Best pizza in New York

146 people recommend, 40 warn against itcounted across its outletsvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC, r/nyc

Joe's recommendations span its New York outlets, including Fulton Street. Fans value the classic slice, and a Village regular praises the balance of chewy-crisp dough, cheese and acidic sauce. A diner specifically describes the Fulton Street shop as solid, with a fast-moving line. Other locations draw late-night praise, but critics report cold or forgettable slices and question whether the reputation still matches the pizza.

FIDI

143 people recommend, 19 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

L'Industrie earns strong recommendations across its New York locations, including West Village. The burrata slice and fig-and-bacon slice draw repeated praise. Fans rank it near the top of their personal lists, but others find the wait hard to justify. Individual diners describe salty slices or an unevenly thick base, and some consider it expensive. Those reservations sit alongside enthusiastic praise rather than a unanimous verdict.

West Village

90 people recommend, 14 warn against itcounted across its outletsvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Mama's Too is recommended across its New York outlets, including West Village. Specialty slices are the recurring draw, including a pear, gorgonzola and hot honey combination and the Angry Nonna. A diner enjoys several varieties but dislikes the elote, while individual diners find the pizza greasy or salty. Long waits and a cumbersome ordering experience are recurring caveats, with some diners saying good pizza does not justify the queue.

West Village

85 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia X, r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC, r/nyc

John's of Bleecker Street draws strong recommendations for whole pies rather than individual slices. A diner credits the coal-fired oven with a distinctive smoky flavor, and several visitors prefer it to other well-known pizza stops. A diner names the picante as a usual order. Not everyone shares the enthusiasm: some visitors find the pizza average or overhyped. The repeated praise is for this Bleecker Street shop, not the separate theater-district John's.

52 people recommend, 11 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

L&B Spumoni Gardens has a strong following for its thick Sicilian square. Fans describe it as distinctive, and one visitor praises eating a tray outside with family. The style does not suit everyone: a nearby diner prefers the round slice and finds the square too heavy on sauce and crust. Others call it overrated or feel the quality has slipped. Its strongest appeal is the square itself, not universal agreement that every slice is exceptional.

Brooklyn

51 people recommend, 21 warn against itvia X, r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Scarr's draws strong praise for its New York slices, with pepperoni and Hotboi repeatedly singled out. A visitor calls it an excellent example of the style, and fans place it high on personal pizza lists. There is substantial dissent too: diners describe it as underwhelming or say the quality has slipped. Lines are another concern. It is popular and genuinely contested, not a unanimous favorite.

Lower East Side

49 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Lucia's SoHo and Avenue X shops draw recommendations for their slices. Fans of the SoHo shop praise the plain cheese slice and compare it favorably with other specialty-slice destinations. A visitor finds it crisp and light, while another thinks the vodka slice needs more sauce. A critic suggests dropping it from a crowded pizza itinerary.

Soho

48 people recommend, 12 warn against itvia r/AskNYC, r/FoodNYC

NY Pizza Suprema near Penn Station remains a frequent recommendation for a classic slice. Diners praise the plain cheese slice, and a regular singles out the Pepperoni Fra Diavolo whole pie. Other visitors find the pizza merely fine, say newer shops have overtaken it, or feel quality has declined. Cost is another recurring complaint, so the convenient location and loyal following come with meaningful dissent.

Penn Station Manhattan

44 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Patsy's original East Harlem shop draws strong recommendations for coal-oven pizza and a straightforward cheese slice. Diners name it among their favorite Manhattan slices, and a visitor recommends the vodka pie with garlic. Some longtime customers feel it no longer reaches its earlier peak, even while still calling it good. These recommendations concern East Harlem; similarly named locations elsewhere are not treated as interchangeable.

East Harlem

44 people recommend, 17 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC

Una Pizza Napoletana draws praise for Neapolitan-style pizza, especially the airy, chewy crust. Enthusiasts rank it among their favorite pies, while critics find it wet, bland or dominated by bread. Getting a table and the cost are recurring reservations. It is a distinctly divisive choice rather than an automatic upgrade over a classic New York slice.

LES

37 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC

F&F on Court Street draws repeated recommendations for its slices, including clam pizza and the tomato Sicilian. A diner praises the Partanna slice's crust while finding it slightly sweet. Another visitor thinks the cheese slice recalls older New York pizza. Cost draws reservations, and a diner prefers eating the slice in the shop to delivery. Some diners are much less enthusiastic and describe the pizza as weak.

Brooklyn

37 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/nyc, r/AskNYC

Luigi's in Brooklyn draws strong recommendations for a straightforward New York slice. A visitor ranks it first on a pizza trip, while others value the quality for the cost. Individual diners recommend the grandma pie or Sicilian marinara. Critics find it merely fine, mediocre or less impressive than its reputation suggests, and a visitor reports a burned slice despite wanting to return. Praise for a classic neighborhood slice is stronger than agreement that it warrants every cross-city trip.

Brooklyn

37 people recommend, 20 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Prince Street Pizza draws strong opinions, with many people recommending it and a sizable group warning against it. Fans praise the pepperoni square, the vodka slice, and the Spicy Spring, and one diner rates it their top square slice in the city. Others report burnt, dry, or underheated slices and long lines, and one visitor found the vodka slice at San Gennaro pretty bad. One commenter considers the traditional slice decent and worth trying.

Soho

33 people recommendvia X, r/FoodNYC

Fini earns recommendations across its New York shops, including Williamsburg. The white slice with lemon and the tomato slice attract repeated praise, and a diner particularly enjoys the tomato slice's garlic breadcrumbs. Another names the long hot shallot as a signature. Dissent is narrower but real: one visitor finds the white slice only ordinary despite the lemon, and another notes that the tomato pie is spicy.

Williamsburg

33 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Rubirosa draws strong recommendations for pizza, with the Tie Dye singled out by name. A diner enjoys its saucier style, and a visitor ranks it among the front runners on a pizza trip. Reservations can be difficult. Critics find it less compelling as a destination, and individual visitors report burned cheese or a disappointing pie. The substantial following does not eliminate those mixed experiences.

32 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Song' E Napule draws recommendations across its New York locations, including Houston Street. Fans consider its Neapolitan pizza a strong expression of the style, and individual diners recommend the margherita or fried pizza. Others find the pizza soggy or less compelling than rival Neapolitan shops. A visitor also feels rushed during a busy period.

Houston

31 people recommend, 7 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Paulie Gee's recommendations span its New York locations and formats, including the Greenpoint Slice Shop. Diners recommend the Hellboy, and one particularly enjoys hot honey pepperoni, while a visitor to the East Village slice shop praises its classic cheese slice. Others find the pizza mediocre or soggy.

Greenpoint

29 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Best Pizza in Williamsburg draws repeated praise for its white slice, with the grandma slice also recommended. A diner describes it as a notably light slice, and another likes its vegetable toppings. Others think the quality or consistency has declined, and a visitor calls it tasty but expensive.

Williamsburg

27 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/FoodNYC

Sal and Carmine's is repeatedly recommended for an old-school Upper West Side slice. Several diners describe it as a classic, and the white slice also has a fan. A diner values it for a quick traditional slice. The enthusiasm is not absolute: one diner sees the history and neighborhood appeal but considers it, ultimately, an ordinary slice, while another says nostalgia contributes to its reputation.

Upper West Side

26 people recommend, 8 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/nyc, r/AskNYC

Lucali inspires enthusiastic praise for its pizza, but the reservation process is a recurring reason people hesitate. Fans describe memorable pies and rank it among their favorites. Other diners enjoy it without finding it exceptional, and some prefer the calzone. Long in-person waits and the possibility of a very late table lead several visitors to favor easier alternatives despite liking the pizza.

Carroll Gardens Brooklyn

26 people recommend, 11 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC, r/nyc

Roberta's recommendations span its New York locations, including the Bushwick original. Fans praise its distinctive pizzas, and a diner calls Bushwick a favorite for non-standard New York pizza. Others find it merely good or overrated, and some feel it has declined. Experiences at other outlets are part of the wider pool rather than guarantees about Bushwick. The substantial following comes with meaningful disagreement about whether a special trip is worthwhile.

Bushwick Brooklyn

25 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/nyc

Ops in Bushwick draws recommendations for its sourdough square and marinara pie. A diner calls this location world class, citing the wood-fired oven, and another recommends the potato and broccoli rabe pizza. Several describe the style as neo-Neapolitan rather than a classic New York slice. Diners also point out that it is a whole-pie destination. One critic considers it overrated.

Bushwick

23 people recommendvia X, r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

New Park Pizza in Howard Beach draws strong praise for its traditional slices, with one diner naming it their top traditional pizza pick anywhere in the city and another ranking it number one. One person praises the Sicilian slices, while another recommends the plain or pepperoni. More than one advises ordering slices well done for a crisper bottom, and one commenter notes the cheese blend is a little different from a standard New York slice, in a good way. It is a destination worth a bus ride for some, though one person says it is the only reason to visit the neighborhood.

Howard Beach

23 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Stretch receives recommendations in Manhattan and Brooklyn. Fans enjoy unusual toppings and substantial slices; a Brooklyn-specific recommendation praises the crust and execution. Other diners find the pizza merely fine or not worth returning for. Historical comments about Manhattan reservations and the sit-down experience are not treated as current features of the Brooklyn pin.

Brooklyn

22 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Joe and Pat's is recommended across its New York locations, including the Staten Island original. Fans praise thin-crust whole pies, and a visitor singles out the Tri Pie. A diner also recommends a vodka pie with sausage. An East Village visitor finds a personal pizza expensive and middling, while wanting to try Staten Island before judging the original.

Staten Island

22 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC

Cello's on St Marks draws recommendations for its slices, including burrata, chicory and bacon, and marinara. Some visitors place it among their favorite downtown stops. Others find the crust disappointing or the pizza overly salty; one diner likes the vodka slice but finds the rest ordinary. A regular still relies on it despite reporting a burned pie. Those contrasting experiences make it more than a simple hype-versus-hidden-gem story.

St Marks

21 people recommend, 6 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Bleecker Street Pizza draws steady praise for its slices, with the Nonna Maria named as a favorite by several people and the grandma slice also singled out. One visitor called it the best of the few places they tried, and another said it tasted as good as remembered after a long gap. Views are not unanimous: a few people were disappointed, with one saying a recent pie fell short and another finding it has been surpassed by newer spots.

West Village

21 people recommend, 7 warn against itvia r/astoria, r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Rosario's in Astoria draws a loyal following for pizza, with diners naming it among their Queens favorites. The sauce divides people: some find it too sweet or lacking flavor, and other visitors describe the pizza as mediocre or overly salty. Even among the mixed views, some still call it a good slice. The support is substantial without being unanimous.

Astoria

21 people recommend, 15 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Di Fara receives both loyal recommendations and substantial criticism. Recommendations include Midwood and other New York locations. Fans praise the regular slice and Sicilian, but diners also describe inconsistent quality or feel the trip to Midwood is no longer justified. One visitor thinks it has improved again.

Midwood Brooklyn

20 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/bronx, r/AskNYC

Louie and Ernie's draws strong Bronx recommendations, with the sausage pie particularly praised by a diner and the Grandma pie favored by another. A longtime customer still enjoys it but is less enthusiastic than before. Another commenter relays uneven results from family members who still visit frequently, and notes that reaching it can require an extra bus trip. Its loyal following comes with reservations about consistency and convenience.

Bronx

19 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/astoria

Rosa's recommendations span its New York locations, including Maspeth. Diners specifically praise the Maspeth shop's Sicilian and grandma slices, and one compares its upside-down Sicilian favorably with L&B. Other locations draw recommendations for eggplant or vodka slices. The Astoria shop also receives mixed views about value and whether the pizza is exceptional; those are not presented as experiences at Maspeth.

Maspeth

19 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC, r/astoria

Wheated is a Brooklyn pizzeria that many people recommend, with several describing its pies as New Haven style and one calling it the first place that comes to mind for that style in the borough. One commenter praises the sourdough crust and the bar, and another says they have never had a bad pie there. The picture is not unanimous: one diner finds the pizza inconsistent at times while still considering it a good option, and another says the regular menu pie is only New Haven inspired, with the closest version appearing as an occasional special.

Brooklyn

19 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Mimi's recommendations span its New York locations, including East 86th Street. Fans of the Upper East Side shop praise its basic slice and squares, including pepperoni. A diner wants to return after trying it on a recommendation. Another enjoys it without understanding the acclaim, and one visitor dislikes it altogether. Praise for a chicken bacon ranch slice elsewhere in the pool is not assigned to this outlet.

86th

19 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC

Brooklyn DOP earns recommendations across its Park Slope and Clinton Hill shops, including Park Slope. Fans praise the crust and slices, and a diner singles out the Nonna Mena with pepperoni. Some regard it as comparable to better-known pizza destinations, while others find it merely good or not worth a special trip. Slow ordering draws complaints, while a diner finds the slice thicker and doughier than expected.

Park Slope

18 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Ace's draws New York recommendations for Detroit-style pizza, including Williamsburg. Fans put it among their preferred pizza stops, and a diner enjoys taking visitors there. Value divides people: one finds it tasty but expensive, while another considers a personal pie good value. Other commenters recommend it alongside different Detroit-style options. The appeal is that square-pie style, rather than a replacement for a classic thin New York slice.

Williamsburg

18 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Philomena's in Sunnyside draws steady praise for its pizza, with people describing the crust as sourdough-leaning and more New York style than Neapolitan. One visitor highlights the white pie as really good, and another calls the square slice the best around with a standout crust. A couple of diners name it as a go-to or a hands-down recommendation in the neighborhood.

Sunnyside

18 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/statenisland

Denino's recommendations span its New York locations, including Staten Island. Diners specifically recommend the Staten Island shop, and others praise whole pies or clam pizza across the wider pool. A visitor to the Village location particularly enjoys the clam pie.

Staten Island

18 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Kesté draws steady praise for its Neapolitan pizza, with the margherita singled out as a favorite and the gluten-free pie called excellent. One commenter recommends it for a sit-down Neapolitan meal, and another notes the lunch pizza has stayed budget-friendly for years. Views are not unanimous: one diner found the Financial District location disappointing and pricey, with dough that did not seem traditional, and another found the montanara sauce too strong.

Fulton St

18 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC

Dani's House of Pizza in Kew Gardens has a loyal following for its pesto slice and distinctive sweet sauce. A visitor considers it worth a stop on a Queens food tour, and a regular describes grabbing slices after a nearby class. The sauce is also the main divide: several diners find it too sweet, and others criticize the regular slice or modest portions. It is a strong choice for fans of that style, not a consensus pick for every pizza preference.

Kew Gardens

17 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/astoria

Mano's is a Ridgewood pizzeria that diners name among their favorite slice shops, and a few rank it at the top of the city or the outer boroughs. One diner who had a plain slice thought it was good but not the best in the city. Several people recommend it as worth seeking out, though one notes it is somewhat off the beaten path.

Ridgewood

17 people recommend, 5 warn against itvia r/AskNYC, r/FoodNYC, r/astoria

Upside recommendations span its New York locations, including Greenpoint. Fans name specific slices they enjoy, including tomato Sicilian, spicy vodka and square pepperoni, across the broader pool. Critics find the pizza bland or merely ordinary, and some question the value. Greenpoint is explicitly recommended, but experiences and dish mentions at other outlets are not treated as guarantees about this location.

Greenpoint

16 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Jonny's on Orchard Street draws recommendations as a strong Lower East Side pizza stop. A diner calls it a favorite regular option, another describes a particularly good New York pie, and pepperoni is singled out by name. Other commenters put it on their short lists or prefer it to more famous slice shops. The praise is for the Orchard Street business rather than an unspecified Johnny's elsewhere.

Orchard Street Manhattan

15 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Village Square recommendations span its New York locations, including Avenue A. A diner recommends the thicker square pepperoni and prefers it to Prince Street's version. Other visitors describe good slices without the long waits associated with some better-known shops. The West Village and Midtown comments remain part of the citywide pool, not claims about the Avenue A shop's menu or queues.

Avenue A 10th Street

15 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Leo is a Williamsburg pizzeria that people recommend for a sit-down pie, with one diner praising the Margherita slice on the bakery side and another calling the New York pie good and the place underappreciated. A commenter groups it with other spots rated excellent but a notch below the most hyped names, and one person notes it leans more neo-Neapolitan than New York style. The clam pizza is mentioned as a highlight, though one commenter believes it comes only as a whole pie.

Williamsburg

15 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC

Lucky Charlie's is a Bushwick pizzeria praised for its coal-fired pies, with one diner calling the char and tangy sauce top-tier and another saying the pizza is outstanding. One diner singles out the Classic Pie, and another recommends the red pie with anchovies. Views are not unanimous: one diner found the pizza soggy, another called it inconsistent, and one liked the pizza but objected to pricey pies and per-topping charges.

Bushwick

15 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC, r/astoria

Juliana's Pizza in Brooklyn draws praise as a go-to for traditional pizza, with one diner calling it the best they have had. A commenter highlights the freshness and variety of toppings, including distinctive olives and a garlic, pepperoni and caper pie. One visitor found it good but not remarkable, and another says the kitchen will not put sausage on a small pizza.

Brooklyn

15 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/nyc, r/FoodNYC

Giuseppina's draws praise for pizza that several people describe as close to Lucali's, with one diner calling the calzones excellent. One commenter finds it a solid pie but not quite at that level, and one visitor found it forgettable. One commenter sees little point in queueing for Lucali when Giuseppina's is easy to reach and delicious, and another notes it is never full.

Brooklyn

14 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Don Antonio draws recommendations for Neapolitan pizza and a sit-down meal in the theater district. A diner particularly likes its fried pizza, while another calls the pizza excellent. One local recommends sharing different individual pies with a group. Waiting for a table can be a concern, and a visitor finds the montanara sauce too concentrated. Those reservations sit alongside strong praise rather than a guarantee of an effortless visit.

Manhattan

14 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Made in New York Pizza recommendations span its New York locations, including Amsterdam Avenue near 80th Street. Two commenters specifically praise the 80th Street shop. Other diners recommend vodka, burrata or upside-down slices across the citywide pool. A visitor to an Upper West Side location enjoys the pepperoni more than the other slices.

80th St

14 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/FoodNYC

Vito's Slices & Ices is a pizzeria near 9th Avenue and 36th Street that people recommend for a classic New York slice, with one diner calling it some of the best pizza they have tried in the city. Another visitor praises the gluten-free pizza as the best on the West Side, and a commenter says it recalls old-school New York pizza. A visitor describes limited seating and the possibility of eating a slice outdoors.

14 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/astoria

Motorino earns recommendations across its New York locations, including East Village. Diners specifically recommend the East Village shop, while others favor the Upper West Side location. Across the wider pool, commenters praise the Neapolitan style, Brussels sprout pizza and stracciatella pizza. A diner finds its dough especially flavorful.

East Village

14 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/astoria, r/FoodNYC

Retro Pizza draws steady praise for its slices, with a diner calling the dough and crust excellent and noting a slice holds its shape when picked up. The Sicilian gets particular attention, including a hot honey pepperoni cup version, and one diner prefers it to the round pie. A vodka sauce slice is another favorite, and a vodka grandma slice is singled out as a standout specialty slice. Views are not unanimous: one diner finds the regular slices mediocre while praising the Sicilians, one says the pizza is awful, another calls it a letdown, and a third says anyone praising it has bad taste.

13 people recommendvia r/bronx, r/FoodNYC

Tommy's is a Bronx pizzeria that people repeatedly name among their favorite slices, with several pointing to the East Tremont location. One diner calls the plain pie the best in the Bronx and says it has stayed the same for decades. A commenter notes the regular, pepperoni and Sicilian slices are solid while the sausage slice is noticeably weaker.

The Bronx

13 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Emmett's recommendations cover its New York venues, including MacDougal Street. Diners seeking Chicago-style pizza recommend the deep dish, while two commenters particularly favor tavern-style thin crust. Grove Street comments concern that separate venue and are not assigned to MacDougal's menu. A repeat visitor finds the deep dish unexceptional, and another notes that waiting for a pie can take time.

13 people recommend, 2 warn against itcounted across its outletsvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Artichoke Basille's recommendations span its New York outlets, including East 14th Street. A diner enjoys hefty, saucy slices, while other diners praise the margherita or vodka slice. The namesake artichoke slice is especially divisive: one visitor finds it satisfying, while critics find it overwhelmingly creamy or simply dislike it. Cost is another reservation, and historical queue reports are not a promise of current conditions.

14th Street

12 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Arturo's on Houston Street draws recommendations for coal-oven pizza. A diner particularly likes its piano-and-bar setting. A longtime visitor describes it as consistently enjoyable.

Houston

12 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC

Ribalta draws recommendations for Neapolitan pizza, with fans placing it among their favorite whole-pie destinations. A diner says it can rival more celebrated alternatives on a good day but is not always consistent. Another diner likes it while finding it oily, and a critic is simply not a fan. The substantial praise sits alongside reservations about execution rather than a unanimous verdict.

11 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Sacco's Pizza on 9th Ave in Hell's Kitchen draws praise as a classic New York slice, with one diner calling it the best classic slice they have had in Manhattan and another calling it the best slice joint in the city. One diner says the sauce is applied lightly, so it may not suit everyone. Views are not unanimous: one diner finds the slices inconsistent, sometimes excellent and occasionally poor, though still likely the best in the area, and another questions whether it is really a sit-down place.

11 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/nyc, r/AskNYC

Norm's recommendations span its New York shops, including Adams Street in Downtown Brooklyn. Fans praise it as a reliable slice option, and a diner singles out the vodka slice. Another likes the balance without too much tomato. Not every view is enthusiastic: a visitor finds the pizza only ordinary while noting its sourdough starter.

11 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Andrea's is a pizzeria in the East Village, with several people also pointing to a location on Second Avenue. One visitor who has tried most of the slices since it opened says all have been excellent, and another thinks the Second Avenue spot is worth the trek back. Others describe it simply as solid or good, and one person ranks it second among their picks in the area. One commenter says it is good but prefers another slice shop nearby.

East Village

11 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/bronx, r/FoodNYC

Sam's Pizza on 231st Street draws loyal Bronx recommendations for a classic slice. A diner particularly likes the Sicilian, and another notes the generous size of a pepperoni pie. Other visitors are less impressed: one describes slices getting oily and soggy, another considers it expensive, and a critic says it does not warrant a subway trip. This is not Uncle Sam's on the Lower East Side or Sam's in Cobble Hill.

231st Street

10 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/astoria

Sac's Place in Astoria draws recommendations for pizza, including Sicilian and grandma pies. One diner calls it a neighborhood favorite, and another ranks it close to Andrew Bellucci's. A visitor reports seasonal limits on slice service, while another is frustrated by the delivery area. Those operational details are individual reports rather than verified current availability; confirm the format before planning around a single slice.

10 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Chrissy's draws recommendations for its pizza, with a diner calling the tomato pie a favorite and a must-try. Another finds the pie very good and comparable with better-known pizzerias, while considering the slices small for the cost. A visitor describes a whole-pie-only format. Confirm the current ordering format rather than assuming slices are available from every reference to a slice.

10 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/nyc, r/AskNYC

Koronet draws recommendations for enormous slices, with several diners treating the size as part of the appeal. A visitor describes a particularly tasty, huge slice, while another suggests stopping near Columbia for the experience. Taste is not unanimously praised: a diner finds it merely satisfying late at night, and another strongly dislikes it. Reports about other Koronet outlets are not treated as promises about this Broadway pin.

Columbia

9 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Grand Street Pizza on the Lower East Side draws recommendations as a reliable nearby slice stop. A diner includes it among local favorites, and another likes spending time there with a beer. A visitor describes the pizza as solid without an overwhelming crowd. The appeal is a neighborhood option rather than a claim of unanimous citywide superiority.

LES

9 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Amore in Flushing draws recommendations for a straightforward, old-school New York slice. A diner describes it as good and affordable, and others name it among their Queens favorites or recommend it alongside nearby pizza stops. The strongest identifiable support concerns Flushing. Praise for a similarly named shop near Columbus Circle is not transferred to this business.

Flushing

9 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/statenisland

Lee's Tavern receives repeated Staten Island recommendations for pizza. Several commenters name it among their preferred whole-pie destinations, and a diner particularly recommends the clam pizza. Another suggests Buffalo calamari as a topping. The more detailed praise is individual, alongside a broader pattern of straightforward local recommendations.

Staten Island

9 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/nyc

Totonno's in Coney Island draws repeated recommendations. A visitor who has been several times considers the pizza top tier. Other diners are less enthusiastic, describing a decline or relaying doubts about the current quality. Reports of limited opening and ordering options also make it sensible to check the current arrangements before travelling.

Coney Island

9 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Sottocasa recommendations span its New York locations, including Harlem. Diners specifically recommend Harlem for Italian-style pizza, and one enjoys the relaxed setting and Italian beers there. Brooklyn comments include both praise and reports of declining quality. Those branch-specific views are not presented as experiences at the Harlem shop.

Harlem

8 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Fermento draws recommendations for its slices, with a diner describing a thin, light and crisp sourdough crust. Another particularly enjoys the burrata slice with chunky tomato sauce and basil. Several visitors report enjoying the pizza, while one finds it good without considering it clearly better than other slice shops. The praise supports a promising option, not unanimous agreement that it is a new benchmark.

8 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Angelo's recommendations include its Midtown locations, including West 57th Street. Diners specifically recommend the West 57th Street shop for a sit-down pizza meal. A commenter prefers Broadway's upstairs dining room to the more casual feel on 57th Street. Other visitors simply name Angelo's among their pizza choices.

Midtown Manhattan

8 people recommendvia r/bronx, r/FoodNYC

Kingsbridge Social Club is recommended for its wood-fired smaller pies, which one diner calls delicious, and for Neapolitan-style pies and drinks in a restaurant setting. One person names it among the best in the area, and another says it came to mind first. One diner calls the pizza great while finding it a bit pricey, and a visitor notes the room can get noisy when crowded.

8 people recommendvia r/astoria

Nonna's 1977 in Astoria draws recommendations for distinctive slices. Individual diners name the Veronica, Layla and chicken Sharona, while another praises the variety and ingredients. Value is the recurring reservation: some enjoy the pizza but find it expensive or difficult to justify by the slice. Fans appreciate the variety without everyone agreeing that it is an everyday-value stop.

8 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Williamsburg Pizza recommendations span its New York locations, including Union Avenue. Diners single out tartufo, tomato Sicilian and a freshly ordered cup-and-char grandma pie across the broader pool. Others favor the Lower East Side shop or recommend the brand more generally.

8 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Austin Street Pizza draws Forest Hills recommendations for its slices. A visitor remembers it as a solid neighborhood option, and another praises the variety and consistent results. Other diners say it is worth a stop while visiting nearby pizza shops. A diner likes the pizza but finds it expensive, particularly when ordering for a family. The neighborhood following comes with that value caveat.

Forest Hills

8 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Frico on 2nd draws Upper East Side recommendations for pizza. A diner particularly praises the Detroit-style slices and also likes the New York-style offering. Another visitor considers it a good addition to the neighborhood, while other commenters name it as a pizza option nearby.

UES

8 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Diamond Slice is a pizzeria in Greenpoint that people recommend for its pizza, with one visitor singling out the marinara slice as incredible. Another person who has been says they really like it, and another names it among their favorites. It is also noted as easily walkable from nearby spots.

Greenpoint

8 people recommendvia r/astoria

Astoria Pizza Factory receives repeated recommendations for Sicilian and grandma slices. A diner particularly likes the pepperoni cup Sicilian and suggests adding hot honey, while another calls the grandma slice a favorite. One commenter values its traditional slices, and another considers it worth the trip. One local likes it but finds another nearby shop less greasy.

8 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskNYC, r/FoodNYC

Little Italy Pizza recommendations span its New York locations, including University Place. Two diners specifically praise this shop's slices. Other outlets receive praise for crisp crust or sauce, but those details are not assigned to University Place. Dissent includes a visitor who calls this location deeply disappointing and another who questions the chain's cornmeal underside. The pool contains enthusiasm without consistent agreement across outlets.

University

8 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia X, r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Ceres draws praise for its tomato pie, and diners also recommend its mushroom slice. The flavor and texture do not convince everyone: a visitor likes the crunch but finds little flavor and would not wait again. Another visitor tries a cold slice and enjoys the texture more than the taste. The disagreement concerns the pizza, not a universal verdict on whether the queue is worthwhile.

Soho

7 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Slicehaus on Carmine Street draws recommendations from diners seeking alternatives to the most hyped slice shops. A visitor calls it a new favorite, and another considers it a strong competitor to L'Industrie. Other commenters recommend it as a worthwhile stop. One diner reports changing toppings, but this is not presented as a verified current menu schedule.

7 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Salsa in Greenpoint draws recommendations for Neapolitan pizza. A diner considers it the best nearby, another reports never having a bad pie, and a visitor who has tried several Neapolitan places ranks it among the strongest. A separate diner rates the margherita highly.

Greenpoint

7 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Peppino's recommendations include its Brooklyn locations, including Bay Ridge. Diners describe the Bay Ridge shop as an under-the-radar whole-pie destination, and one compares it favorably with much more famous pizzerias. A diner also recommends the Park Slope location. Comments naming a Peppino's near White Plains Road are not attributed to this Brooklyn business.

Bay Ridge

7 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Lo Duca at Newkirk Plaza draws recommendations for traditional New York pizza. A diner particularly likes the grandma pie and prefers it to Di Fara, while finding the fusion-style pies less appealing. A local also prefers it to Di Fara, and other diners recommend it as a nearby option.

Newkirk Plaza Brooklyn

7 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Sotto Le Stelle in Sunnyside draws recommendations for Neapolitan-style pizza. A diner calls it a favorite for its flavors and chewy crust, and another considers the four-cheese pizza worth a long train journey. A visitor rates the Diavola highly. Other commenters recommend it more generally as a Queens pizza stop. These recommendations concern the Queens Boulevard shop.

Sunnyside

7 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC

Marinara recommendations span its New York locations, including the East Village. Individual diners recommend the grandma slice or chicken Caesar slice, and another prefers the stuffed-crust Sicilian to the round pie. A dissenting diner finds the pizza mediocre.

East Village

7 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/AskNYC, r/FoodNYC

Two Boots recommendations span its New York locations, including Park Slope. Fans recommend it for unusual slices, and one visitor enjoys a saucy, crisp pie. Other diners strongly dislike the sauce or find the crust underbaked. A commenter prefers the Buckminster to the cheese slice. Those pooled dish opinions are not claims about the Park Slope shop's current menu.

6 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Unregular recommendations span its New York locations, including Fourth Avenue. A diner praises its non-classic pizza options, and a visitor describes repeat takeaway orders as reliably good. Another specifically enjoys the 37th Street shop.

6 people recommendvia r/astoria, r/FoodNYC

Macoletta in Astoria receives several recommendations for pizza. A diner chooses it for specialty pies, while others name it among their neighborhood picks. The positive comments are mostly straightforward recommendations rather than detailed agreement on a single topping.

6 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Krispy Pizza is a Brooklyn pizzeria that people mention among the slice spots worth trying in the borough, and one diner calls it their go-to there. Another visitor, who stopped in on a rainy night, was especially taken with the plain cheese slice, saying it stood out even though they usually order pepperoni and ranking it among the best they have had in the city. Others simply list it as a place to try or a good spot on 13th Avenue.

Brooklyn

6 people recommendvia r/bronx, r/FoodNYC

Pugsley Pizza draws Bronx recommendations, with a diner particularly praising the vegetable slice and another enjoying the pizza with pepper oil. Several commenters name it among their local favorites. Sources disagree about how close it is to Arthur Avenue, so it is better treated as its own stop rather than an assumed short detour. Seasonal opening claims are not presented as verified current hours.

Arthur Avenue

6 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/nyc

Little Pizza Parlour on Duffield Street in Downtown Brooklyn draws praise for its slices, with one visitor calling it a hidden gem a short walk from the Jay Street Metrotech station. A couple of commenters name it their favorite pizza place in the area, and one diner says they often hear customers leaving while telling someone they just had the best pizza. Another commenter suggests it for margherita.

Downtown Brooklyn

6 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Nolita Pizza on Kenmare draws recommendations, with a diner particularly praising the plain slice. A diner calls it the real deal, and another prefers it to Prince Street in every respect. A visitor is happy to have found it after a disappointing experience elsewhere. Its appeal in these comments is the slice itself; a description of enjoying it while drinking is not evidence of current late-night hours.

6 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Parla on the Upper West Side draws recommendations for pizza. A diner who has visited twice describes excellent pies on both occasions, while another praises the pizza and appetizers. A commenter includes it among Manhattan favorites. The praise is positive without establishing a signature preparation.

6 people recommendvia r/bronx

Jerome Pizza & Pasta on Bedford Park is named by multiple commenters as a pizza pick, with one person calling out the buffalo slice and the grandma spinach. Another commenter says it has been their spot for many years. The recommendations point to the Bedford Park location.

Bedford Park

6 people recommendvia r/astoria

Jack's Pizza draws enthusiastic recommendations, with one diner calling it their go-to spot. A commenter singles out the cheese and margherita slices as underrated, and another feels the place is slept on and deserves more attention. Several others simply praise the pizza.

5 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

East Village Pizza draws recommendations for a straightforward slice. A diner praises it as a classic option on the go, and another enjoys its more unusual double-stacked and heart-shaped pizzas. Other visitors find it perfectly good rather than exceptional, and one describes the space as tiny. Comments discussing East Village Pizza and Stromboli together are not treated as independent proof of a particular late-night offering here.

5 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/FoodNYC

La Traviata on West 68th Street draws recommendations for a straightforward New York slice. A diner particularly praises the simple pepperoni, and another reports consistently good slices. Visitors also value it as a budget-friendly stop. A commenter describes a small space with only a couple of tables rather than a full sit-down restaurant, so it is better suited to a quick slice than an elaborate meal.

Upper West Side

5 people recommendvia r/bronx

Salvatore's of SoHo in Riverdale draws Bronx recommendations for classic New York pizza. A diner describes it as a good example of that style, and others name it among their local choices. Not all praise is unqualified: one visitor finds the pizza hit or miss, while another thinks it merely fine even though the broader menu is a strength. It is a neighborhood choice with real reservations about consistency.

Riverdale

5 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Aromi in Carroll Gardens draws recommendations for Neapolitan pizza. A diner particularly praises the crust, and other commenters name it alongside other Neapolitan destinations. Replies enthusiastically agree with those recommendations.

Carroll Gardens