The Jolly Judge, Royal Mile
21 people recommendvia r/Edinburgh, r/whisky23 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Most people who mention The Jolly Judge recommend it, and it sits just off the Royal Mile. Several patrons praise the beer, and one commenter singles out its rotating craft line-up, while a couple of commenters say the cider selection is good. One patron calls it very cosy, and a couple of commenters say it works well for drinking solo. On the downside, one visitor says the fire is an imitation electric one, and one commenter notes it serves no food.
Address
7, Jolly Judge, 493 James' Ct, Lawnmarket, Edinburgh EH1 2PB, United Kingdom
At a glance
- Best for
- Craft beer
- Known for
- Rotating craft beer, Cider and perry, Cask and keg beer
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to The Jolly Judge, Royal Mile, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/TheRank_Badjin in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2024
Suggested as the next stop on the route.
- Recommendsu/ButcherCowpent in r/Edinburgh · Nov 2026
Included in their ranked list of favourite pubs and bars.
- Recommendsu/nibutz in r/Edinburgh · Nov 2024
Recommends it for solo drinking, close to the Royal Mile, from someone who often drinks alone.
- Recommendsu/Purple_Toadflax in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2024
Worth a visit in the Old Town.
- Recommendsu/vivalanation734 in r/Edinburgh · Aug 2026ambience
Names The Jolly Judge when asked for pubs with lit fires.
- Recommendsu/MJCAudio in r/Edinburgh · Sep 2025
Suggests starting at the Jolly Judge before moving on as a solo route.
- Recommendsu/Snell84 in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2024
Says it is a good spot for spending a long afternoon out.
- Recommendsu/Amphitrite227204 in r/Edinburgh · Aug 2025price
Says a good-quality pint is available there at a reasonable cost, unlike pricier nearby venues.
Show all 23 cited comments
- Recommendsu/Specific_Current4487 in r/Edinburgh · Oct 2026
Suggests the Jolly Judge as a pub worth visiting.
- Recommendsu/EastyLUFC in r/Edinburgh · Aug 2025
Calls it a great pub that earns its place on the list.
- Recommendsu/showna15 in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2024taste
Recommends Jolly Judge for consistently good beers.
- Recommendsu/penguin62 in r/Edinburgh · Dec 2023ambience
Pleasant blend of regulars and visitors; disruptive groups get turned away, and they always enjoy it.
- Recommendsu/portbeans in r/Edinburgh · Apr 2024
Praised as a strong all-round spot; kids over five reportedly welcome outdoors before 10, but no food.
- Recommendsu/Particular-Name-7177 in r/Edinburgh · Aug 2025variety
Rates it the top independent beer spot in town, admiring its rotating, mostly craft range.
- Recommendsu/FliXerock107 in r/Edinburgh · Apr 2025
Suggested as a top pick; located near the Royal Mile.
- Recommendsu/ScottishTrader in r/whisky · Feb 2024variety
Suggests this less obvious close pub for its good whisky selection and fewer tourists.
- Recommendsu/ProfessionalStay5797 in r/Edinburgh · Aug 2026
Calls The Jolly Judge one of their favourite places in town.
- Recommendsu/sapphire-coast in r/Edinburgh · Jul 2026variety
Says this pub usually offers a strong range of ciders and perry.
- Mixedu/Sakiaba in r/Edinburgh · Apr 2025ambience
Good if you skip cocktails, though it can get noisy.
- Recommendsu/Stuu666 in r/Edinburgh · Mar 2025variety
Says this pub is a dependable pick for anyone who likes cider.
- Recommendsu/Certes_ in r/Edinburgh · Dec 2025
Points readers to the Jolly Judge as a worthwhile nearby alternative.
- Mixedu/edi_blah in r/Edinburgh · Aug 2026ambience
Rates The Jolly Judge highly but says its fire is an electric one.
- Recommendsu/ScottishDanOWar in r/Edinburgh · Apr 2025
Agrees with the Jolly Judge suggestion.
More maps in Edinburgh, United Kingdom
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 17 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.