Supreme Pizza, West Seattle
13 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/Seattle, r/AskSeattle, r/SeattleWA15 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Most commenters recommend Supreme, and many name the West Seattle location; some say it works as a New York-style slice. One diner finds the everyday slice good, and one says the U District outlet is very good. Two diners are negative, one saying the West Seattle spot is bad and not open for lunch.
Address
Supreme, 4521 California Ave SW, Seattle, WA 98116
At a glance
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Supreme Pizza, West Seattle, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/spraj in r/Seattle · Nov 2023taste
Lists this among Seattle pizza strong enough to rank in most cities, except possibly New York or New Haven.
- Recommendsu/FrontArmadillo7209 in r/Seattle · Jul 2025
Names Supreme when asked for the best supreme pizza in Seattle.
- Recommendsu/FestiveCrybaby369 in r/Seattle · Jun 2024
Recommends Supreme alongside Hot Mama's as a top local choice.
- Recommendsu/Hold_Effective in r/Seattle · Jun 2024
Ranks Supreme fourth among local picks, with an overall lukewarm view of the local scene.
- Recommendsu/missespanda in r/AskSeattle · Oct 2026
Says they like this West Seattle pizzeria.
- Recommendsu/splanks in r/Seattle · Jan 2026taste
Says Supreme satisfies the NYC slice craving.
- Recommendsu/Longjumping_Ice_3531 in r/SeattleWA · Nov 2025
Recommends the West Seattle Supreme as a good pick, alongside another spot named in the same comment.
- Recommendsu/Raymore85 in r/SeattleWA · Oct 2024
Says Supreme in West Seattle is still their pick.
Show all 15 cited comments
- Recommendsu/Tromp9 in r/SeattleWA · Nov 2025taste
Says the U District Supreme is very good.
- Recommendsu/AnswerFit6984 in r/AskSeattle · Apr 2025
Suggests this West Seattle place as a New York-style option.
- Recommendsu/cascadiaquilts in r/Seattle · Jul 2024variety
Says the U District Supreme location had the taco pizza on Tuesdays, directly answering the question.
- Recommendsu/Lost_Dare_2391 in r/AskSeattle · Jun 2026taste
Thinks the West Seattle location's everyday slice is good and closest to a supreme-style pie.
- Caveatu/Comesontoostrong in r/SeattleWA · Nov 2025
Agrees with the parent's negative take and says they've only eaten there after a night out.
- Recommendsu/chlorpyrifos in r/AskSeattle · Oct 2026
Agrees with the parent's Supreme pick and calls it excellent.
- Caveatu/Mundane-Pop-1383 in r/SeattleWA · Nov 2025
Calls the West Seattle spot bad and notes it's not open for lunch.
More maps in Seattle, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 13 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.