Black Magic Pizza
21 people recommendvia r/orlando21 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Black Magic Pizza draws repeated pizza recommendations, including specialty pies and a suggestion for feeding a crowd. One diner highlights the Dr. Pepperoni; wings and poutine also receive endorsements. One commenter suggests taking a pie to the Milkhouse patio, and another names it for late-night food in the Milk District.
Address
Black Magic Pizza, 121 N Bumby Ave, Orlando, FL 32803
At a glance
- Signature dishes
- Dr. Pepperoni
- Best for
- Groups, Late night
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/squeefactor in r/orlando · Jun 2026
Named as a late-night option in the Milk District.
- Recommendsu/paranoidtransdroid in r/orlando · Mar 2026
Named in the commenter's list of inexpensive favorites.
- Recommendsu/PeptoBisquick in r/orlando · Apr 2025
Enjoys eating its pizza alongside a visit to neighboring Whiskey Lou's.
- Recommendsu/GatorSe7en in r/orlando · Jul 2026taste
Recommends the poutine as really good.
- Recommendsu/yawnstack in r/orlando · Sep 2025taste
Calls Black Magic their favorite and rates its quality above Lazy Moon.
- Recommendsu/checkonechecktwo in r/orlando · Sep 2025variety
Suggests Black Magic pies to please a crowd.
- Recommendsu/Funny-Berry-807 in r/orlando · Mar 2024taste
Calls it the top pizza in Orlando and suggests eating it on the Milkhouse patio across the street.
- Recommendsu/RoundConstruction526 in r/orlando · Jul 2026taste
Enthusiastically ranks its pizza among local favorites.
Show all 21 cited comments
- Recommendsu/Automatic-Weakness26 in r/orlando · Sep 2026
Suggests pairing the pizza with neighboring Whiskey Lou's in the Milk District.
- Recommendsu/xomable in r/orlando · Jul 2026
Agrees it is their favorite too.
- Recommendsu/JHunihan in r/orlando · Jun 2026taste
Agrees Black Magic Pizza is the pick, no questions.
- Recommendsu/SwaggySteve_21 in r/orlando · Sep 2025
Fully endorses Black Magic.
- Recommendsu/Erik_Lassiter in r/orlando · Jul 2026
Came to the thread to second the Black Magic Pizza recommendation.
- Recommendsu/Current-Orange-726 in r/orlando · Apr 2026taste
Recommends the Dr. Pepperoni and speaks highly of the pizza.
- Recommendsu/Epic-x-lord_69 in r/orlando · Mar 2025
Recommends Black Magic Pizza.
- Recommendsu/Unhappy_Street_422 in r/orlando · Mar 2024
Recommends the nearby pizzeria.
- Recommendsu/Avathecat87 in r/orlando · May 2026
Endorses Black Magic Pizza enthusiastically.
- Recommendsu/Walkingdichotomy83 in r/orlando · May 2026taste
Enjoys the Calabrian Buffalo wings and mentions a midweek offer.
- Recommendsu/Aggravating_Dog7698 in r/orlando · Mar 2025
Names Black Magic as a recommendation.
- Recommendsu/TaffyTool in r/orlando · Sep 2025
Suggests trying Black Magic for pizza.
- Recommendsu/Greginthesouth2 in r/orlando · Sep 2025
Says Black Magic is great.
Also on
Black Magic Pizza is on another map too, with what people said about it there.
More maps in Orlando, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 10 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.