laksa, Chez Jules for the lunch deal, Dishoom for okra fries and black daal, Gautam's for nihari gosht, Noto for butter crab, and Noodles & Dumplings for soup noodles, though you will need cash there.
Open the map