Thrift stores in New York
21 thrift stores that New York locals recommend — the real reasons, and the caveats.
New York thrift and secondhand shops, with the named branches, finds and disagreements in the source conversations.
Drawn from real discussions in r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn, r/VintageFashion, r/thrifting and r/nyc — 21 thrift stores in New York that people actually recommend. Each one shows why people rate it, the caveats they raised, and a link straight to the original comment — so you read the source yourself instead of trusting a laundered rating. Places cluster around Bushwick, Williamsburg, Atlantic Avenue and Chelsea.
How this map is made: Built from 226 Reddit comments across 206 people in r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn, r/VintageFashion, r/thrifting and r/nyc. Last refreshed November 17, 2026. We paraphrase — never copy — and never take payment for a place. How we make our maps
Showing 21 places
Filters
Map
The map and place list use the same cited directory records. Every public entry has a stable Maps We Made ID and geopoint.
Places
1.L Train Vintage, Bushwick
51 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/AskNYC, r/nyc, r/Brooklyn
People recommend the L Train Vintage shops in Bushwick, Gowanus, Crown Heights and Manhattan; the address given is the Bushwick one. Most people recommend it, and many customers call its prices reasonable or budget-friendly, with one customer finding the pants and sweaters especially well priced. Many people point to the Bushwick shops, and two customers bought leather jackets at L Train shops. The downsides are that a few people find some items pricey or overpriced, and one person feels the shop is overhyped.
Bushwick
- RecommendsCustomer rates L Train positively and says its Urban Jungle branch often turns up finds. r/AskNYC, Jan 2024
- CaveatDescribes L train vintage as usually overpriced, unlike the cheaper Queens options listed. r/AskNYC, Jun 2026
2.Housing Works, Chelsea
48 people recommend, 7 warn against itvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn, r/VintageFashion
People recommend the Housing Works shops across the city; the address given is the Chelsea one. One customer calls the Chelsea shop good for men's suits and sports coats, another says the stores often carry sturdy wooden furniture, and a third has had success finding things at Housing Works. One commenter suggests the SoHo shop while noting that branches may vary. One commenter says what you find depends on the day, and one says higher prices are fine because they support the charity. Two commenters are less keen: one says it is often overpriced, and one says it lacks real bargains.
Chelsea
- RecommendsSays charity chains are generally poor, but has had success finding things at Housing Works. r/AskNYC, Jun 2026
- CaveatSays it is often overpriced and aimed at wealthier shoppers who treat thrifting as a hobby. r/AskNYC, Dec 2023
3.Beacon's Closet, Park Slope
27 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn, r/VintageFashion
People recommend the Beacon's Closet shops across the city; the address given is the Park Slope one, which one commenter names as near Barclays Center. Many people recommend Beacon's Closet and mention it alongside other secondhand shops nearby. Several commenters are less enthusiastic: one shopper recalls a strong past find but judges the stock weaker than it was, one plus-size shopper finds it almost always poor for larger sizes, one says it has declined over the years, and one says it costs more than the best-value shops.
Park Slope
- RecommendsSuggests this thrift store to the niece; commenter enjoyed it as a teenager about two decades ago. r/AskNYC, Sep 2024
- CaveatSays it is almost always poor for plus sizes, though they got lucky a few times. r/AskNYC, Jun 2026
4.Big Reuse, Gowanus
19 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Brooklyn, r/AskNYC
People recommend Big Reuse; the address given is the Gowanus shop, and commenters mention a second location in Bushwick. Several commenters say it stocks used furniture, others mention housewares and decor, one commenter calls it a good swap from big charity shops, and a couple call its items reasonably priced. One commenter calls it a rip-off.
Gowanus
- RecommendsRecommended to someone who likes secondhand stores and antiques; the commenter gives its location off Hamilton Avenue. r/Brooklyn, Mar 2025
- CaveatCalls the place a rip-off, suggesting poor value for the money. r/Brooklyn, Mar 2024
5.Urban Jungle, Bushwick
18 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn, r/VintageFashion
People recommend the Urban Jungle shops in Bushwick; the address given is the Bushwick one. Most people recommend it, and several describe the Bushwick shop as budget-friendly. A few people describe it as large, and one visitor came home with several fur coats. Two people say it takes patience, and one of them says it isn't cheap.
Bushwick
- RecommendsCustomer calls Urban Jungle in Bushwick the lowest-priced real thrift store. r/AskNYC, Aug 2026
- MixedIncludes this Brooklyn shop among favorites, while noting it takes patience to find things. r/Brooklyn, Nov 2025
6.Goodwill, Chelsea
17 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn
People recommend Goodwill shops around the city; the address given is the Chelsea one. One commenter calls the Chelsea Goodwill fairly good and says they found high-end pieces there at low cost, and another says it has plenty of men's jeans. Other commenters name different Goodwill shops, including Downtown Brooklyn, First Avenue on the Upper East Side, Boerum Hill and the Long Island City bin outlet.
Chelsea
- RecommendsCustomer calls Goodwill bins in Sunnyside the best value, though the trip is a hassle and results are inconsistent. r/AskNYC, Aug 2026
- MixedSays the bins can yield cheap finds for those who arrive early and handle heavy competition; not suited to everyone. r/AskNYC, May 2024
7.2nd Street, NoHo
13 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn
People recommend the 2nd Street shops; the address given is the NoHo one. One commenter calls it a personal favorite with a solid men's range that leans slightly streetwear, another finds better menswear here than at Beacon's Closet, and another praises its international and Japanese labels. One commenter suggests pairing the NoHo shop with the Union Square one since the two are close. Two commenters find it pricey, one visitor found limited stock, and one commenter personally avoids it.
NoHo
- RecommendsEndorses visiting secondhand shops and names this as one of several chains. r/AskNYC, Sep 2024
- CaveatCustomer finds Second Street's Manhattan locations overpriced. r/AskNYC, Jan 2024
8.Out of the Closet, Atlantic Avenue
12 people recommendvia r/Brooklyn, r/AskNYC
People recommend the Out of the Closet thrift shops; the address given is the Atlantic Avenue one in Brooklyn. Many people recommend it, and one visitor calls it very good. Two customers point to its furniture, one noting the downstairs area gets less foot traffic than the main floor, and another customer buys silverware there and finds it budget-friendly since items can be bought one at a time. One visitor says the shop has a few worthwhile finds.
Atlantic Avenue
- RecommendsNames this as among the best thrift options they've personally found in the Williamsburg to Crown Heights stretch. r/Brooklyn, Dec 2023
9.Other People's Clothes, Bushwick
10 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn
People recommend the Other People's Clothes shops; the address given is the Bushwick one. One customer praises its wide selection and pleasant feel, and another calls it a curated vintage shop. A couple of commenters find it affordable. Others are more reserved: one says it costs more than the best-value shops nearby, another says it may feel too trendy, and a third says the plus-size racks are reliable but limited.
Bushwick
- RecommendsCustomer adds Other People's Clothes as another suggested shop. r/AskNYC, Jan 2024
- MixedSays it has strong finds but is costlier than the best-value options. r/AskNYC, Feb 2025
10.Stella Dallas, Williamsburg
10 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn, r/VintageFashion
Stella Dallas has more than one Williamsburg shop, and the address given is Stella Dallas Living, the vintage textiles shop. Many people recommend Stella Dallas in Williamsburg. A few commenters point to the Living shop's vintage textiles and older pieces. Separately, one commenter recommends Stella Dallas as the first place to try for a leather jacket, another for men's clothing, and one calls it unmatched, without saying which shop they mean. One commenter says it isn't extremely pricey, though it costs more than some alternatives.
Williamsburg
- RecommendsSuggests Stella Dallas as the answer, saying the kind of shop being asked about has largely disappeared. r/AskNYC, Feb 2024
11.Salvation Army, Atlantic Avenue
10 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn
People recommend Salvation Army thrift stores around the city; the address given is the Atlantic Avenue one across from Out of the Closet, and commenters also name shops in Woodside, Hell's Kitchen, Maspeth, Chelsea and Nostrand Avenue. One commenter says the Atlantic Avenue shop is inexpensive, and another says it has plenty of furniture and goods downstairs. Others are less keen: two commenters say shops on 46th and 23rd Streets rarely have much worth buying, one finds the Atlantic Avenue shop's housewares selection thin, and one says it takes digging.
Atlantic Avenue
- RecommendsCustomer suggests the Salvation Army across the street as the next stop after Out of the Closet. r/Brooklyn, Nov 2024
- CaveatCalls the nearest Salvation Army on 46th gloomy and limited, and advises against going. r/AskNYC, Jun 2025
12.Mother of Junk, Williamsburg
8 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn
People recommend Mother of Junk, a vintage shop; the address given is the Williamsburg one, and one commenter names a Woodside shop. Most commenters recommend it as a thrift stop. One commenter says the Williamsburg shop has a very large quantity of furniture, and one customer has had luck there and suggests it for dishes and cups. A customer who used to live nearby says the more unusual finds in Williamsburg are not inexpensive.
Williamsburg
- RecommendsSuggests this Williamsburg shop as a place to try for the old paper materials being sought. r/AskNYC, Jul 2024
- MixedUsed to pass time there while living nearby, but says its more unusual finds are not inexpensive. r/AskNYC, Feb 2024
13.Life Boutique, Park Slope
8 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn
People recommend Life Boutique Thrift, also called Life Vintage and Thrift, which has two Park Slope stores; the address given is the one on 5th Avenue. Many commenters recommend it. One customer says it has many cheap items, and another found a vintage formal dress there and says the shop has a lot of formalwear. One commenter describes the stock as quite random, and one customer found the curated top floor had pricey pieces, though they still felt they were fairly priced.
Park Slope
- RecommendsSays Life Vintage and Thrift's two Park Slope stores have many cheap items. r/AskNYC, Aug 2026
- MixedNotes the curated upper floor has items above their budget, yet still sees them as fairly priced. r/Brooklyn, Jun 2025
14.HEE-space Thrift, Flatbush
8 people recommendvia r/Brooklyn, r/AskNYC
Many people recommend HEE-space Thrift, a secondhand shop on Rogers Avenue near Lincoln Road in Flatbush and Prospect Lefferts Gardens. Two customers say they find standout pieces here at low prices. One customer describes the shop as a tiny spot, and one commenter calls it locally owned.
Flatbush
- RecommendsCalls a thrift shop at that Rogers Ave corner excellent and tells the asker to look it up. r/Brooklyn, Dec 2023
15.Le Point Value, Bushwick
7 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn
People recommend Le Point Value; commenters name the Bushwick shop and one on Rogers Avenue in Flatbush, and the address given is the Bushwick one. Several people recommend it as a thrift stop, and a few describe its prices as budget-friendly. In Bushwick, one commenter says it has reasonable finds for patient searchers though it isn't cheap, and another says the shoes and bags often offer good value while the clothing is priced oddly. One commenter says the clothes are disorganized and there are no dressing rooms, while another says there is little trendy stock.
Bushwick
- RecommendsCustomer adds Le Point as another suggested shop. r/AskNYC, Jan 2024
- MixedCustomer says Le Point's clothing is priced strangely, but its shoes and bags are often good value. r/AskNYC, Aug 2026
16.Remix Market, Long Island City
7 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn
People recommend the Remix Market shops; the address given is the Long Island City one, and commenters also mention Brooklyn, Williamsburg and Queens shops. Several commenters name the Long Island City shop. One customer says its stock comes from haulers and its prices are usually decent, another says it has decent furniture but some high-end pieces stay pricey, and a third says delivery is available.
Long Island City
- RecommendsNames Remix Market in LIC as a place to buy furniture. r/AskNYC, Dec 2025
- MixedSays it has decent furniture, though some pieces are high-end and stay pricey. r/AskNYC, May 2025
17.Bedford Galleries, Bed Stuy
7 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn
Bedford Galleries is a vintage furniture shop in Bed-Stuy, and many people recommend it. One person says it carries vintage and refurbished pieces, another calls the shop well curated, and one customer has bought chairs, mirrors and cedar chests there. A couple of people call the prices reasonable. One person says that for more variety, you would need to look further west along Atlantic Avenue.
Bed Stuy
- RecommendsSays it has good vintage and refurbished pieces, fairly priced for the quality, and offers delivery and assembly. r/AskNYC, Dec 2025
18.Gentlemen's Resale, Upper East Side
7 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskNYC
Several people recommend Gentlemen's Resale, a consignment shop on the Upper East Side, with two naming it for menswear. One customer who bought a suit there for a wedding describes it as a consignment shop rather than a thrift store, and had a tailor adjust the fit. One commenter describing a cluster of designer-focused shops on East 81st Street that includes this one says the group can be a little pricey but has good variety. One commenter says it has declined sharply.
Upper East Side
- RecommendsSuggests Gentlemen's Resale on the Upper East Side as a menswear option. r/AskNYC, May 2025
- CaveatSays this shop has declined sharply. r/AskNYC, May 2025
19.MyUnique Thrift, Bronx
7 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskNYC
People recommend the MyUnique Thrift shops; the address given is the Bronx one. Several customers rate the Bronx shop positively, and one found a distinctive coat there. One commenter calls the chain the cheapest option in the city.
Bronx
- RecommendsSays this resale shop, with Bronx and Queens locations, is the cheapest option in the city. r/AskNYC, Aug 2024
- CaveatStopped going to Unique Thrift after past visits found little quality and prices seemed high. r/AskNYC, May 2026
20.Domsey Express, Bushwick
5 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn
People recommend Domsey's, which has more than one outlet; commenters place it in Bushwick, and the address given is Domsey Express IV. Several people suggest it when asked for thrift spots, and one commenter calls the Bushwick shop great.
Bushwick
- RecommendsCustomer suggests Domsey Express as an extra option, depending on what shoppers want. r/AskNYC, Jan 2024
21.Plus BKLYN, Williamsburg
5 people recommendvia r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn
Plus BKLYN is a secondhand shop focused on plus sizes, and several people recommend it for finding larger-size clothing. Two commenters name the Williamsburg location, while another says it has leaned toward women's clothing.
Williamsburg
- RecommendsNames Plus BKLYN in Williamsburg as a place to find plus sizes, noting few local stores carry them. r/AskNYC, Jun 2026
Questions people ask
- Which thrift stores do New York locals recommend most?
- Right now the most-recommended are L Train Vintage, Bushwick, Housing Works, Chelsea and Beacon's Closet, Park Slope, ranked by how many different people vouched for each one. Every place lists the reasons people gave and the caveats they raised, with a link to the original comment.
- How is this list made?
- It is built from public Reddit discussions — 226 comments from 206 people across r/AskNYC, r/Brooklyn, r/VintageFashion, r/thrifting and r/nyc. We paraphrase why each place is recommended, keep the negatives and caveats in, and link to the original comment so you can read the source yourself. We never invent details.
- Are these paid placements?
- No. Nothing here is sponsored, paid or ranked by a business. Places are included only because real people recommended them in public conversations, and every claim links back to its source.
- How recent are these recommendations?
- This map was last refreshed November 17, 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time, so confirm current details directly before you rely on them.
Did this page answer your question?
More maps to explore
New York
Best fine dining
New York fine-dining recommendations, with diners' opinions on the food, setting and trade-offs.
Open the mapNew York
Best street food
New York carts, counters and street-food stops recommended in local conversations, with the specific locations and caveats.
Open the mapNew York
Best brunch
New York brunch recommendations, including pancake favorites and the queues diners warn about.
Open the mapNew York
Bookstores
New York bookshops recommended for browsing, used books and particular selections, with individual branches kept distinct.
Open the mapNew York
Best cafés
New York cafés and coffee stops discussed for coffee, pastries and places to sit, with the source recommendations and mixed views.
Open the mapNew York
Best bars
New York bar recommendations, from dive bars and beer bars to cocktail lounges, with the original praise and caveats for each place.
Open the mapNew York
Best sushi
New York sushi and omakase recommendations, with cited opinions on the meals and the differences between locations.
Open the mapNew York
Best ramen
New York ramen recommendations, including Tonchin, Ramen Ishida and Okiboru, with cited opinions on bowls, noodles and broth.
Open the mapNew York
Best seafood
New York seafood recommendations, including oyster bars, mariscos and Thai seafood restaurants, with the original recommendations and reservations.
Open the mapNew York
Parks
New York parks recommended for walks, meadows and time outdoors, with cited suggestions for exploring them and caveats about crowds and upkeep.
Open the mapNew York
Best ice cream
New York ice cream shops discussed for their flavours, sundaes and texture, with the original recommendations and reservations about each place.
Open the mapNew York
Best burgers
Dry-aged tavern burgers and onion-forward smash burgers both attract loyal fans in New York. This map keeps the recommendations alongside disagreements over seasoning, consistency and value.
Open the mapNew York
Indian restaurants
South Indian dosas, Punjabi cooking and modern tasting menus draw different followings across New York. These recommendations retain disagreements over flavor, value and whether a meal merits the trip.
Open the mapNew York
Best steak
Porterhouse loyalties, dry-aged flavor and old-school dining rooms divide New York steak recommendations. This map keeps the enthusiasm alongside reports of disappointing seasoning, uneven doneness and meals that did not justify the premium.
Open the mapNew York
Museums
New York museums for art, natural history and city transport, with visitor recommendations and caveats.
Open the mapNew York
Best pizza
New York pizza places, from neighbourhood slice shops to sit-down pizzerias, with recommendations and disagreements from Reddit and X.
Open the mapNew York
Best breakfast
New York breakfast spots discussed for bagels, pancakes and egg sandwiches, with outlet context, queues and disagreements kept alongside the recommendations.
Open the mapNew York
Best restaurants
Where New Yorkers send people to eat: Katz's pastrami, al pastor at Los Tacos No. 1, the mutton chop at Keens, slices at Joe's and L'Industrie, and Italian sandwiches from Defonte's to All'Antico Vinaio. Katz's prices and Joe's reputation get plenty of pushback too.
Open the mapNew York
Places to visit
Where New Yorkers send friends: the Met, Central Park, and quiet walks with skyline views at Green-Wood Cemetery. Many also point to the Bronx Zoo and the Botanical Garden side by side, and to museums they call underrated, like the Cloisters, the Museum of the City of New York and the Museum of the Moving Image.
Open the map