The Guildford Arms
16 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Edinburgh19 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Most people who weigh in recommend The Guildford Arms, with a couple of commenters liking its interior and decor and one commenter saying it reliably has good Scottish ales. One commenter places it close to the station. The main caveat is crowding: many commenters say it gets busy, a couple describe the bar as small, and one patron who found it packed went elsewhere. One commenter says it can be calmer early in the day.
Address
The Guildford Arms, 1 W Register St, Edinburgh EH2 2AA, United Kingdom
At a glance
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to The Guildford Arms, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/Cockjuggling in r/Edinburgh · Oct 2026
Points the asker to the Guildford Arms as a pub close enough to walk to.
- Recommendsu/Rather_good in r/Edinburgh · Oct 2026
Endorses the Guildford Arms as a solid choice for the first meeting.
- Recommendsu/TheRank_Badjin in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2024
Suggested as the starting point of a pub route.
- Recommendsu/ButcherCowpent in r/Edinburgh · Nov 2026
Included in their ranked list of favourite pubs and bars.
- Recommendsu/Purple_Toadflax in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2024ambience
Among the best New Town options; gets packed, but quieter earlier in the day.
- Recommendsu/AblePhase in r/Edinburgh · Oct 2026ambience
Finds the Guildford Arms nice inside, though it can get busy depending on the time.
- Recommendsu/Specific_Current4487 in r/Edinburgh · Oct 2026
Includes the Guildford Arms in its list of suggestions.
- Mixedu/cloud__19 in r/Edinburgh · Aug 2024ambience
Finds the small bar badly crowded with people leaning on it.
Show all 19 cited comments
- Recommendsu/JMWTurnerOverdrive in r/Edinburgh · Apr 2026
Suggests it as one of a few places worth trying.
- Recommendsu/charliewest0 in r/Edinburgh · Apr 2025consistency
Says it is reliably good and adds it as another pick.
- Mixedu/strawberrydandon in r/Edinburgh · Oct 2026
Rates the Guildford Arms highly, likely the top local option by the station, yet often crowded.
- Recommendsu/harpistic in r/Edinburgh · May 2026ambience
Liked it; very small, so best when it is not too busy.
- Recommendsu/Alarming_Taste3730 in r/Edinburgh · Nov 2026
Described it as a deeply personal favourite of theirs.
- Recommendsu/Shan-Chat in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2024
Named in a list of suggested pubs.
- Recommendsu/GeekyGamer2022 in r/Edinburgh · Oct 2026
Lists the Guildford Arms on West Register Street and calls it excellent.
- Recommendsu/mckvlt in r/Edinburgh · Nov 2026
Named among their favourite spots with no further detail.
- Caveatu/Youngy_Bhoy in r/Edinburgh · Oct 2026wait time
Found the Guildford Arms packed on their visit, so went elsewhere.
- Recommendsu/spr148 in r/Edinburgh · Oct 2026
Named with Abbotsford as a central drinking option.
- Recommendsu/Stewmelbill in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2024variety
Says it reliably has strong Scottish ales and a stunning interior.
More maps in Edinburgh, United Kingdom
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 17 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.