Best bars in Edinburgh
84 bars that Edinburgh locals recommend — the real reasons, and the caveats.
Edinburgh pubs and bars recommended for beer, whisky and live music, with named branches and disagreements kept visible.
Drawn from real discussions in r/Edinburgh, r/cocktails, r/whisky, r/AskUK and r/Scotland — 84 bars in Edinburgh that people actually recommend. Each one shows why people rate it, the caveats they raised, and a link straight to the original comment — so you read the source yourself instead of trusting a laundered rating. Places cluster around Leith, New Town, Old Town and Tollcross.
How this map is made: Built from 659 Reddit comments across 533 people in r/Edinburgh, r/cocktails, r/whisky, r/AskUK and r/Scotland. Last refreshed November 17, 2026. We paraphrase — never copy — and never take payment for a place. How we make our maps
Showing 84 places
Filters
Map
The map and place list use the same cited directory records. Every public entry has a stable Maps We Made ID and geopoint.
Places
1.Athletic Arms
30 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh, r/whisky
The Athletic Arms, known locally as The Diggers, sits near Dalry cemetery. Many people recommend it, and several praise its whisky range. One patron rates its house beer highly, a couple rank it among the city's best pubs, and several find the drinks good value. One visitor found older regulars sometimes joined their table, which felt awkward but is fine if that doesn't bother you, and one says it is a bit out of the way but worth the trip.
- RecommendsRates it among the top pubs in the city and is surprised others would dispute that. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2026
- MixedReports regulars often joining their table, making one visit awkward; fine if that doesn't bother you. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2025
2.Teuchters, West End
30 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh, r/cocktails
Most commenters recommend this pub, and several patrons praise the food, including fish and chips and hearty dishes. Several also like the drinks and beer selection, and one commenter says it suits rugby viewing. Expect crowds, though: a few people say it gets busy on match days, so seats are not guaranteed, and two commenters say the separate Leith branch, Teuchters Landing, is less packed.
West End
- RecommendsRecommends ending a river walk in Leith by heading to this bar. r/Edinburgh, Jan 2025
- CaveatSays the William Street branch is packed on match days, so seats aren't guaranteed; suggests arriving early. r/Edinburgh, Jan 2024
3.The Bow Bar, Old Town
30 people recommend, 5 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh, r/whisky
Many people recommend The Bow Bar on Victoria Street, mostly for its beer, with cask and keg lines and a good selection on tap, and several point to its whisky. Several find it good value for the city centre. Mixed views include one patron who calls it very good but feels its cellar runs warm for keeping beer in top shape, and another who feels the beer selection has slipped while still counting it among the best Old Town pubs for decent beer. One would rather pick a different pub first, and one visitor found the cheapest whisky pricey.
Old Town
- RecommendsRecommends it for the area around the Royal Mile and Grassmarket. r/Edinburgh, Dec 2025
- CaveatVisited once on a slow evening; found the cheapest whisky pricey and is unsure if the crowd is mostly tourists. r/Edinburgh, Dec 2025
4.Banshee Labyrinth, Old Town
25 people recommend, 5 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh
Overall, people lean towards recommending Banshee Labyrinth, and several say it fits rock, goth or grunge tastes. One patron says they have seen great alternative shows there, a commenter says it tends to run alternative nights, and two commenters mention an in-house cinema. Two commenters say it is crowded, one calls the room small, one patron finds drinks pricey, and another says a membership makes beer budget-friendly. Several are less impressed, one finds it underwhelming next to Bannerman's, two call it one of the few options left, and one commenter says it suits metal and hardcore gigs.
Old Town
- RecommendsCalls it an important local music venue and says they've seen great alternative gigs there. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2026
- CaveatSays drinks here took a big chunk out of their budget in one night. r/Edinburgh, Dec 2024
5.Cloisters, Tollcross
23 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend Cloisters in Tollcross, and several praise its beer, with one visitor calling its cask ale excellent and another noting the range changes often. A couple of people find it budget-friendly. One person calls it a more traditional choice and another says it sometimes comes close to an old-pub feel. One person cautions that conversation can be harder on some days, depending on the crowd.
Tollcross
- RecommendsSuggested as the final stop on the route. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
- MixedAlways recommends it for beer, but notes conversation can be hard depending on the crowd. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
6.The Brass Monkey, Leith
23 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Most people who mention the Brass Monkey recommend it, and several suggest it for drinking on your own. It has several outlets and not every comment says which; a couple name the Leith Walk bar, where one commenter finds it a bit dark but fairly priced and another suggests it for quiet reading over a drink, while others mention the Grange and Shore outlets. One commenter calls it a last stop for seasoned drinkers in Leith, and another says its sofas are closer to beds.
Leith
- RecommendsSuggests it as a cool spot for hanging out solo. r/Edinburgh, May 2026
- MixedSuggests it, but notes its sofas are more bed-like. r/Edinburgh, Apr 2025
7.Bannerman's, Old Town
23 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Most people recommend Bannerman's on the Cowgate, and many commenters point to it for rock and metal. Several commenters mention its live music, one commenter rates the pints and whisky selection highly, and one commenter says the pints are not overpriced for the location. Less favourable views include one commenter who says they have never enjoyed a night there, another who says it has drifted towards older rock and cover acts, and a couple of commenters who say it is pricey. Another says it does not host hardcore gigs, one says it is small and busy for large groups, and a couple see it as one of the few options left rather than a first choice.
Old Town
- RecommendsCalls it an important local venue and says they have seen great alternative gigs there. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2026
- CaveatSays they have never enjoyed a night there. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2026
8.The Jolly Judge, Royal Mile
21 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh, r/whisky
Most people who mention The Jolly Judge recommend it, and it sits just off the Royal Mile. Several patrons praise the beer, and one commenter singles out its rotating craft line-up, while a couple of commenters say the cider selection is good. One patron calls it very cosy, and a couple of commenters say it works well for drinking solo. On the downside, one visitor says the fire is an imitation electric one, and one commenter notes it serves no food.
Royal Mile
- RecommendsSuggested as the next stop on the route. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
- MixedGood if you skip cocktails, though it can get noisy. r/Edinburgh, Apr 2025
9.Lost in Leith
19 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Lost in Leith is a Leith bar that many people recommend, and a few praise its beer, with one patron saying it usually pours a sour and a barrel-aged stout. Two people mention its outdoor seating area, and one of them expects it to catch plenty of sun, while two people mention music events and DJ nights. One patron held a party in a front area that can be reserved and reports there is no bar food, only pizzas that can be ordered in. One person adds that a big dark-beer range isn't guaranteed, though some dark beers should be available.
- RecommendsSuggests Lost in Leith when asked for good taprooms in Edinburgh. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
10.The Guildford Arms
16 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Most people who weigh in recommend The Guildford Arms, with a couple of commenters liking its interior and decor and one commenter saying it reliably has good Scottish ales. One commenter places it close to the station. The main caveat is crowding: many commenters say it gets busy, a couple describe the bar as small, and one patron who found it packed went elsewhere. One commenter says it can be calmer early in the day.
- RecommendsPoints the asker to the Guildford Arms as a pub close enough to walk to. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2026
- CaveatFound the Guildford Arms packed on their visit, so went elsewhere. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2026
11.Sandy Bell's, Old Town
15 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Visitors recommend Sandy Bell's, and several point to its folk and trad music. Others call it lively and sociable, and two visitors say it is easy to strike up a conversation. One visitor likes the lack of background music, while another finds it busier with tourists than The Waverly.
Old Town
- RecommendsSuggested specifically for Scottish folk music. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
12.The Blue Blazer, Tollcross
14 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh
Most visitors recommend the Blue Blazer, and a few name it among their favourite or top bars. One patron praises its range and vibe and finds it mid-priced rather than cheap, another names its cask beer as a favourite, and one visitor calls it a classic boozer with a regular crowd. Two visitors warn: one says they will not return, and another says beer quality has slipped. One patron who no longer rates it says it seems unwelcoming to groups, though solo visits are probably fine, and one visitor finds it more old-fashioned in feel than most.
Tollcross
- RecommendsSuggested as a later stop on the route. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
- CaveatSays they will not return. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2025
13.Panda & Sons
14 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh, r/cocktails
Panda & Sons is a speakeasy-style cocktail bar on Queen Street, and one visitor describes a hidden entrance and themed cocktail menus. Many people recommend it, a few praise its drinks, and two rate it as the best place for cocktails in Edinburgh. A couple of people find it loud, especially near the speakers, and one visitor found it dim and less suited to a first date. A few people think it is overrated or don't see the appeal.
- RecommendsNominates Panda and Sons as a themed pub answer. r/Edinburgh, May 2024
- CaveatDidn't see the hype; felt shabby and neglected with too little atmosphere. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2024
14.The Stockbridge Tap
14 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend this Stockbridge beer bar, mainly for its beer, and one patron calls it the best in town while another rates it the best in Scotland. One commenter points to a larger ale selection than nearby options, and one patron finds it quiet much of the time. On the downside, a couple of commenters warn it does not like large groups, and another patron says a large group was turned away. One commenter feels it has declined since its refit and is no longer focused on beer, while another suggests it for a large group and a different commenter is lukewarm.
- RecommendsIncluded in their ranked list of favourite pubs and bars. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2026
- CaveatSays this pub discourages big groups, pointing to a door sign that says so. r/Edinburgh, Feb 2024
15.The Last Word, Stockbridge
12 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh, r/cocktails, r/whisky
Most commenters recommend this Stockbridge basement bar, and a few of them describe it as cosy. One commenter calls it low-key and peaceful, and two commenters single out the whisky sour, which the bar will tailor to your taste. Another commenter, not naming a location, cautions that it can get very busy and noisy, and a few recommendations don't say which location they mean.
Stockbridge
- RecommendsDescribes this cosy basement bar; says it isn't central either. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2024
- MixedSuggests it alongside the other one, but warns it can get busy and noisy. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2024
16.Cask & Barrel, Southside
12 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
People recommend Cask & Barrel, and a few name its Southside branch among favourite or suggested Edinburgh pubs. Two people describe the Newington and Broughton Street branches as spacious, and one says the Broughton Street branch has good cask ale. One person says the Southside branch is straightforward to reach by bus, and another notes that either branch suits people who don't mind standing at the bar rather than sitting.
Southside
- RecommendsIncluded in their ranked list of favourite pubs and bars. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2026
17.John Leslie's, Newington
12 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh, r/Scotland
Many people recommend John Leslie's, a pub in Causewayside, as a good place for a drink. One patron praises its old-fashioned interior, and another calls it a great spot. One person suggests it for those wanting just a drink and no meal, and one patron says the choice of keg, cask and boxed cider is small.
Newington
- RecommendsIncluded in their ranked list of favourite pubs and bars. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2026
18.The Oxford Bar, New Town
12 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Commenters recommend the Oxford Bar in the New Town, and several people praise its fire, especially in winter. One visitor says it suits reading, and one patron calls it their favourite place to drink alone.
New Town
- RecommendsNames the Oxford Bar as a likely pick for New Town, citing its coal fire and old-school character. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
19.Leith Depot
12 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend Leith Depot in Leith, and a few point to its gigs and club nights. One patron finds it good for a drink and for meeting locals, another calls its alcohol-free pilsner really good, and one regular says young children are welcome. A drinker finds the pint prices fair. The main caveat is one punk and emo fan who says the venue has dropped off in their circle, though they still rate it.
- RecommendsSays they regularly find good gigs and DJ nights at this venue. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2025
20.Kay's Bar
12 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Most people recommend Kay's Bar in Edinburgh's New Town, and a few praise its beer. One person suggests it for an old-fashioned drink at the bar counter, noting it can fill up at times, and a couple suggest it if you're looking for a fire. Two people say it is unlikely to be quiet, though one finds conversation possible and another says you can sit in peace. Two people say the crowd skews posh.
- RecommendsIncluded in their ranked list of favourite pubs and bars. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2026
- CaveatSays it's far from quiet, joking that only someone hard of hearing would find it so. r/Edinburgh, Dec 2024
21.Bramble
12 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh, r/cocktails
Most people recommend Bramble, and a couple say its cocktails are good while a couple describe it as snug or cosy. One person says it is not a quiet place, another says constant loud hip-hop has changed the calmer feel it once had, and one visitor found it quiet on a slow night.
- RecommendsSuggests trying Bramble, though only tentatively. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2025
- CaveatSays it was quieter before the constant loud hip-hop. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2025
22.Nauticus, Leith
11 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh, r/cocktails
Many people recommend Nauticus in Leith. A couple of visitors praise its cosy pub feel, and one visitor rates its drinks nearly as highly as a favourite cocktail spot. Two visitors note it can be quite busy at weekends.
Leith
- RecommendsSuggests Nauticus as a place to check out. r/Edinburgh, Apr 2025
23.Sheep's Heid, Duddingston
11 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend the Sheep's Heid in Duddingston as a stop after a walk through Holyrood Park or around Arthur's Seat. A first-hand visitor found it quiet and enjoyed a game of skittles, and one person suggests it as a stop on a history-themed date. Caveats: one person feels it may have slipped a bit, another warns that the skittles are not really suited to toddlers, and one person advises booking because it gets busy.
Duddingston
- RecommendsRecommends it as a finish to an Arthur's Seat walk, advising booking because it fills up. r/Edinburgh, Jan 2025
- CaveatAfter several visits, says its skittles are not really suited to toddlers. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2026
24.Newbarns, Leith
11 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend Newbarns, a Leith brewery taproom, and one patron finds it cosy but more pub-like. Two patrons praise the beer, with one saying it is the best they have had, while another likes the taproom but finds the beer underwhelming. One patron says evenings and weekends bring families with young children to the tables, and another feels the children run about unsupervised and thinks this has gone too far.
Leith
- RecommendsCalls Newbarns an excellent spot. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
- CaveatEnjoyed evening pints there, but says evenings often have families with young children at tables. r/Edinburgh, Apr 2026
25.Captain's Bar
10 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
People recommend Captain's Bar, and a few say it normally has live music. Two visitors say it's a good place to chat with other drinkers, and a couple of visitors say it suits going on your own. One patron finds it small and crowded, and one visitor warns that chatting to strangers there can draw hard stares.
- RecommendsNamed as a top pick for this visitor's pub plans. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
- MixedLovely atmosphere, though it's small and crowded; still a good pick for chatting. r/Edinburgh, Apr 2026
26.Voodoo Rooms
10 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many commenters recommend the Voodoo Rooms in Edinburgh, and one patron found it quiet and pleasant on a date. One commenter praises its banquet-style seating, another counts it as a late-night music venue, and one doubts it has TVs.
- RecommendsLists the Voodoo Rooms as another good option. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2026
27.The Abbotsford, New Town
10 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend The Abbotsford on Rose Street, and a couple of people suggest it for a central drink. Two people praise the food, and one says it is good value for the location. One person describes an old-school feel but notes that vegetarian options are limited, while another suggests the bar or long tables for conversation. One patron says the upper floor is great and that it may be the best pub they have visited.
New Town
- RecommendsIncluded in their ranked list of favourite pubs and bars. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2026
28.Salt Horse, Royal Mile
10 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh, r/AskUK
Salt Horse sits just off the Royal Mile on Blackfriars Street. Several people praise its beer range, and one says its guest stouts are better than Guinness. One patron finds the small spirits, wine and cider list well chosen and says it is popular for first dates. Overall, people recommend it.
Royal Mile
- RecommendsSuggests Salt Horse for a few drinks if you are near the Royal Mile. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
29.Bennett's, Tollcross
10 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Most people who weigh in on Bennett's in Tollcross recommend it, and many include it in pub lists. One patron calls it great for whisky and mentions old regulars, a historic feel and stools for solo drinkers, while another visitor finds it suited to sketching over a drink. One patron has found it packed with one type of crowd on repeated visits, and two visitors feel it is a different kind of place from traditional old-school pubs.
Tollcross
- RecommendsSuggested as a good pick for sitting at the bar and chatting. r/Edinburgh, Dec 2023
- CaveatHas found it packed with one kind of crowd on each recent attempt to go. r/Edinburgh, May 2026
30.Malt & Hops, The Shore
10 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Many commenters recommend Malt & Hops, and several name it in lists of recommended stops. One patron says the beer is reliably good and the pub feels authentic, and another says it is their regular choice. One patron found a Guinness there pricey. Only one commenter links it to the Shore.
The Shore
- RecommendsLists it among the Leith places worth checking out, in answer to the request. r/Edinburgh, Apr 2025
- CaveatWas surprised by a pricey Guinness there on a visit home. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2025
31.Moonwake, Leith
10 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend Moonwake, a brewery taproom in Leith. One visitor highly rates the black lager and milk stout and finds the taproom an enjoyable place to have a drink. This visitor notes a lift to the mezzanine and an accessible toilet. One person thinks it is not worth visiting, though they rate the other recommended places well.
Leith
- RecommendsLists Moonwake among its taproom suggestions. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
- CaveatJudges Moonwake not worth visiting, but rates the other suggested places highly. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
32.The Royal Oak
10 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend the Royal Oak, and several mention its live music. Three people describe it as friendly or easy to meet people in; one says they reliably find company there when going alone. A few people mention busy crowds. On the downside, two patrons found their visits awkward, overwhelming or lonely, one finds the vibe somewhat strange, one says results vary, and another finds the folk crowd can seem pretentious.
- RecommendsMentioned as an additional option to consider. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
- CaveatSingle past visit on a busy bank holiday evening felt awkward and overwhelming for them. r/Edinburgh, May 2026
33.Hanging Bat, Tollcross
10 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh, r/AskUK
Many people recommend the Hanging Bat for its rotating craft beer range, and one commenter says its guest stouts beat Guinness. Two commenters point to the Lothian Road branch as a good place for beer. Some commenters are less keen: one finds the cask beer poorly handled, another finds the beers too hoppy with small measures, and others strongly dislike the place or find the crowd unpleasant. One patron also calls it pricey, though they still praise the beer.
Tollcross
- RecommendsSuggests the Hanging Bat when asked for good taprooms in Edinburgh. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
- CaveatDislikes it, citing small beer sizes and beers that are too hoppy. r/Edinburgh, Apr 2025
34.The Cumberland
9 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Most people recommend The Cumberland, and several patrons name it among their favourite pubs. A few patrons find it pleasant and nice, and a couple rate the beer decent or good. One patron finds it lacking in atmosphere, another suspects neighbouring structures might keep it shaded, and one notes it is a fair walk.
- RecommendsIncluded in their ranked list of favourite pubs and bars. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2026
- MixedSays it could be a decent pick unless nearby buildings shade it. r/Edinburgh, Apr 2024
35.Roseleaf
9 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend Roseleaf, and several describe it in warm terms as a hidden gem, a lovely little pub, or a favourite. One patron praises its food, drinks and atmosphere, and another suggests it for a date. One patron, after being turned away twice, advises booking a table to eat, and says a drink-only visit to the bar may not be possible when it is busy. A further commenter cannot guarantee it will be lively on a Tuesday.
- RecommendsAlso suggests Roseleaf as another spot to try. r/Edinburgh, Apr 2025
- MixedAdvises booking ahead after being refused entry twice, and notes limited bar standing when busy. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2024
36.Paradise Palms
9 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Most people recommend this cocktail bar, and two diners praise its food and cocktails. Two visitors also enjoy the music, which livens up late on Fridays and Saturdays when the DJs are good. One patron says its events are largely queer and it is a go-to during Pride, while another says people come for the welcoming feel rather than their identity. Opinions split on whether it counts as a gay bar: one visitor says it basically is, another calls it LGBTQ+ friendly and a strong bar but not a gay bar, and one visitor notes the crowd is mostly students.
- RecommendsCalls it nice in a brief endorsement. r/Edinburgh, Jan 2024
- MixedIncluded in a list, but noted as mostly student-only. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2025
37.Mortal Kocktail
9 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Mortal Kocktail is a cocktail bar down an alley just off Cockburn Street, and most people recommend it. Some commenters mention the pinball machines. One patron likes the atmosphere, and another says it suits relaxed late-night hangouts. One commenter calls it a dive bar that isn't necessarily nice, though they still note the pinball and cocktails.
- RecommendsCalls this bar down an alley off Cockburn Street a cool spot. r/Edinburgh, May 2024
- MixedThey find the place a dive bar that is not always pleasant, though it offers pinball and cocktails. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2026
38.Joker & the Thief, Leith
9 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend Joker & the Thief, and one visitor names the Leith Walk bar as their favourite. One patron praises the range of alcohol-free beers. Another says it feels welcoming whether they visit alone or with friends, while one visitor calls it a great pub and a hidden gem that looks unremarkable from outside.
Leith
- RecommendsPraises the music and lively regulars, and strongly recommends it. r/Edinburgh, Dec 2024
39.Bellfield, Leith
9 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
People recommend Bellfield, the Leith brewery; the outlet shown on the map is its Nobles bar on Constitution Street, which two commenters name, while others mean the brewery taproom or its Abbeyhill outlet. Several rate Bellfield highly: one patron praises the beer and food, and another points to a pop-up kitchen that rotates its menu. One patron describes it as closer to a bar with outside space than a pub. On beer, one person says Newbarns' beer is far better, while a different person says Bellfield's beer at Nobles or Abbeyhill is much better than Newbarns'.
Leith
- RecommendsIncluded in their ranked list of favourite pubs and bars. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2026
40.Hey Palu
9 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh, r/cocktails
Many people recommend Hey Palu, and a couple praise the cocktails, with one adding that the snack pairings are excellent too. One finds the menus exciting and the atmosphere modern and cosmopolitan. One patron found it noisy on a previous visit but quiet on another, and one visitor describes the nearby area as a party zone.
- RecommendsCommenter personally likes it and lists it among good after-date drinking options. r/Edinburgh, Apr 2026
- CaveatSays Hey Palu was noisy on their last visit. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2024
41.The Bailie, Stockbridge
9 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend The Bailie in Stockbridge, with one visitor calling it a good pick for sitting at the bar and chatting and another calling it tremendous. One visitor says it has a fire between clock changes each year, and another mentions cask ale. The main caveats are noise and atmosphere: one patron found it too loud for a relaxed chat, another finds it miserable and unpleasant, and a visitor expects it to get loud when football is on. Views on groups are mixed: one visitor thinks it would be a squeeze for a big group depending on timing, while another tentatively suggests it could work for a large group, perhaps with the back half blocked off, and one patron who likes it finds a decent view hard to get.
Stockbridge
- RecommendsNames The Bailie in Stockbridge when asked for bars good for chatting at the bar. r/Edinburgh, Dec 2023
- CaveatFound it too loud for a relaxed chat; will try others. r/Edinburgh, Dec 2024
42.Eastway Tap, Leith
9 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend Eastway Tap, the Easter Road pub, and one commenter says its beer selection is consistently strong. One commenter notes it has cask and keg lines. Food is disputed: one commenter says it doesn't serve food, while another mentions toasties. One commenter thinks it may be the only Easter Road pub without a TV and may have a no-football-shirts rule, but a patron who went for a trad music session found a TV turned up loud with fans shouting and couldn't stay for the music.
Leith
- RecommendsLists Old Eastway Tap among its taproom suggestions. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
- CaveatNotes it turns away people in football colours on matchdays. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2023
43.Starbar
9 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh
Several commenters recommend Starbar, with a few describing its atmosphere as good and one patron saying they like how quiet it is. One commenter says their group regularly meets there, and another mentions a small outdoor garden at the back. A few commenters raise concerns: one says a particular crowd has been taking over the venue, one says it no longer works as a jukebox pick, and one who lives nearby says people leaving late at night are very loud outside. One commenter finds the crowd hit or miss, sometimes students and sometimes locals.
- RecommendsSays this bar has good atmosphere, while noting Edinburgh is pricey overall. r/Edinburgh, Dec 2024
- CaveatSays a particular crowd has been taking the venue over. r/Edinburgh, Jan 2026
44.Whistle Binkies
8 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Most commenters recommend Whistle Binkies, and a few point to its live music. Two commenters mention open mic nights on Mondays, and one praises its vibe and mix. One commenter doubts it stays quiet given its nightly live music, and another wouldn't call it budget-friendly. One calls it an odd bar but predicts a good time, and another says nobody leaves disappointed.
- RecommendsSays this bar fits the requested vibe, though it isn't especially cheap. r/Edinburgh, Dec 2024
- MixedLists it as a possible option but doubts it stays quiet because of nightly live music. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2024
45.Mother Superior, Leith
8 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend Mother Superior, the bar on Leith Walk. One patron recommends it for whisky, citing a very large range, and a visitor counts it among favourites. Another patron who likes it finds it pricey for a small bar.
Leith
- RecommendsSays they regularly find good gigs and DJ nights at this venue. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2025
- MixedLikes Mother Superior but finds it overpriced for such a small bar. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2025
46.The Belfry, Bruntsfield
8 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend The Belfry, and two of them name it for a solo drink. One patron who visited once found it quiet, classy and not pricey, good for conversation, and another points to its rotating taps and large whisky selection. One person says it draws the same crowd as the Ensign Ewart.
Bruntsfield
- RecommendsSays this place reliably has a gluten-free choice available. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2025
47.The Windsor
8 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
The Windsor is a pub on Leith Walk near the Omni Centre, and many commenters recommend it. One patron says the long bar suits sitting alone or joining conversations, and one person calls it a longtime favourite, though they have not visited for some time. One commenter suggests it as a pint option for people who just want a drink. Another patron says they occasionally see children there and that the children are usually quiet.
- RecommendsIncluded in their ranked list of favourite pubs and bars. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2026
48.Black Rose Tavern, New Town
8 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Several patrons praise the jukebox, which one visitor says is mostly metal, and most people recommend this pub on Rose Street. One visitor counts it among the few permanent alternative-music venues left in town. The caveats: one patron finds it pricey, and another who has been there feels the crowd has shifted toward more casual drinkers, though the music is unchanged.
New Town
- RecommendsSays the Black Rose Tavern's jukebox is a good pick, especially for rock, depending on taste. r/Edinburgh, Jan 2024
- CaveatSays it is very expensive. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2026
49.The Antiquary, Stockbridge
8 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Most people recommend The Antiquary, and a few say the food is good, with one patron calling the chips the best they've had. For drinks, one patron at the Stockbridge branch finds a broad range of low- and no-alcohol beers. Sport on the TV comes up a few times. Not everyone names a branch, so some of these views may not apply to Stockbridge.
Stockbridge
- RecommendsSays the pub has a notably broad range of alcohol-free beers; a clear positive on variety. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2026
- CaveatPushes back on the praise, noting the lack of a draught option is the drawback. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2026
50.The Dreadnought, Leith
8 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/Edinburgh
Many commenters recommend The Dreadnought in Leith, and one puts its beer range among the top in the area. One describes the atmosphere as good and welcoming, and one says it is LGBTQ+ friendly, though not a gay bar in the way CC's and Planet are. Other views are more mixed: a few people say it is a little off the main route, though one notes it is easy to reach by tram or bus; a couple of commenters are critical of the atmosphere, with one saying working-class patrons get unwelcoming looks from newer middle-class regulars; and one patron with a child says they were turned away on a visit.
Leith
- RecommendsIncluded in their ranked list of favourite pubs and bars. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2026
- CaveatSays working-class patrons get unwelcoming looks from newer middle-class regulars there. r/Edinburgh, Jan 2024
51.Lady Libertine
7 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Most people recommend Lady Libertine, with one calling it excellent and another describing it as gorgeous. One suggests it as a later stop after a drink elsewhere. One calls it alright, a more lukewarm view.
- RecommendsCommenter personally likes it and lists it among good after-date drinking options. r/Edinburgh, Apr 2026
- MixedDescribes it as passable, a lukewarm rather than enthusiastic view. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
52.The Waverley, Old Town
7 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend The Waverley, a pub just off the Royal Mile on St Mary Street, and a couple of people say it is good for drinking on your own. A couple of people describe a local crowd and friendly regulars, and one person calls it a proper pub. Another says it does a good pint, while one patron says it is small and can be busy. One person agrees it is a good pub but notes it is not a cocktail bar.
Old Town
- RecommendsNamed as a strong solo-drinking option near the Royal Mile; commenter says they drink solo there often. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2024
- MixedAgrees it is a good pub but notes it is not the cocktail bar the asker wanted. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2024
53.The Raeburn
7 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend The Raeburn in Stockbridge, and several point to it for large groups, with one noting it has function rooms with bars. Two think it may be the only pub in the area that can comfortably handle a big party. One adds that a midweek evening is easier than a busy rugby weekend, and one says its ale selection is smaller than that of a larger pub nearby.
- RecommendsSuggests it as one of two pubs suitable for a big group. r/Edinburgh, Feb 2024
54.Ryrie's, Haymarket
7 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many commenters recommend Ryrie's, a pub next to Haymarket Station, and one calls it a good pub. Another suggests it as a good pick for Haymarket. One commenter says it counts as Haymarket rather than Dalry, and another notes that pubs in that area change character on match days.
Haymarket
- RecommendsIncluded in their ranked list of favourite pubs and bars. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2026
55.The Golden Rule
7 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Many people recommend The Golden Rule. One patron sees it as a classic, traditional pub, another rates it very good, and a further visitor calls it delightful. One visitor would rather go there than The Fountain, and another picks it for its character.
- RecommendsRates the Golden Rule highly among the pubs they name. r/Edinburgh, May 2026
56.The Pear Tree
7 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Overall people recommend The Pear Tree. One commenter describes a sizeable beer garden and a big television, and a patron who lives nearby says the outdoor screen makes match days lively. Another finds it cosy on winter weeknights, with a fire to sit by and enough room to read without feeling in the way. One warns that it is a student pub.
- RecommendsDescribes it as a good evening hangout from earlier visits. r/Edinburgh, Apr 2024
- CaveatRaises a pricing reservation, unsure whether it still applies. r/Edinburgh, Aug 2024
57.The Regent
7 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Many commenters recommend The Regent, and two patrons find it friendly. Two say it is quiet or not very crowded in the daytime, though one is unsure how it is in the evenings. One patron who loved it in earlier years doubts a return visit would feel the same. One commenter notes that a local queer network holds regular pub nights here.
- RecommendsCalls the Regent the one casual pub option in the scene. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2025
- CaveatOlder, quieter crowd; thinks it has declined from its earlier standard. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2026
58.Cocktail Geeks
7 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh, r/cocktails
Many people recommend Cocktail Geeks, a cocktail bar where several people say the theme changes every few months. One visitor calls it fun and not too serious, another found the setting atmospheric, and one praises the cocktails as good. One patron found a Mario-themed night disappointing.
- RecommendsNominates this cocktail bar whose geeky themes keep changing. r/Edinburgh, May 2024
- CaveatWent on a Mario-themed night there and found it disappointing. r/Edinburgh, May 2024
59.The Dog House, Southside
6 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend The Dog House, and the Clerk Street branch sits across from the old Odeon cinema. A couple of commenters describe it as alternative, with one noting its unusual decor, while one patron mentions nice locals. Two commenters are less convinced: one patron finds it an odd place that may not suit every visitor, though it can be lively, and another finds The Dog House bleak despite its ceiling decor.
Southside
- RecommendsIncludes this Clerk Street bar among favourites for its alternative feel and nice locals. r/Edinburgh, Dec 2024
- MixedCalls it an odd place, not to everyone's taste, yet lively and hard to see as one of the worst. r/Edinburgh, Jun 2026
60.The Artisan
6 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend The Artisan, with one person calling it a good local pub and another calling it a pleasant, traditional pub. One person says it gets plenty of sun, and another says it has a strong Hibs crowd on match days. One person who grouped it with two other Abbeyhill pubs doesn't find any of them touristy or gritty in style, and has not heard music at any of them.
- RecommendsRates it as a dependable neighbourhood local. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2025
- MixedNot seen as touristy, though not gritty in style; no live music ever heard there. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
61.The Tourmalet, Leith
6 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
People recommend The Tourmalet bar, and those who mention its area place it in Leith. One visitor says the atmosphere is good, and another says a lot of the crowd is LGBTQ+ women. One person counts it among their favourites, alongside bars described as having nice locals and an alternative feel. One visitor is positive overall but adds a caveat.
Leith
- RecommendsLists this bar among favourites for its nice locals and alternative feel. r/Edinburgh, Dec 2024
- MixedSays the bar is good overall but warns people to avoid its washrooms. r/Edinburgh, Dec 2024
62.The Wildcat
6 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend The Wildcat, a cocktail bar in Tollcross, with one describing its drinks as inventive takes on classics and another naming the Pesca Picante as a signature cocktail. One person calls it nice but says it is much like the Raging Bull.
- RecommendsNames Wildcat as the top answer to the cocktail bar request. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2024
- MixedCalls it nice, but its cocktails are pricey and it resembles the Raging Bull. r/Edinburgh, May 2026
63.Carrier's Quarters, The Shore
6 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend Carrier's Quarters, and one patron found a pint there excellent. At the Shore location, another says the crowd is lively without being dull, while one patron notes that quiet is hard to find at the bar, which they see as both good and bad. One patron would pick it over Port of Leith.
The Shore
- RecommendsSuggested as a stop before the final destination. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2024
64.The Ensign Ewart
6 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh, r/whisky
Several commenters recommend The Ensign Ewart, a pub on the High Street near Edinburgh Castle. A few commenters single out its whisky, and one visitor says the ale is well kept despite the central spot. That visitor found it on the pricey side, and one commenter says locals do not go in much, since it sits so near the castle. Another commenter calls it fun.
- RecommendsRated the ale well kept and the whisky excellent, despite it being central and somewhat pricier. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2026
65.The Old Bell, Newington
6 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people suggest The Old Bell in Causewayside, and two say the pub food is decent. One visitor finds it relaxed and well placed between the hills, and one mentions screens for watching sport. One visitor, though, found the vibe odd and the on-tap beer choice limited, and thought John Leslie's might be better.
Newington
- RecommendsNamed as one of four recommended Causewayside pubs; also says it has decent pub food. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2026
66.Robbie's, Leith
6 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend Robbie's, and two people say it is a good spot for a drink. One person finds it unpretentious, with a mix of regulars and well-kept cask beer, though it may have changed since that visit. On food, one person says it does not serve any, while another is unsure, and one describes it as a busy Hibs spot. One person mentions the Leith Walk location specifically.
Leith
- RecommendsRecommends it as an unpretentious spot with mixed regulars and good cask beer, though it may have changed since their last visit. r/Edinburgh, Apr 2025
67.The False Widow, Leith
6 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend The False Widow in Leith as a good place for a drink. One visitor says it is tucked away, so it is less packed, with nice drinks and a cosy, chilled feel. Another patron calls it great.
Leith
- RecommendsSuggests False Widow in Leith when asked for a bar matching this vibe. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2025
68.Duke's, Leith
6 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend Duke's, and one visitor says it has a good beer range and food and suits NFL fans, switching to rugby when no big football match is on. One patron finds the Duke Street branch budget-friendly, and another enjoyed several pints there.
Leith
- RecommendsLists this Duke Street bar as another cheap option matching the post's ask. r/Edinburgh, Dec 2024
70.The Devil's Advocate
6 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh, r/whisky
Two commenters say it suits dates and first meetups, and one says it is a personal favourite. Overall, opinion leans positive. One commenter advises checking first that the venue is suitable if you may struggle with stairs.
- RecommendsCommenter personally likes it and lists it among good after-date drinking options. r/Edinburgh, Apr 2026
- CaveatCautions checking the venue suits anyone who may struggle with stairs. r/Edinburgh, Oct 2026
71.The Safari Lounge, Abbeyhill
5 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend The Safari Lounge, with some praising the food and one patron mentioning good pints and cocktails. Two people find it chilled, with one saying the back is good for reading and weekend evenings get busy and lively. One patron held a 40th party downstairs, where guests could play their own music through the sound system. One visitor has never heard music there.
Abbeyhill
- RecommendsPartner held a 40th there; liked the downstairs room, the option to play own music, and the chilled feel. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2025
- MixedNot seen as touristy, though not gritty in style; no live music ever heard there. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
72.The Street
5 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend The Street, and several describe a friendly crowd where it is easy to make friends. One patron finds it a good place for a relaxed daytime drink, and says it becomes a club downstairs at weekends with more mainstream music. Another calls it a top late-night spot for queer drinkers, but notes the drinks are pricey. Views differ on crowding: one patron finds it comfortable in size and not overly busy, while a different patron describes it as crowded but chatty.
- RecommendsDescribes it as a friendly, general-crowd spot good for daytime drinks, with a club downstairs at weekends. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2026
- MixedCalls it the top queer late-night spot, though notes drinks are pricey. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2025
73.SPRY, Leith
5 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend Spry, and several point to the Leith Walk branch. One patron calls that branch fab, and another lists it among their favourites. Another visitor describes a Scandinavian-style modern look. One patron feels it is pricey.
Leith
- RecommendsCalls the Spry branch on Leith Walk great. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2026
- MixedAgrees the place is worth a look but finds it overpriced. r/Edinburgh, Feb 2026
74.The Barony
5 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend The Barony, a pub on Broughton Street. A few name it among their favourite pubs and bars, and one calls it a great place.
- RecommendsIncluded in their ranked list of favourite pubs and bars. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2026
75.Bowlers Rest, Leith
5 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend Bowlers Rest, a pub in Leith. One patron praises its rotating beer selection, and a couple of people point to its bluegrass sessions, with one saying the sessions make it easier to meet people than a regular pub night. One person suggesting it for bluegrass nights says the venues they list, this one included, are not too loud and have nice seats. Another person rates it highly but notes it is a little further out than the other spots on their list.
Leith
- RecommendsEnjoys the bluegrass session at this pub; says it's easier to meet people there than at standard pub nights. r/Edinburgh, Jan 2026
76.Jingling Geordie's
5 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend Jingling Geordie's, a pub just off the Royal Mile. One visitor suggests it for a quick drink on the way through Waverley station, and another suggests it as a budget-friendly option. One patron finds it consistently friendly, and another says it is good for a pint. One visitor calls it a good local's pub and says there is no live music, though there is an outdoor smoking area.
- RecommendsSuggested as a quick drink on the way through Waverley station. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2024
77.King's Arms, Tollcross
5 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend the King's Arms. One patron describes it as a traditional, old-school pub that has resisted the craft-beer trend, and another calls it their most-loved pub in Edinburgh. Details on the drinks and food are sparse.
Tollcross
- RecommendsCalls it the last traditional local nearby that hasn't gone craft-beer. r/Edinburgh, May 2026
78.Decanter, Bruntsfield
5 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend Decanter, a wine bar in Bruntsfield. One visitor calls it a nice, small place for wine, and another simply says it is great.
Bruntsfield
- RecommendsSuggests Decanter in Bruntsfield in reply to the wine request. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2026
79.Smith & Gertrude, Stockbridge
5 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend Smith & Gertrude, with several naming its Portobello branch and several naming its Stockbridge branch as good places to go. One patron says the Stockbridge wine list is strong, and another finds the Stockbridge cheese board decent.
Stockbridge
- RecommendsCalls the Portobello branch great. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2026
80.Bittersweet, Leith
5 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend Bittersweet, and several mention the Leith location. One patron finds it budget-friendly. Two patrons speak well of the cocktails, and one of them also highlights the Italian sharing plates; another calls the place fab, and a further commenter says it offers something distinctive.
Leith
- RecommendsSays Bittersweet makes many of its own drinks. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2024
81.Lucky Liquor Co, New Town
5 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend Lucky Liquor Co, and three of them name its Queen Street branch. Several praise the drinks, with two singling out the cocktails, and one patron says the Queen Street spot feels quiet, cute and laid back.
New Town
- RecommendsRecommends it for cocktails and likes its quiet, cute, laid-back feel. r/Edinburgh, Jan 2024
82.Keller, New Town
5 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend Keller. One patron, recalling a past visit to the Broughton Street Lane spot, suggests it for a date thanks to its window seats. One patron likes the couch seating area and drinks, another finds the place pleasant, and a commenter says the German beer is a plus. The caveats are that another patron says the window seats are hard to get, one patron feels it lacks coziness and is too open, and that commenter found the Dunkel too distracting to read.
New Town
- RecommendsSuggests it for a date, noting window seats and a layout that keeps it from getting too loud, based on a past visit. r/Edinburgh, Mar 2025
- CaveatSays Keller lacks coziness and feels too spacious and stark. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2025
83.The Penny Black, New Town
5 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Several people recommend The Penny Black, which sits on Leith Street a short walk from the Omni. One patron calls it quite nice, a commenter notes a non-alcoholic beer option, and another says the crowd leans towards rock.
New Town
- RecommendsA good choice, a close walk from the Omni. r/Edinburgh, Apr 2026
- CaveatAuthor visited and again felt lonely there, a negative experience for a solo night out. r/Edinburgh, May 2026
84.Nightcap, New Town
5 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh
Nightcap is a cocktail bar on York Place that many people recommend. One visitor describes a small basement bar that is good for dates, with a great cocktail menu and beer also served. One patron who has visited says it was once great but has declined somewhat.
New Town
- RecommendsSays Nightcap is likely the closest match for this look in the city. r/Edinburgh, Sep 2025
- CaveatSays it was once excellent but has declined somewhat. r/Edinburgh, Nov 2024
Questions people ask
- Which bars do Edinburgh locals recommend most?
- Right now the most-recommended are Athletic Arms, Teuchters, West End and The Bow Bar, Old Town, ranked by how many different people vouched for each one. Every place lists the reasons people gave and the caveats they raised, with a link to the original comment.
- How is this list made?
- It is built from public Reddit discussions — 659 comments from 533 people across r/Edinburgh, r/cocktails, r/whisky, r/AskUK and r/Scotland. We paraphrase why each place is recommended, keep the negatives and caveats in, and link to the original comment so you can read the source yourself. We never invent details.
- Are these paid placements?
- No. Nothing here is sponsored, paid or ranked by a business. Places are included only because real people recommended them in public conversations, and every claim links back to its source.
- How recent are these recommendations?
- This map was last refreshed November 17, 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time, so confirm current details directly before you rely on them.
Did this page answer your question?
More maps to explore
Edinburgh
Best breakfast
Edinburgh breakfast recommendations, from full Scottish breakfasts to rolls and café brunches, with the specific venues and caveats in the source conversations.
Open the mapEdinburgh
Best cafés
Edinburgh coffee shops and bakeries discussed for espresso, beans, cakes and pastries, with queue and seating caveats alongside the recommendations.
Open the mapEdinburgh
Indian restaurants
Indian dining in Edinburgh, from South Indian dosas to shared small plates, with the cited recommendations and disagreements about food and service.
Open the mapEdinburgh
Best restaurants
People steer friends in Edinburgh toward Soul Vegan for its laksa, Chez Jules for the lunch deal, Dishoom for okra fries and black daal, Gautam's for nihari gosht, Noto for butter crab, and Noodles & Dumplings for soup noodles, though you will need cash there.
Open the mapEdinburgh
Places to visit
Edinburgh recommendations run from museums to garden and riverside walks: the free National Museum of Scotland, which people return to again and again, a relaxed stroll at the Royal Botanic Garden, Dean Village on a Water of Leith walk to Stockbridge, the murals at the Scottish National Portrait Gallery and the closes off the Royal Mile, though its shops lean to souvenirs.
Open the map