West of Chicago, West Seattle
26 people recommendvia r/Seattle, r/AskSeattle, r/SeattleWA28 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Most commenters recommend West of Chicago's West Seattle spot, and many say it reminds them of Chicago-style pizza. Some praise the deep dish and some the thin tavern-style pie. One diner finds the sauce a bit bland, one found the deep dish underwhelming, and one notes it does not deliver.
Address
West of Chicago Pizza Company, 3770 SW Alaska St, Seattle, WA 98126
At a glance
- Signature dishes
- Deep dish, Tavern style pizza
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to West of Chicago, West Seattle, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/Emotional_Garage_950 in r/Seattle · Jan 2026taste
Calls it pretty good.
- Recommendsu/mondren in r/Seattle · Dec 2025taste
Calls this West Seattle spot pretty solid for Chicago-style pizza.
- Recommendsu/pre_squozen in r/Seattle · Dec 2025taste
Thinks this West Seattle place comes closest to Chicago-style pizza, in their view.
- Recommendsu/good-good-dog in r/AskSeattle · Nov 2025
Names it in a short list of pizza suggestions answering the request.
- Mixedu/Electrical_Nobody196 in r/Seattle · Dec 2025taste
Says this one isn't bad, but finds the sauce a bit bland.
- Recommendsu/WinSome_DimSum in r/SeattleWA · Jul 2026taste
Prefers West of Chicago to Windy City and points to its West Seattle location.
- Recommendsu/Scott2700 in r/Seattle · Jan 2026taste
A recent first visit; liked the deep dish, would return, and found the tavern pizza good too.
- Recommendsu/delicious_things in r/AskSeattle · Nov 2025
Names it among standout local pizza spots in a reply defending the city's pizza scene.
Show all 28 cited comments
- Recommendsu/jmradus in r/Seattle · Oct 2025
Believes this pizza justifies going out of the way to reach West Seattle.
- Recommendsu/krczer in r/Seattle · Jan 2026taste
Enjoys the tavern-style pie and says it reminds them of Chicago.
- Recommendsu/halermine in r/Seattle · Oct 2024
Recommends West of Chicago for Chicago-style pizza, saying they'd be satisfied there.
- Recommendsu/Gabbagool4u in r/SeattleWA · Jul 2026
Answers the best deep dish question by naming West of Chicago.
- Recommendsu/matatat in r/Seattle · Jan 2026taste
Relays a Chicago friend's view that it's solid, though they've never eaten there.
- Recommendsu/add_agro_fennel in r/PNW · Aug 2025
Calls this West Seattle spot good and mentions its Chicago-style pies, including tavern-style options.
- Recommendsu/5MileBurrito in r/SeattleWA · Jun 2025
Lists West of Chicago for deep dish.
- Recommendsu/1983Targa911 in r/Seattle · Mar 2024taste
Suggests the West Seattle location and says its pizza is quite tasty.
- Recommendsu/infinitespectre in r/AskSeattle · Oct 2026taste
Names it as their best Chicago-style choice, also arrived at after years of trying.
- Mixedu/IndominusTaco in r/Seattle · Feb 2026taste
Says the tavern style beats the deep dish, which they found underwhelming.
- Recommendsu/SpicyNoodle4 in r/Seattle · Feb 2026taste
Says the place is good and reminds them of Chicago.
- Recommendsu/Nunyabidnisss in r/Seattle · Jan 2026taste
Tried a meatball version, found it delicious, and praised the cheese pull.
- Recommendsu/Fillmore_the_Puppy in r/Seattle · Jan 2026taste
Likes the deep dish and craves the thin tavern pizza, especially with pepperoni.
- Recommendsu/CharlieWhizkey in r/Seattle · Jan 2026
Votes for it as their pick.
- Recommendsu/kaiju4life in r/Seattle · Jan 2026taste
Prefers this West Seattle spot to Delfino's, though it does not offer delivery.
- Recommendsu/IronDevil74 in r/Seattle · Nov 2025taste
Calls West of Chicago a real treat.
- Recommendsu/Soggy-Market-3800 in r/PNW · Aug 2025taste
Praises this spot's deep dish as solid.
- Recommendsu/Sensitive_Maybe_6578 in r/AskSeattle · Jan 2025ambience
Notes the spot advertises football viewing nights and an arcade room, with easy bridge access and plenty of street parking.
- Recommendsu/LibraryCareful in r/SeattleWA · Nov 2024taste
Calls this West Seattle spot pretty good, a step above the city's mostly decent or weak pizza.
- Recommendsu/alpastoor in r/Seattle · Jan 2026value
Says the tavern-style pie is an excellent deal for the money.
More maps in Seattle, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 13 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.