Best sushi in New York

54 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Sushi W is recommended across its Upper West and Upper East Side locations, with the Upper West Side outlet shown here. One visitor to the Upper West Side calls the omakase enjoyable and tasty, while a repeat customer praises the fish and value across the brand's menus. Not every visit feels leisurely: one diner found the meal rushed and impersonal, and an east-side visitor thought the fish portions small and the meal good rather than exceptional.

Upper West Side

53 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Shinn is recommended across its East and West locations, with the frequently named East Village counter shown here. Diners repeatedly praise the value, and one first-time omakase visitor was particularly pleased with Shinn East. The agreement is not universal: one East customer feels quality has declined, another prefers Shiki at a similar cost, and a further diner dislikes the heavily garnished set-menu style.

East Village

49 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/AskNYC, r/FoodNYC

Thirteen Water draws repeated recommendations for good-value omakase in the East Village. One diner especially likes its unusual toppings, while another says it feels more upscale than its price suggests. Those embellishments divide opinion: one dissenter finds the sauces overwhelming, and diners who enjoyed the meal still describe a fast pace. It is a better-supported pick for an affordable sushi meal than for a long, leisurely celebration.

46 people recommend, 8 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC

Sushi Noz draws strong high-end omakase recommendations for both the original Upper East Side counter and Noz 17, though the meals and experiences differ between locations. One diner compares the original counter favorably with sushi they have eaten in Japan; another likes it less than the other omakase restaurants they tried. Cost is the recurring reservation, with dissenters questioning whether the experience warrants the premium. Praise for the separate Noz Market concept is not a review of these counters.

Upper East Side

42 people recommend, 5 warn against itcounted across its outletsvia r/FoodNYC

Sushi by M's recommendations span its New York outlets, with the East Village location shown here. Repeat visitors praise its value and accessibility for people new to omakase, and one diner singles out lightly torched toro as a memorable bite. Dissenters say quality has declined or that competing counters offer better value. The balance favors an approachable entry-level meal, not a claim that it matches the city's most refined omakase.

East Village

42 people recommend, 10 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Sushi Yasuda draws repeated praise for fish-focused omakase, with one diner describing a special-occasion meal that never felt hurried. Another enjoyed comparing different varieties of the same seafood within the meal. Its reputation is contested: some commenters feel later visits have disappointed or that other counters have overtaken it, while another regular still finds the experience worth an occasional splurge. These are diners' experiences, not a guarantee of a particular menu or pace.

41 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/Brooklyn

Katsuei's omakase recommendations span Park Slope and the West Village, with the Park Slope outlet shown here. A Park Slope regular reports consistently enjoyable meals, while a West Village diner likes the mix of familiar fish and more unusual pieces. Value is a recurring theme across both locations. One Park Slope commenter likes the quality but finds the child-heavy dining room a drawback for a quieter outing.

Park Slope

40 people recommend, 17 warn against itcounted across its outletsvia r/FoodNYC

Sugarfish draws recommendations and warnings across its New York outlets, with Midtown East shown here. One visitor to that branch found it an enjoyable introduction to omakase with approachable fish selections, and another customer likes how its sushi travels. Substantial dissent remains: commenters call it overrated or unremarkable, and one repeat customer describes inconsistent or declining quality. Its convenience and accessibility have stronger support than a claim of top-tier sushi.

Midtown East

38 people recommend, 11 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC

Sushi Nakazawa has a substantial following for high-end omakase, including a regular who chooses it for birthday meals and praises its quality relative to more expensive counters. Other diners disagree about whether the meal merits its reputation. Criticism centers on inconsistent rice, an unexciting fish selection and a formal or crowded atmosphere. It remains a strongly recommended but genuinely divisive choice, rather than an automatic upgrade for every sushi diner.

37 people recommendvia r/Brooklyn, r/AskNYC, r/FoodNYC

Sushi Lin is recommended across its New York locations, with the explicitly recommended SoHo outlet shown here. Diners repeatedly praise the omakase and value; one SoHo visitor counts it among their preferred budget options. Another diner favors counter seating for the accompaniments served with the fish, but that experience is not attributed specifically to SoHo. The brand has a broad following, but these accounts do not promise identical meals at every branch.

Soho

37 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Sushi 35 West is repeatedly recommended for takeout and delivery rather than an elaborate dining-room experience. One repeat customer praises how well its sushi travels, and another considers it the best value among the delivery options they have tried. The modest hallway setting is part of that trade-off. Dissenters question the value or prefer competing sushi, and one customer liked the quality but received an incomplete order.

Midtown

34 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Tanoshi is repeatedly recommended for omakase on the Upper East Side. One birthday visitor loved the contrast of cold fish and warm rice, while another values the counter's cozy, intimate feel. Opinions on value are less settled: a fan still finds it worthwhile despite rising costs, while dissenters report disappointing meals or prefer other counters. Praise for particular past visits should not be read as a promise of an identical menu on every visit.

Upper East Side

33 people recommend, 6 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC

Yoshino is frequently placed among New York's leading high-end sushi counters. One visitor praises an entertaining meal with excellent sushi, while another finds the room warm and enjoyable and particularly likes the small plates. The premium divides diners: some regard it as money well spent, while others feel the improvement over cheaper omakase does not justify the cost. Its strong reputation is not unanimous agreement on value.

32 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC

Sushi Yasaka is repeatedly recommended for everyday sushi on the Upper West Side. One regular describes it as a dependable weeknight choice; another calls it a favorite non-omakase restaurant and singles out the toro oshinko and blue crab California rolls. A dissenter finds the food ordinary and the room unappealing, preferring to think of it as a neighborhood delivery option rather than a destination meal.

Upper West Side

30 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Sendo is recommended across its New York locations, with Greenwich Village shown here. A visitor explicitly praises that branch for a simple, unembellished sushi meal and strong value, while repeat customers elsewhere also report enjoyable omakase. Not everyone shares the enthusiasm: one diner was underwhelmed by the value and another prefers competing counters. Historical comments about booking or waiting at an unspecified branch are not instructions for this location.

30 people recommend, 6 warn against itcounted across its outletsvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Sushi by Bou is recommended across its New York outlets, with the explicitly reviewed NoMad branch shown here. Diners often suggest the brand as an approachable introduction to omakase, and one NoMad visitor enjoyed the meal. A different customer praises an unhurried visit at the 20th Street outlet, which should not be assumed to describe NoMad. Dissenters criticize repetitive sweet sauces or feel other affordable counters now offer better sushi.

Nomad

29 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Shinzo Omakase earns repeated recommendations for affordable sushi in the East Village. One visitor praises the individual pieces, and another highlights the quality relative to the cost. Comments about friendly service reinforce the appeal, but the view is not unanimous: one diner found the meal merely average and would not return. Value is the main appeal rather than luxury.

East Village

27 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC

Hatsuhana draws repeated recommendations for sushi sets in Midtown. One diner finds the sushi deluxe particularly good value, while a longtime customer prefers the table-served sushi special to the counter omakase. It is also a family lunch favorite in one account. The caveat is consistency: a dissenter reports several disappointing lunches and has stopped returning, despite the restaurant's other fans.

22 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/sushi, r/FoodNYC

KazuNori is recommended across New York, with the explicitly mentioned East 53rd Street outlet shown here. One lunch recommendation especially likes that branch's no-frills hand rolls, while citywide fans favor the quick, casual format and two prefer the brand to Sugarfish. The dissent concerns the balance of rice and fish: one finds the fish bland, and another dislikes the contrast between very hot rice and very cold fish. Those experiences are not all specific to East 53rd Street.

19 people recommend, 6 warn against itcounted across its outletsvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Sushi on Me's recommendations span its Queens and Brooklyn outlets, with Jackson Heights shown here. Fans describe inventive sushi and an unusually lively, drinks-led omakase; a Queens visitor calls it especially entertaining. The same emphasis divides opinion: one Jackson Heights diner found the party atmosphere forced, while others liked the experience more than the fish. It is not the strongest fit for someone seeking a quiet, traditional sushi counter.

Jackson Heights

17 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Sushi Ikumi is repeatedly recommended for omakase in SoHo. One diner describes a relaxed, less embellished style, and another considers a past lunch especially good value. A solo visitor also reports an enjoyable meal. The qualification is personal preference: a diner who otherwise likes Ikumi finds its fish cuts too large, and some recommendations place it above the budget tier.

Soho

17 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Shiki Omakase draws repeated recommendations in the affordable omakase tier. One diner who tried both prefers it to Shinn East, and other commenters make the same comparison in Shiki's favor. Another visitor places it among the strongest budget counters they have sampled. This is support for an enjoyable value-focused meal, not a promise that it reproduces a high-end omakase experience.

Soho

17 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Nami Nori's recommendations span New York locations, with the West Village outlet shown here. One visitor enjoyed its hand rolls as an alternative to a full omakase, and another customer especially likes having the temaki paced out at the counter. A further diner singles out the mushroom hand roll. These experiences are not all from the West Village, nor a guarantee of identical seating, menus or service at every branch.

17 people recommend, 1 warns against itcounted across its outletsvia r/FoodNYC

Sushi Seki's recommendations span New York outlets, with the First Avenue location shown here. One regular values the fish and a quieter setting, while another recalls meals tailored to their preferences rather than a rigid set. The style divides opinion: two commenters find the nigiri heavily embellished, and one argues it is far removed from traditional edomae sushi. The personal tailoring described in past visits is not a service guarantee.

Upper East Side

17 people recommend, 2 warn against itcounted across its outletsvia r/FoodNYC

Blue Ribbon Sushi's recommendations span several New York outlets, with the SoHo restaurant shown here. A SoHo regular remains an enthusiastic fan, while another diner finds that branch dependable rather than exceptional. Across the brand, value is the recurring disagreement: some appreciate the sushi, while others think similarly good or better meals are available for less. Comments about the rooms or cooked dishes at other outlets are not claims about SoHo.

Soho

17 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC

Takahachi is repeatedly recommended for casual sushi, with the explicitly named Avenue A restaurant shown here. One East Village recommendation highlights reasonable prices, while a customer who does not identify a branch recalls ordering for decades. Those citywide accounts should not all be read as reviews of this branch. Two dissenters either did not enjoy repeated meals or preferred another casual sushi restaurant.

East Village

16 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskNYC, r/FoodNYC

Tsumo draws repeated recommendations for affordable omakase. One visitor found every piece excellent and enjoyed a quiet room, while another customer likes the meal and drinks selection. The disagreement is about how it compares with nearby alternatives: one diner found the pieces too small to justify returning, and another preferred the fish at Shinn East. A pleasant value-focused meal has more support than an unqualified best-in-city claim.

16 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/Brooklyn

Geido draws repeated recommendations for sushi on Flatbush Avenue. A longtime customer likes both the fish and the relaxed atmosphere, while another regular values it as a dependable neighborhood choice. One commenter ranks it highly for seasonal fish. A diner who followed a recommendation disagreed, finding the sushi underwhelming despite enjoying the room, so the atmosphere has broader appeal than a unanimous verdict on every meal.

Flatbush

15 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/Brooklyn

Daigo's recommendations span its Brooklyn locations, with the Carroll Street roll bar shown here. One diner explicitly favors that bar for a quiet lunch and considers the rolls worth the extra cost. Other fans praise hand rolls or the DeKalb Market outlet, without those experiences being transferred to Carroll Street. Value is the main reservation: one takeout regular rarely orders without a discount, and another diner found the sushi underwhelming.

15 people recommend, 1 warns against itcounted across its outletsvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Sushi of Gari's recommendations span New York outlets, with the explicitly named 46th Street restaurant shown here. One diner likes the blend of familiar sushi and inventive toppings, while another remembers an increasingly creative meal at the former Tribeca setting. Those are distinct branch experiences. Dissenters find the toppings excessive or question the value, making it a less obvious fit for someone seeking restrained sushi.

Theater District

15 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC

Sushi Blossoms in Chelsea draws repeated omakase recommendations. One repeat visitor particularly likes the visual presentation, and another diner considers the meal good value compared with competing counters. A visitor who did not feel rushed adds support for a more relaxed experience, though that is not a guaranteed seating duration. One dissenter did not enjoy it enough to choose it over other similarly priced omakase.

Chelsea

14 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Icca is repeatedly named among New York's preferred high-end omakase restaurants. One diner compares it favorably with sushi they have eaten in Japan, while another likes the creative courses with beef and Italian influences. Its following includes people who recommend it for a splurge rather than an inexpensive introduction to sushi. The detailed praise for those non-sushi courses comes from one diner, not a universally shared menu preference.

14 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Kanoyama is repeatedly recommended for sushi in the East Village. One local especially likes its set meals and considers them better value than some inexpensive omakase counters. Another customer followed a recommendation, ordered takeout and enjoyed it, while a further diner praises the sushi platter for two. Fans favor it as an alternative to a fixed tasting-menu experience, without promising a particular set or price.

East Village

13 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Nakaji earns repeated recommendations for high-end omakase, with one visitor particularly enjoying the larger, traditional-leaning nigiri and interesting fish selection. That same diner finds the overall meal less rounded than some peers. Another customer remembers it as a favorite dining experience, while a further commenter likes it slightly less than other leading counters. The strongest support concerns sushi character and presentation, not an unqualified ranking above every rival.

13 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

DOMODOMO on West Houston Street draws recommendations for omakase and hand rolls. One diner found a recent domakase meal particularly enjoyable, while another likes the food's balance and distinctiveness. Delivery produces a different value judgment: a commenter appreciates the quality but thinks the higher cost is difficult to justify once the sushi has travelled. That distinction is more useful than treating dining in and delivery as interchangeable experiences.

13 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Sushi Ishikawa is recommended across its Upper East and Upper West Side locations, with the latter shown here. One Upper West Side visitor especially likes the food and service, and a different diner praises the unconventional omakase style without specifying a branch. Other fans place it above the budget tier. The creative approach is part of its appeal, rather than a reason to assume it suits everyone seeking a restrained, traditional sushi meal.

Upper West Side

13 people recommend, 6 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC

Jōji's recommendations span the Midtown omakase and its related takeout boxes, which are different meal formats. Some diners favor the high-end counter, while takeout customers praise the packaging and convenience. Other customers find the boxes disappointing, and one diner considers the omakase poor value. An opening-week visitor would not return at the premium, so enthusiasm for the setting and format does not amount to agreement on value.

12 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Shota in Williamsburg draws repeated omakase recommendations. One visitor particularly praises the fish, rice and unhurried feel, while another places it among their preferred choices for execution and value. The qualification comes from a commenter who still likes it but puts it below the very highest edomae tier. The positive balance is strong without being an uncontested best-in-city ranking.

Williamsburg

12 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Sanyuu West draws recommendations for accessible omakase in Chelsea. One diner praises the rice and fish temperature, and a repeat visitor says friends they have brought have consistently enjoyed it. The main qualification is pacing: one customer warns that the meal moves quickly. Another advises choosing something else for an experienced omakase enthusiast who expects a more ambitious sushi experience.

Chelsea

12 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Brooklyn, r/FoodNYC

Ki Sushi's recommendations span its Brooklyn locations, with the explicitly named Flatbush Avenue restaurant shown here. One visitor to that location treats it as a special indulgence, while another customer likes taking a solo dinner there. A regular also recommends it for dates but finds the fish texture lacking, and a further commenter considers it mediocre. Its neighborhood following does not amount to an uncontested verdict on the sushi.

Flatbush Ave

11 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Rosella is recommended for a less conventional sushi meal in the East Village. Diners describe distinctive fish sourcing and fusion touches, and one couple enjoyed visiting despite different preferences over raw fish. Individual menu experiences vary: another diner was disappointed not to find salmon nigiri, even while liking the food. Such accounts describe past meals, not a promise of sourcing, dietary suitability or current menu availability.

11 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Noda draws repeated high-end omakase recommendations, with one diner choosing it as their best experience and another especially valuing the service alongside the food. A further fan likes the atmosphere and distinctly sour-leaning rice. That rice preference is personal rather than a universal advantage. Commenters also place it well above inexpensive counters, so enthusiasm should not be confused with a budget recommendation.

11 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Sushi Hatsune is a low-key sushi spot that people repeatedly name for takeout and delivery. One diner praises the vinegary sushi rice and finds everything fresh and budget-friendly, and another used to eat here regularly before leaving the Lower East Side. A commenter calls it their favorite delivery option, while another considers it the standout choice for delivered sushi, though unsure whether it reaches their area.

10 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Takumi on the Lower East Side draws recommendations for value and a filling omakase experience. One visitor especially likes the tuna and eel, while another enjoyed the variety and fish-to-rice balance. Diners also discuss an all-you-can-eat extension, but their accounts differ on which pieces can be repeated and when it is available. Those past experiences are not a guarantee of unlimited repeats or current booking terms.

Lower East Side

10 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC

Momoya's recommendations span New York locations, with the explicitly recommended SoHo outlet shown here. One diner calls SoHo and Chelsea reliable choices, while another likes the brand's food and atmosphere without identifying a branch. One dissenter finds it overhyped and unremarkable. A separate poor experience at the Upper West Side location is not transferred to SoHo, but it is a reason not to assume all branches feel alike.

Soho

9 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Omakase Room by Mitsu draws recommendations for the quality of its fish. A repeat visitor was impressed again by the seasonal items, and another customer likes the small room's private-feeling atmosphere. A diner who prefers ordering individual pieces finds the omakase format limiting even while admiring the setting. Fans favor an intimate sushi meal, but their accounts do not promise a fixed guest count or menu.

9 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Bar Miller is suggested as an alternative to the city's most expensive omakase counters. One visitor remembers a particularly enjoyable meal and pairings, praising the uni and describing a casual, trendy room. Another commenter still places it in a premium tier. The strongest detailed praise comes from one visit, so it should not be read as broad agreement on a specific current menu.

9 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Sushi Dairo draws repeated recommendations for omakase near Union Square. A regular likes meals tailored to their preferences, and another diner recommends both omakase and ordering individual pieces, with scallop among their favorites. Those experiences favor a more flexible sushi meal than a rigid tasting menu, but do not guarantee personalization or particular menu items.

9 people recommend, 3 warn against itcounted across its outletsvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Sushi Lab's recommendations and warnings span its New York outlets, with the explicitly mentioned East Village restaurant shown here. One visitor found the brand's sushi meal fun and tasty, while a Midtown commenter also recommends it. Dissenters criticize the rice, fish texture or declining quality as the group expanded. Descriptions of the rooftop and the room above Chemistry Room are not attributed to the East Village location.

East Village

8 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Sushi Hayashi draws recommendations for fish quality and a filling omakase experience. One diner especially likes the fatty tuna and unagi, while another favors Hayashi over competing all-you-can-eat counters for its fish. A different commenter prefers Hatsu's repeat-piece variety. These comparisons support a real choice between fish preference and selection, not a guarantee of current all-you-can-eat terms.

8 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Kikoo is repeatedly recommended for all-you-can-eat sushi, with one diner particularly liking the quality relative to the cost. Another regular reports returning about monthly. The appeal includes a lively, drinks-led meal rather than just the fish: one comparison favors it over a cheaper rival while acknowledging better sushi at more expensive counters, and another comment is lukewarm about the food itself. Past drinks packages are not guaranteed inclusions.

8 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/FoodNYC

Hatsu earns recommendations for an omakase meal followed by additional nigiri. Two commenters particularly like the variety of its all-you-can-eat selection, and one compares its rice and drinks favorably with rival counters while preferring Hayashi's fish. Another diner enjoyed a lively atmosphere. Accounts describe different repeat-piece and drinks arrangements, so they should not be read as a guarantee of unlimited service on every visit.

8 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/Brooklyn

Taiki is a sushi spot in Boerum Hill that people recommend for high-quality sushi in a low-key, unassuming setting. One diner calls it the best sushi they have had in Brooklyn, and another says the omakase is very good, though slightly above their budget. A commenter describes it as a quaint sushi bar with an ambiance suited to a date, and another rates it highly for seasonal fish.

Boerum Hill

8 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodNYC

Hasaki is a sushi spot that many diners recommend, with one visitor describing high-quality, nigiri-focused meals and calling it more upscale than some alternatives. Another diner considers it a classic. One person notes it runs slightly over their budget but says they have never been rushed there, while another commenter feels it is very expensive.

8 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/AskNYC, r/FoodNYC

Fuku draws recommendations for affordable omakase in Greenwich Village. One first-time omakase diner was particularly impressed, while another customer remembers an enjoyable meal and a standout monkfish-liver piece. Dissenters criticize preparation, middling quality or a rushed seating. Those positive experiences do not mean every visit will feel leisurely or include the same pieces.

7 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/FoodNYC

Akino's recommendations span its Queens locations, with the explicitly recommended Elmhurst restaurant shown here. One Elmhurst diner likes the quality and generous portions, while another commenter considers the brand a reliable all-you-can-eat choice. Views over time are mixed: a former fan thinks it has declined, while another still prefers it to competing options. Its appeal is the format and quality, rather than a clear consensus that it is inexpensive.

Elmhurst

7 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Tatsuda in Hell's Kitchen draws repeated omakase recommendations. One commenter calls it outstanding and suggests pairing dinner with a show; two other visitors report enjoyable meals. That supports a theater-area sushi outing without implying that every recommendation comes from someone who combined both activities.

Hell's Kitchen

7 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Kazumi draws repeated recommendations for accessible omakase in Greenwich Village. One diner and their dining companion loved the meal, and another visitor reports a very good experience. A further commenter includes it among affordable favorites rather than the luxury tier. The appeal is an approachable sushi meal rather than a high-end splurge.

7 people recommendvia r/Brooklyn, r/FoodNYC

Ozakaya is a sushi restaurant in Prospect Heights that several commenters recommend, and one diner says it looks nice inside and would suit a sushi date. Another person praises its vibes, and one visitor who has eaten there describes the food as high quality with a vibe they found trendier than other spots they listed. A commenter also notes that the menu is diverse, and one diner says it is the first delivery option that met their quality bar.

6 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/FoodNYC

Beyond Sushi is recommended across New York, with its Midtown location shown here. Commenters suggest it specifically for fish-free sushi, with one diner praising the variety and another calling the restaurant very good. A less enthusiastic commenter finds the mock sushi rolls acceptable rather than outstanding. These accounts describe the appeal of the concept, not dietary or allergy guarantees for every item.

6 people recommendcounted across its outletsvia r/FoodNYC, r/Brooklyn

Fushimi's recommendations span Brooklyn outlets, with the explicitly named Bay Ridge restaurant shown here. One customer likes the roomier, sociable setting, and another reports enjoying a meal despite different raw-fish preferences within the couple. Those detailed experiences do not identify Bay Ridge and are not transferred to its dining room or menu. Two separate commenters do specifically recommend the Bay Ridge location for sushi.

Bay Ridge

6 people recommendvia r/Brooklyn, r/AskNYC, r/FoodNYC

Uotora in Crown Heights is repeatedly recommended for sushi. One diner prefers its regular rolls to its omakase and says that keeps their meals affordable. Other commenters describe it as excellent or overlooked. These are personal recommendations rather than a consensus that one meal format is better.

Crown Heights

6 people recommendcounted across its outletsvia r/FoodNYC

Sushi Counter's recommendations span its West and East Village outlets, with the West Village shown here. One diner especially likes the generous filling and flavors of the hand rolls, while another values the quick takeout format. A further commenter recommends both locations. It is a choice for a convenient hand-roll stop rather than a traditional, sit-down sushi meal.

6 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/FoodNYC

One Bite Omakase is a multi-course omakase spot on the Upper West Side that people recommend as a good-value option. One diner was struck by how well it delivered for the money, and another rates it highly and considers it worth the cost. Several people name it as a go-to omakase suggestion.

6 people recommendvia r/Brooklyn, r/FoodNYC

Oita in Park Slope draws repeated sushi recommendations. One local customer describes it as a neighborhood go-to, and another praises the food alongside the room. A further diner calls it a clear personal favorite. The support is neighborhood enthusiasm rather than evidence for a specific service format, signature dish or universal best-in-city ranking.

Park Slope

6 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC

Sushi Ann draws recommendations for omakase, with one regular particularly praising the rice and preferring its smaller cuts of fish. Another visitor likes the quiet, old-school feel of a nigiri-focused meal. Not everyone is persuaded: two diners question the experience or value, and a fan prefers fewer seared pieces. This is a preference-sensitive choice rather than broad agreement on every preparation.

6 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC

Kouzan on the Upper West Side draws recommendations for value. One diner especially likes the large nigiri and toro scallion roll, while another customer recalls strong quality from delivery. A longtime fan also recommends the shrimp tempura roll. Two dissenters disagree about the value or fish-to-rice balance, so the portion praise is not an uncontested verdict on every roll.

Upper West Side

5 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Omakase Room by Maaser is a West Village omakase spot that several diners recommend. One long-time fan praises its experimental, New York-style courses as thoughtful and delicious rather than gimmicky, and one West Village diner left satisfied after a multi-course meal. Others simply call it a great pick.

West Village

5 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Sasabune is recommended for omakase on the Upper East Side. One diner especially values the attention to detail without formality, while another considers its less conventional omakase a personal favorite and suggests trying it. A different customer describes a small, plainly decorated room. The appeal is the sushi experience rather than an elaborate dining-room setting.

Upper East Side

5 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn

Ume in Williamsburg draws sushi recommendations for a distinctive meal format and setting. One repeat visitor enjoys assembling different combinations from the sushi set, while another diner praises the sunken-table room. A family group also reports enjoying its omakase. That is evidence for a memorable, hands-on meal rather than a guarantee of current ingredients, seating or romantic suitability.

Williamsburg

5 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Douska earns recommendations for hand rolls and value on the Lower East Side. A repeat visitor particularly likes the omakase and temaki sets, and other diners separately praise the hand rolls. One customer also finds getting a table straightforward, though that is a personal experience rather than a booking promise. Its value-focused following is better established than any current deal or price.

5 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Sashimi Express earns recommendations across its Upper East Side locations, with the explicitly named second location shown here. Diners repeatedly praise the roll deals and value, and one customer regards it as a dependable choice. Another likes the quality but notes that the rolls are small. Historical comments about delivery, payment or takeout-only service are not guarantees of current operating terms.

5 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Omakase Sushi by No Name draws repeated recommendations, with one diner particularly liking the extra appetizers and substantial nigiri. That same diner also calls it a personal favorite, while a different commenter considers it overlooked. The portion praise is one person's experience, not a promised course count or a guarantee that particular fish can be added.

5 people recommendvia r/FoodNYC

Hama is a sushi spot that diners suggest for lunch, with one calling it a dependable choice and comparing the sushi to what you would get in Japan. Another finds it better than expected for the money. One diner specifically likes the 51st Street branch.

51st Street

5 people recommend, 2 warn against itcounted across its outletsvia r/FoodNYC

Bondi draws recommendations and warnings across its New York outlets, with the Upper West Side location shown here. Two commenters count it among their favorites, and one customer enjoyed a delivered meal. Others find the fish flavor or rice disappointing. It is a divisive option rather than a clear destination-sushi recommendation.

5 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/FoodNYC

Ito draws high-end omakase recommendations in Tribeca. One diner remembers a particularly extravagant meal, and another recommends it for a birthday sushi request. A dissenter found a visit forgettable, while another advises choosing competing counters. Views favor it overall, but this is not a unanimous luxury recommendation.

Tribeca