Goat Hill Pizza, Potrero Hill
32 people recommend, 4 warn against itcounted across its outletsvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 14 threads.
What people say, in short
Diners recommend Goat Hill across its San Francisco outlets for sourdough crust. Individual diners recommend the Porky Pie and Hawaiian Roast without identifying an outlet for those orders. Some describe the brand as dependable neighborhood pizza rather than a destination meal, while others actively dislike it or find it overhyped. Price increases also come up in the discussion; the different outlets should not be assumed to offer identical experiences.
Address
Goat Hill Pizza, 300 Connecticut St, San Francisco, CA 94107
At a glance
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Goat Hill Pizza, Potrero Hill, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/MochingPet in r/AskSF · Nov 2025taste
Says Goat Hill does its own delivery and makes better pizza than some earlier picks.
- Recommendsu/banana_peanut in r/sanfrancisco · Nov 2025taste
Praises the sourdough crust and mentions a birthday discount offer.
- Caveatu/citronauts in r/sanfrancisco · Nov 2025price
Says the restaurant adds a surcharge fee and is not surprised by it.
- Recommendsu/tshane_dot_com in r/sanfrancisco · Nov 2025ambience
Says the place always has a great atmosphere and congratulates it on its anniversary.
- Recommendsu/FolsomMulch in r/sanfrancisco · Feb 2025
Enthusiastically endorses Goat Hill with no further detail.
- Recommendsu/kevinw88 in r/sanfrancisco · Feb 2025taste
Prefers Goat Hill over the other option, saying its crust is better.
- Recommendsu/ConsciousCappuccino in r/sanfrancisco · Dec 2025value
Points to a Monday unlimited-pizza deal as worth checking.
- Recommendsu/AffableCynic in r/sanfrancisco · Nov 2025
Fondly recalls pies from here waiting after brewery tours years ago.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Recommendsu/eOeOr in r/AskSF · Apr 2026taste
Singled out for its sourdough crust and rotating seasonal flavors.
- Recommendsu/zulmirao in r/sanfrancisco · Nov 2025taste
Answers that it tastes fairly good and the sourdough crust sets it apart.
- Recommendsu/Party-Belt-3624 in r/sanfrancisco · Feb 2025
Offers Goat Hill as one of two answers for the request.
- Recommendsu/Oldbluevespa in r/AskSF · Sep 2024delivery
Says Goat Hill handles its own delivery, the West Portal branch covers Diamond Heights, and orders can be placed online.
- Recommendsu/thedudeabides666 in r/sanfrancisco · Dec 2025taste
Recommends the Potrero location and says its cornmeal crust is excellent.
- Mixedu/surrealmirror in r/sanfrancisco · Nov 2025taste
Says it is not the top pick but still good.
- Recommendsu/Key-Article6622 in r/sanfrancisco · Nov 2025taste
Calls the pizza good and describes it as a pleasant place to get a pie.
- Recommendsu/llcoolgay9 in r/sanfrancisco · Nov 2025taste
Rates it as top-tier pizza locally and says the service is also great.
- Recommendsu/neBular_cipHer in r/AskSF · Nov 2025taste
Also recommends Goat Hill and praises its Porky Pie as great.
- Recommendsu/lceberg415 in r/AskSF · Jul 2025
Names Goat Hill as the answer.
- Recommendsu/runbeautifulrun in r/sanfrancisco · Jul 2025
Recommends its sourdough pizza and notes single slices are available as a fast option.
- Recommendsu/Willing_Drawer_3351 in r/sanfrancisco · Dec 2025taste
Praises the sourdough crust and describes the Hawaiian Roast as the basic Hawaiian plus bacon and jalapeño.
- Recommendsu/12Afrodites12 in r/sanfrancisco · Feb 2025taste
Recommends Goat Hill for its sourdough crusts, noting three locations and delivery.
- Caveatu/Jayang in r/sanfrancisco · Nov 2025taste
Lives nearby and says it is overrated, among the weakest pizzas locals praise.
- Recommendsu/turtledancers in r/sanfrancisco · Oct 2025taste
Thinks the pizza is merely okay but still considers Goat Hill the stronger sourdough option.
- Recommendsu/pb_in_sf in r/sanfrancisco · Feb 2025
Endorses Goat Hill and suggests strolling Potrero Hill while waiting.
- Recommendsu/Defiant-Spray7523 in r/sanfrancisco · Feb 2025
Lists Goat Hill as a top pick.
- Recommendsu/peanutbuttermellly in r/sanfrancisco · Nov 2025taste
Calls it decent overall and says the crust is quite good.
- Recommendsu/giogadi in r/sanfrancisco · Feb 2025taste
Says Goat Hill's crust holds up better once the other pizza has cooled a bit.
- Mixedu/Upper_Maintenance_41 in r/sanfrancisco · Feb 2025taste
Calls Goat Hill a solid neighborhood spot but underwhelming for visitors.
- Recommendsu/Martian-Sundays in r/AskSF · Jan 2025taste
Suggests this as the pick if you want quality from a local chain.
- Caveatu/ELWallStreet in r/sanfrancisco · Nov 2025
Calls the place overhyped.
More maps in San Francisco, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 10 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.