Athletic Arms
30 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh, r/whisky29 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 21 threads.
What people say, in short
The Athletic Arms, known locally as The Diggers, sits near Dalry cemetery. Many people recommend it, and several praise its whisky range. One patron rates its house beer highly, a couple rank it among the city's best pubs, and several find the drinks good value. One visitor found older regulars sometimes joined their table, which felt awkward but is fine if that doesn't bother you, and one says it is a bit out of the way but worth the trip.
Address
Athletic Arms, 1-3 Angle Park Terrace, Edinburgh EH11 2JX, United Kingdom
At a glance
- Price
- Budget
- Known for
- Whisky selection
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Athletic Arms, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/FliXerock107 in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2026
Rates it among the top pubs in the city and is surprised others would dispute that.
- Recommendsu/ButcherCowpent in r/Edinburgh · Nov 2026
Included in their ranked list of favourite pubs and bars.
- Recommendsu/Gobberlobs in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2026
Named in a walkable group of local pubs the commenter judges decent overall.
- Recommendsu/WearyPrimary2433 in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2024
Top recommendation; notes many central traditional pubs are touristy.
- Recommendsu/ultrafud in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2026
Says it sits where Dalry is on the map, beside the cemetery, and calls it the top pub in the city.
- Recommendsu/37025InvernessTMD in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2026portion
Believes this pub does 35mm measures, though the commenter is not certain.
- Recommendsu/Purple_Toadflax in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2024
Excellent, especially for whisky fans; a bit out of the way but worth the trip.
- Recommendsu/Lopsided_Counter1670 in r/Edinburgh · Dec 2025
Says they're a regular there, which implies they like going.
Show all 29 cited comments
- Recommendsu/reddit_is_for_gimps in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2024
Recommends it; says to search for it under the Athletic Arms name.
- Mixedu/jez_24 in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2025
Reports regulars often joining their table, making one visit awkward; fine if that doesn't bother you.
- Recommendsu/batteredandboozed in r/Edinburgh · Jan 2024variety
Named among whisky pubs said to offer a broader selection.
- Recommendsu/Gyfertron in r/Edinburgh · Jan 2026variety
The bar asked which option was wanted when ordering, a good sign.
- Recommendsu/Pitiful-Breadfruit-4 in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2025
Lists Diggers as a top solo spot, especially if you can get a seat in the dugout.
- Recommendsu/meconopsi in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2025
Calls the pub brilliant for toasties and praises its whisky range.
- Recommendsu/raymondg1902 in r/Edinburgh · Dec 2024
Calls the pub a great boozer in reply, though they had never been in.
- Recommendsu/Shan-Chat in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2024
Named in a list of suggested pubs; says more exist.
- Recommendsu/Striking-Giraffe5922 in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2024
Offers Athletic Arms as a suggestion without further detail.
- Recommendsu/rachbbbbb in r/Edinburgh · Nov 2026
Named as one of their top picks with no further detail.
- Recommendsu/DougalR in r/Edinburgh · Aug 2025price
Recommends trying it for a good-value pint.
- Recommendsu/GingerSnapBiscuit in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2024
Suggested as the pick for Gorgie.
- Recommendsu/porcupineporridge in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2026portion
Agrees the Diggers pub does 35mm and says the measure is advertised on new signage.
- Recommendsu/Amphitrite227204 in r/Edinburgh · Aug 2025price
Enjoys the place and found the session beer affordable.
- Recommendsu/runrunrun800 in r/whisky · May 2025variety
Calls it a must-visit city bar with a huge list, reasonable pricing and slightly bigger pours.
- Recommendsu/RedHal in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2025taste
Suggests ordering the onion-filled toastie variant and rates the house beer highly.
- Recommendsu/Grimfandangotter in r/Edinburgh · Oct 2026value
Says Diggers is good value for drinks, with a strong whisky selection, though a bit farther out.
- Recommendsu/whisky_anon_drama in r/Edinburgh · Aug 2025price
Says cask and most pints there are cheap, citing the Gorgie branch.
- Recommendsu/hrtlssromantic in r/whisky · Feb 2024variety
Named among city spots offering a wide whisky range to try.
- Recommendsu/The_1701 in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2025
Lists Diggers among its personal picks.
- Recommendsu/1bour1scot in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2025variety
Praises the whisky range; notes it once offered buffets for larger groups.
More maps in Edinburgh, United Kingdom
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 17 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.