Kay's Bar
12 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh15 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Most people recommend Kay's Bar in Edinburgh's New Town, and a few praise its beer. One person suggests it for an old-fashioned drink at the bar counter, noting it can fill up at times, and a couple suggest it if you're looking for a fire. Two people say it is unlikely to be quiet, though one finds conversation possible and another says you can sit in peace. Two people say the crowd skews posh.
Address
Kay’s Bar, 39 Jamaica St, Edinburgh EH3 6HF, United Kingdom
At a glance
- Opinions divided
- Yes
- Known for
- Cask beer, Bar counter drinking
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Kay's Bar, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/ButcherCowpent in r/Edinburgh · Nov 2026
Included in their ranked list of favourite pubs and bars.
- Caveatu/nibutz in r/Edinburgh · Dec 2024ambience
Says it's far from quiet, joking that only someone hard of hearing would find it so.
- Recommendsu/HoldenHiscock69 in r/Edinburgh · Nov 2024ambience
Suggested for a traditional, old-fashioned bar-counter drink, though it can fill up with a crowd at times.
- Recommendsu/Purple_Toadflax in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2024ambience
Great pint spot away from tourists; crowd can skew a bit posh.
- Recommendsu/IndependentKey8467 in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2025service
Says regulars are friendly and solo drinkers can sit quietly.
- Recommendsu/Outrageous-Cattle874 in r/Edinburgh · Aug 2026ambience
Recommends Kay's Bar in answer to the fire question.
- Recommendsu/Specific_Report2517 in r/Edinburgh · Aug 2026ambience
Suggests Kay's as a pub to try for a fire.
- Recommendsu/throwaway5746348 in r/Edinburgh · Nov 2026
Listed among quirky favourites chosen for character rather than strict ranking.
Show all 15 cited comments
- Recommendsu/Otherwise_Type6223 in r/Edinburgh · Jan 2026
Calls it a great all-round pub with easy street parking out front and level access inside.
- Recommendsu/farcetasticunclepig in r/Edinburgh · Apr 2025taste
Notes it repeatedly wins a CAMRA award for top cask quality.
- Recommendsu/AraiHavana in r/Edinburgh · Jun 2026
Says the Kasbar was truly special back in its earlier period.
- Recommendsu/therealverylightblue in r/Edinburgh · Dec 2024
Calls it also good.
- Mixedu/Boomdification in r/Edinburgh · Jan 2024
Praises the beer but says the clientele is very posh.
- Recommendsu/Awkward-Language-861 in r/Edinburgh · Dec 2023ambience
Suggested as another pub that comes to mind for drinking without sport on.
- Mixedu/Necessary-Most-3991 in r/Edinburgh · Dec 2024ambience
Says it's not usually quiet, but the beer is good and conversation is possible.
More maps in Edinburgh, United Kingdom
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 17 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.