Bannerman's, Old Town
23 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh29 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Most people recommend Bannerman's on the Cowgate, and many commenters point to it for rock and metal. Several commenters mention its live music, one commenter rates the pints and whisky selection highly, and one commenter says the pints are not overpriced for the location. Less favourable views include one commenter who says they have never enjoyed a night there, another who says it has drifted towards older rock and cover acts, and a couple of commenters who say it is pricey. Another says it does not host hardcore gigs, one says it is small and busy for large groups, and a couple see it as one of the few options left rather than a first choice.
Address
Bannerman's Bar, 212 Cowgate, Edinburgh EH1 1NQ, United Kingdom
At a glance
- Best for
- Live music
- Opinions divided
- Yes
- Known for
- Live music
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Bannerman's, Old Town, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/mizzlemoonn in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2026
Calls it an important local venue and says they have seen great alternative gigs there.
- Recommendsu/st_owly in r/Edinburgh · Oct 2025
Recommends this bar for rock and metal gigs.
- Caveatu/Joy-of in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2026
Says they have never enjoyed a night there.
- Recommendsu/fiftyseven in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2025
Names Bannerman's as the top pick for this request.
- Recommendsu/DayMan_94 in r/Edinburgh · Dec 2024
Says this bar fits the requested vibe, though it isn't especially cheap.
- Recommendsu/Shan-Chat in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2024
Suggested as the best fit for someone wanting punk or metal.
- Mixedu/TheRealSpaldy in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2026variety
Calls it a good gig venue but says it has drifted towards older rock and cover acts.
- Recommendsu/Saint_Sin in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2025
Says it is on the same Cowgate street and often has live music.
Show all 29 cited comments
- Recommendsu/KodiakVladislav in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2026variety
Says it books almost any act, so narrow bills reflect the scene rather than the venue.
- Recommendsu/BassMilitant in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2026ambience
Calls this a great hangout that welcomes more casual visitors than before.
- Recommendsu/SloanWarrior in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2026
Includes this pub in the same short list of recommended spots.
- Recommendsu/Ok_Employer4583 in r/Edinburgh · Dec 2024value
Says it's dingy and music-focused and not overpriced for pints given its location.
- Recommendsu/GeekyGamer2022 in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2026
Counts it among the few remaining traditional rock bars.
- Recommendsu/savagesoundsystem in r/Edinburgh · Oct 2025
Says it should be added to the list.
- Mixedu/cthulu_is_trans in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2026variety
Says Bannerman's does not host hardcore gigs, which they accept as fair, and that Banshees suits that style better.
- Mixedu/MotorVariation8 in r/Edinburgh · Apr 2026
Sees these two as the only options left, a resigned rather than enthusiastic pick.
- Mixedu/User-Name-3886 in r/Edinburgh · Aug 2026ambience
Says it draws an older crowd, costs more, and is cramped for big groups.
- Recommendsu/IronAffectionate5936 in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2025
Says it was a longtime favourite, though they haven't been in for a while.
- Recommendsu/Unlikely_Project7443 in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2025
Says Bannerman's is the place to go over the others mentioned.
- Recommendsu/Traditional-Swan-130 in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2025ambience
Calls it the best bet, with a dark rock and metal feel and frequent live bands.
- Recommendsu/Volfgang91 in r/Edinburgh · Nov 2026
Named as one of their top picks with no further detail.
- Recommendsu/ChaoticSalvation in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2025ambience
Says it fits the rock vibe the request is after.
- Recommendsu/Siphilator in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2026
Calls it the main rock venue with constant live music and Sunday open mics.
- Recommendsu/hengus in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2026
Includes it in a short list of recommended spots.
- Mixedu/Own_Mammoth9488 in r/Edinburgh · Apr 2026
Suggests it could be a suitable stand-in for Legends if its setup suited that role.
- Recommendsu/alphabetown in r/Edinburgh · Feb 2026
Listed among venues their punk and emo circle still rates.
- Recommendsu/nuedd in r/Edinburgh · Oct 2025
Says venues are fine, Bannermans helped them find a favourite band, but almost none of the bands they like book there.
- Recommendsu/Maximum_Ambition_591 in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2025
Suggests Bannermans as a pick.
- Recommendsu/logielogie44 in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2025taste
Rates its beer as the best in the city and likes the whisky range and music.
More maps in Edinburgh, United Kingdom
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 17 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.