Bookstores in New York
31 bookstores that New York locals recommend — the real reasons, and the caveats.
New York bookshops recommended for browsing, used books and particular selections, with individual branches kept distinct.
Drawn from real discussions in r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn, r/nyc, r/FoodNYC and r/newyorkcity — 31 bookstores in New York that people actually recommend. Each one shows why people rate it, the caveats they raised, and a link straight to the original comment — so you read the source yourself instead of trusting a laundered rating. Places cluster around East Village, Soho, Upper East Side and Broadway.
How this map is made: Built from 210 Reddit comments across 196 people in r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn, r/nyc, r/FoodNYC and r/newyorkcity. Last refreshed November 16, 2026. We paraphrase — never copy — and never take payment for a place. How we make our maps
Showing 31 places
Filters
Map
The map and place list use the same cited directory records. Every public entry has a stable Maps We Made ID and geopoint.
Places
1.The Strand
45 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/nyc, r/AskNYC, r/newyorkcity
Most people who name the Strand recommend it, and several point to its large stock of used books; the shop on the map is at Broadway and 12th Street. Some mention the cheap sidewalk carts outside and some the upstairs rare-book room. One commenter says the selection has declined but is still worth a visit, and two others dislike it.
- RecommendsVisitor says the outside carts and the upstairs rare book room make a top outing. r/nyc, Nov 2026
- CaveatVisitor bluntly says the Strand is bad, without giving any specifics about the books or browsing. r/nyc, Nov 2026
2.McNally Jackson, SoHo
31 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn, r/FoodNYC
People recommend McNally Jackson across its several shops, and the shop on the map is the SoHo one, which some commenters name, one saying they like it and another calling it one of the best. Others point to the Seaport, Downtown Brooklyn and Rockefeller Center shops, and a couple like it as a place to sit and read. One commenter finds the Albee Square shop nice but a little tight, and another says the Downtown Brooklyn shop is only sometimes cool.
SoHo
- RecommendsLists this shop among their favorite bookstores. r/AskNYC, Jun 2025
- MixedSays the downtown Brooklyn McNally is sometimes cool, though they find most such shops cookie-cutter. r/Brooklyn, Feb 2026
3.Books Are Magic
16 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn
Many people recommend Books Are Magic, which has more than one Brooklyn shop; the shop on the map is the Smith Street one in Cobble Hill, which a couple of commenters name. One commenter notes another in Brooklyn Heights, one says its extensive selection suits browsing, and another describes the atmosphere as good vibes.
- RecommendsNames this shop in a list of NYC bookstores. r/AskNYC, May 2024
4.Housing Works Bookstore Cafe, Soho
16 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn
Many people recommend Housing Works Bookstore Cafe for used books; the shop on the map is the Crosby Street one in SoHo, which several commenters name. One praises the used-book selection and the cafe for reading, another says it is hard to beat for old-fashioned bookshop atmosphere, and one reports consistently good luck finding books there. Two are less keen: one says it has declined somewhat but is still worth a visit, and another found fewer books and more branded merchandise.
Soho
- RecommendsThis visitor suggests this shop on Crosby Street as a used-book option. r/AskNYC, Aug 2025
- CaveatSays a visit showed fewer books and more branded merchandise, leaving them disappointed. r/Brooklyn, Feb 2026
5.Book Culture, Columbia
15 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/newyorkcity
People recommend Book Culture, which has several shops; the shop on the map is the West 112th Street one near Columbia, which commenters place there. One recommends the Upper West Side shop for academic books and another the Long Island City shop, one says the kids' section is good and another praises its selection. One commenter notes foreign-language books on an upper level at the Columbia shop.
Columbia
- RecommendsThis visitor lists the Book Culture shop at 112th as a used-book option. r/AskNYC, Aug 2025
6.Unnameable Books, Prospect Heights
15 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Brooklyn, r/AskNYC, r/nyc
Many people recommend Unnameable Books in Prospect Heights, and several praise its range of used books. One calls it the top choice for philosophy and critical theory, another names its book carts for varied browsing, and one calls it a good small, out-of-the-way shop. One commenter would not suggest it, finding it poorly organised.
Prospect Heights
- RecommendsSays the shop is not aimed at cheap books, yet has an excellent range of used books. r/Brooklyn, Oct 2024
- CaveatWould not suggest it, finding it poorly organised. r/nyc, Sep 2026
7.Bonnie Slotnick Cookbooks, East Village
10 people recommendvia r/AskNYC
Bonnie Slotnick Cookbooks is a cookbook shop that many people recommend for used, rare and out-of-print titles. Several suggest calling, emailing or visiting before going, and one says the shop helped them track down an out-of-print cookbook. One commenter calls it small and intimate, and another left without the cookbook they wanted but enjoyed the visit.
East Village
- RecommendsNotes the shop focuses on out-of-print cookbooks and advises getting in touch, since dealers can search in ways shoppers can't. r/AskNYC, Jan 2025
- MixedVisited in person; did not find the cookbook but enjoyed the visit and conversation. r/AskNYC, Jan 2025
8.Kinokuniya
9 people recommendvia r/AskNYC
Many people recommend Kinokuniya, and a few single out its manga, with one also naming imports and another anime and Asian-themed books. One commenter calls it a fun visit for books, manga and imports, and another lists it among midtown nerd spots.
- RecommendsA visitor lists Kinokuniya among midtown nerd spots worth checking out. r/AskNYC, Dec 2023
9.Bookoff, Midtown
9 people recommendvia r/AskNYC
Many people recommend Book Off, a used bookstore, and the shop on the map is the Midtown one on West 45th Street, which several commenters name. A couple say it is cheap, and one found plenty of good books there across genres.
Midtown
- RecommendsA visitor lists Book Off among midtown nerd spots worth checking out. r/AskNYC, Dec 2023
10.Argosy Book Store
8 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/FoodNYC, r/newyorkcity
Many people recommend Argosy Book Store on East 59th Street as a rare and antique book shop. A few mention its old maps, and one adds old prints and an upstairs gallery. One visitor calls it an old and rare book wonderland where they could wander for hours, and another calls it old school. One commenter says it mostly stocks pricey rare books, though cheaper finds exist, and still calls it worth a visit.
- RecommendsA visitor calls it the city's oldest independent bookstore, focused on scarce old volumes and antique cartography. r/AskNYC, Jan 2026
- MixedSays this shop mostly stocks pricey rare books, though cheaper finds exist there, and it is worth a visit. r/AskNYC, Feb 2025
11.Three Lives & Company, West Village
8 people recommendvia r/AskNYC
Many people recommend Three Lives & Company, a small independent bookshop in the West Village. A few say they love it or call it a favourite, and a couple praise its well-curated stock or collection. One commenter calls it a staple though small, and another calls it long-established and says it will order titles.
West Village
- RecommendsHighly recommends this small independent shop for its well curated stock, calling it one of their favorite city spots. r/AskNYC, Jan 2026
12.Mercer Street Books & Records, SoHo
8 people recommendvia r/AskNYC
Many people recommend Mercer Street Books & Records on Mercer Street in SoHo as a used bookstore. One says they regularly make a loop of bookshops that includes it, one says the stock keeps building up, and a couple name it among other used and antiquarian shops worth a visit.
SoHo
- RecommendsNames this shop as a suggestion, with no further comment. r/AskNYC, Jun 2025
13.Westsider Rare and Used Books, Broadway
8 people recommendvia r/AskNYC
Westsider is a secondhand bookshop on Broadway on the Upper West Side that many people recommend. A few name it as a place for used books, one recommends it for rare books and classics, and another calls it excellent and a good place to browse records.
Broadway
- RecommendsThis visitor lists Westsider on Broadway as a used-book option. r/AskNYC, Aug 2025
14.Sweet Pickle Books, Lower East Side
8 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn
Many people recommend Sweet Pickle Books on the Lower East Side, and a couple call it a favourite or a top-tier shop. A couple point to it as a used-book option, and one says it pairs books with pickles. One commenter is less impressed, calling the stock mostly castoffs.
Lower East Side
- RecommendsLists this shop among their favorite bookstores. r/AskNYC, Jun 2025
- CaveatThis visitor dismisses the shop as mostly castoffs with backwards curation. r/AskNYC, Oct 2026
15.Alabaster Books, East Village
7 people recommendvia r/AskNYC
Many people recommend Alabaster Books, a small used bookstore on Fourth Avenue around the corner from the Strand. One calls it charming, another praises its trade paperbacks, and one calls it a favourite. One commenter found it small but crowded.
East Village
- RecommendsThey describe this small used shop, set behind the Strand area and facing Fourth Avenue, as charming. r/AskNYC, Jan 2026
- MixedDescribes this shop as small but crowded, located around the block from the Strand. r/AskNYC, Dec 2024
16.Albertine Books, Upper East Side
7 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/FoodNYC, r/newyorkcity
Many people recommend Albertine Books on Fifth Avenue as a French-focused bookshop. Several mention its French-language books, a couple adding children's titles and a couple English books by French authors or translations, and a few call the space beautiful or stunning. One commenter notes a painted zodiac ceiling upstairs, and another calls it the prettiest option but says it mostly stocks French books.
Upper East Side
- RecommendsStrongly recommends this shop; says it sells French-language kids' and adult books plus English books by French authors. r/AskNYC, Nov 2023
- MixedCalls Albertine the prettiest option, but notes it mostly stocks French books. r/AskNYC, Dec 2024
17.Greenlight Bookstore
7 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn, r/nyc
Many people recommend Greenlight Bookstore, and the shop on the map is the Fort Greene one on Fulton Street, which commenters place there. A couple call it locally or independently owned, one recommends it for new books, and another calls the Fort Greene shop charming.
- RecommendsNames this shop in a list of NYC bookstores. r/AskNYC, May 2024
18.Codex Books, NoHo
7 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/FoodNYC
People recommend Codex Books at Bleecker Street and the Bowery as a used bookstore. A few name it among their used-book options, one praises its curation, and another lists it among shops stocking items hard to find elsewhere.
NoHo
- RecommendsThis visitor lists Codex on Bleeker as a used-book option. r/AskNYC, Aug 2025
19.The Book Cellar, Upper East Side
7 people recommendvia r/AskNYC
Commenters recommend The Book Cellar, a used-book shop in a library basement (the Webster branch on York Avenue) on the Upper East Side. One describes a strong range of titles in very good condition, some say it is cheap, and some advise checking the opening hours first.
Upper East Side
- RecommendsRecommends The Book Cellar and notes that a library sits on top of the shop. r/AskNYC, Jul 2025
20.Printed Matter
6 people recommendvia r/AskNYC
Printed Matter is an art bookstore in Chelsea that many people recommend. One says it has a very large range of art books, and another calls it a go-to for artist-made books and zines. One visitor finds its offbeat books on culture hard to beat but warns that mainstream titles are not stocked.
- RecommendsNames Printed Matter as a suggestion, with no further comment. r/AskNYC, Jun 2025
- MixedPraises the unusual artist-made selection but warns mainstream titles are missing. r/AskNYC, Jun 2025
21.Community Bookstore
6 people recommendvia r/Brooklyn, r/AskNYC, r/nyc
People recommend Community Bookstore in Park Slope, and a couple call it their go-to or favourite shop. One commenter describes it as the sister shop of Terrace and says it beats Terrace's newer location, and another recommends it as a locally owned place for new books.
- RecommendsRecommends this locally owned shop for new books. r/Brooklyn, Feb 2026
22.Mast Books, East Village
6 people recommendvia r/AskNYC
Many people recommend Mast Books, an art-focused bookshop in the East Village. One says its selection is well curated, and another includes it among small and intimate shops for a walking route. A couple suggest it when asked for art book cafes while noting it is not really a cafe.
East Village
- RecommendsLists this shop among those stocking items unavailable elsewhere. r/AskNYC, Jun 2025
23.Barnes & Noble, Union Square
6 people recommendvia r/AskNYC
A few people recommend the Barnes & Noble at Union Square outright, one saying they really like it. One says the store has pleasant spots to sit and read, one suggests the large store as a place to try for a specific book, advising calling ahead, and one guesses it is probably the top choice for sci-fi and fantasy, though not certain.
Union Square
- RecommendsSays they really like the Union Square outlet and lists it among their favorites. r/AskNYC, Jun 2025
24.Books of Wonder
6 people recommendvia r/AskNYC
Many people recommend Books of Wonder, a children's bookstore on West 17th Street near Union Square. One visitor says it is devoted entirely to children's books, with a broad selection that includes rare titles, and a few call it a great or fantastic children's shop.
- RecommendsRecommends Books of Wonder as a top children's bookshop and says it will ship to the Upper West Side. r/AskNYC, Sep 2025
25.Mysterious Bookshop
6 people recommendvia r/AskNYC
Many people recommend Mysterious Bookshop, a mystery and crime specialist in Tribeca, and a few point to it for readers of mystery and crime fiction. One commenter calls it charming and welcoming, another says it is a lovely place to come across books they had not set out to find, and one calls it a rare gem among the few niche bookstores.
- RecommendsRecommends it for mystery fans, calling it charming and welcoming. r/AskNYC, Jun 2025
26.The Drama Book Shop
6 people recommendvia r/AskNYC
Many people recommend The Drama Book Shop, a theatre-focused bookstore in midtown West. A few single it out for people into theatre, and one calls it one of a kind, unlike other bookstores they have visited. One commenter places it on West 38th or 39th Street.
- RecommendsA visitor suggests the Drama Bookshop as a midtown stop for theatre fans among nerdy spots. r/AskNYC, Dec 2023
27.Rizzoli, Flatiron
6 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskNYC
Many people recommend Rizzoli, and one calls the Flatiron shop excellent. Another praises its book collection and the music and events in its back room, and one calls it cool. One visitor who knew the old location says the newer one seems to be turning into a Barnes & Noble-style store.
Flatiron
- RecommendsCalls it great, praising its collection and the music and events in its back room. r/AskNYC, Jan 2026
- CaveatThis visitor says the new Rizzoli location seems to be turning into a Barnes & Noble-style store. r/AskNYC, Aug 2025
28.Kitchen Arts & Letters
6 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskNYC
Most people who name Kitchen Arts & Letters recommend it, a cookbook specialist on Lexington Avenue on the Upper East Side. One likes its food and drink history books beyond cookbooks, and a couple suggest asking the shop about out-of-print titles. One commenter says rare cookbooks there are priced high and suggests flea markets or less specialised shops instead.
- RecommendsSays this shop sometimes stocks some out-of-print titles and suggests asking it for help. r/AskNYC, Jan 2025
- CaveatSays rare cookbooks here are priced high and suggests trying flea markets and less specialised stores instead. r/AskNYC, Jan 2025
29.Aeon Books, Two Bridges
5 people recommendvia r/AskNYC
People recommend Aeon Books in the Two Bridges and Lower East Side area. One lists it among shops stocking items hard to find outside New York, one says they like it, and another describes it as small and intimate.
Two Bridges
- RecommendsLists this shop among those stocking items unavailable elsewhere. r/AskNYC, Jun 2025
30.Troubled Sleep, Park Slope
5 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn
People recommend Troubled Sleep, a used bookstore in Park Slope. One says they always find something there, with a selection from cheap finds to collectible books, a couple call it a good or amazing out-of-the-way shop, and one names its book carts for varied browsing.
Park Slope
- RecommendsCalls it an amazing used bookstore, out of the way. r/AskNYC, May 2025
31.Yu & Me Books, Chinatown
5 people recommendvia r/AskNYC
Several people recommend Yu & Me Books, and a few name it in lists of favourite or recommended New York bookstores. Two say they like it.
Chinatown
- RecommendsLists this shop among their favorite bookstores. r/AskNYC, Jun 2025
Questions people ask
- Which bookstores do New York locals recommend most?
- Right now the most-recommended are The Strand, McNally Jackson, SoHo and Books Are Magic, ranked by how many different people vouched for each one. Every place lists the reasons people gave and the caveats they raised, with a link to the original comment.
- How is this list made?
- It is built from public Reddit discussions — 210 comments from 196 people across r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn, r/nyc, r/FoodNYC and r/newyorkcity. We paraphrase why each place is recommended, keep the negatives and caveats in, and link to the original comment so you can read the source yourself. We never invent details.
- Are these paid placements?
- No. Nothing here is sponsored, paid or ranked by a business. Places are included only because real people recommended them in public conversations, and every claim links back to its source.
- How recent are these recommendations?
- This map was last refreshed November 16, 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time, so confirm current details directly before you rely on them.
Did this page answer your question?
More maps to explore
New York
Best fine dining
New York fine-dining recommendations, with diners' opinions on the food, setting and trade-offs.
Open the mapNew York
Thrift stores
New York thrift and secondhand shops, with the named branches, finds and disagreements in the source conversations.
Open the mapNew York
Best street food
New York carts, counters and street-food stops recommended in local conversations, with the specific locations and caveats.
Open the mapNew York
Best brunch
New York brunch recommendations, including pancake favorites and the queues diners warn about.
Open the mapNew York
Best cafés
New York cafés and coffee stops discussed for coffee, pastries and places to sit, with the source recommendations and mixed views.
Open the mapNew York
Best bars
New York bar recommendations, from dive bars and beer bars to cocktail lounges, with the original praise and caveats for each place.
Open the mapNew York
Best sushi
New York sushi and omakase recommendations, with cited opinions on the meals and the differences between locations.
Open the mapNew York
Best ramen
New York ramen recommendations, including Tonchin, Ramen Ishida and Okiboru, with cited opinions on bowls, noodles and broth.
Open the mapNew York
Best seafood
New York seafood recommendations, including oyster bars, mariscos and Thai seafood restaurants, with the original recommendations and reservations.
Open the mapNew York
Parks
New York parks recommended for walks, meadows and time outdoors, with cited suggestions for exploring them and caveats about crowds and upkeep.
Open the mapNew York
Best ice cream
New York ice cream shops discussed for their flavours, sundaes and texture, with the original recommendations and reservations about each place.
Open the mapNew York
Best burgers
Dry-aged tavern burgers and onion-forward smash burgers both attract loyal fans in New York. This map keeps the recommendations alongside disagreements over seasoning, consistency and value.
Open the mapNew York
Indian restaurants
South Indian dosas, Punjabi cooking and modern tasting menus draw different followings across New York. These recommendations retain disagreements over flavor, value and whether a meal merits the trip.
Open the mapNew York
Best steak
Porterhouse loyalties, dry-aged flavor and old-school dining rooms divide New York steak recommendations. This map keeps the enthusiasm alongside reports of disappointing seasoning, uneven doneness and meals that did not justify the premium.
Open the mapNew York
Museums
New York museums for art, natural history and city transport, with visitor recommendations and caveats.
Open the mapNew York
Best pizza
New York pizza places, from neighbourhood slice shops to sit-down pizzerias, with recommendations and disagreements from Reddit and X.
Open the mapNew York
Best breakfast
New York breakfast spots discussed for bagels, pancakes and egg sandwiches, with outlet context, queues and disagreements kept alongside the recommendations.
Open the mapNew York
Best restaurants
Where New Yorkers send people to eat: Katz's pastrami, al pastor at Los Tacos No. 1, the mutton chop at Keens, slices at Joe's and L'Industrie, and Italian sandwiches from Defonte's to All'Antico Vinaio. Katz's prices and Joe's reputation get plenty of pushback too.
Open the mapNew York
Places to visit
Where New Yorkers send friends: the Met, Central Park, and quiet walks with skyline views at Green-Wood Cemetery. Many also point to the Bronx Zoo and the Botanical Garden side by side, and to museums they call underrated, like the Cloisters, the Museum of the City of New York and the Museum of the Moving Image.
Open the map